Are we being hypocrites?

Salman should not have been treated in that way - he is just a kid - not some grown up fully trained singer. Alka should of explained that to the judges then Kailash would not have had to do what he did. Mithun handles his show better.

Originally posted by: sajeet

When Ram Sampat Criticized Niladri, all hell broke loose on him.

He was accused of being unfair, harsh, "a friend" of kailash kher, etc etc

while Pyarelaal ridiculed Salman, by asking him to sing in a different scale and then cutting him off a few times and interjecting his song, we did not mind at all. In fact we are all praises him.

Just because Kailash has had a bad attitude on the sets from day one, we are overlooking some good things he said during the last episode!

Do we always judge actions based on who is doing it, rather than judging people by what action they do?

Is that fair?

Originally posted by: Westwick

This is not an excuse that they are childred. If they are not told about there faults now thet will never learn. If they are not singing well they must be told so. By unnecessary praise they will spoil their career. Both Ram & Pyarelalji were correct in telling where they went wrong. By not telling what they are you are being hypocrite.

Originally posted by: Westwick

This is not an excuse that they are children. If they are not told about there faults now thet will never learn. If they are not singing well they must be told so. By unnecessary praise they will spoil their career. Both Ram & Pyarelalji were correct in telling where they went wrong. By not telling what they are you are being hypocrite.