Krishna - Arjun vs. RaDev - Barkha

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Shankar

@-Shankar-

Inactive

+ 4

Posted: 14 years ago

#11

and we are saying that barkha is getting all the lines, well aren't we giving her so much attention?

Quote

Radhe101

@Radhe101

Rocker

Posted: 14 years ago

#12

Anu good theory of Krishna and RaDev...The Bhagvad Geeta was based on Arjun's refusal to lift weapon against Bhisma Pita, his Guru, and his cousins in Kuruchetra. Arjun couldn't decide if it was okay for him to fight his own people That's when Krishna show his mighty avatar to Arjun and narrate the entire geeta. He also said to Arjun that people who support lies or adharma are as much guilty as the one who commited the sin. the mahabharat wouldn't exist if Arjun raised question against his eldest brother during the gambling and vastraharan of Draupadi or Bhisma Pita and Guru Dronacharya stopped the Duryodhan for conspiring against pandava. Krishna does come to help his devotee if they are really helpless like Draupadi was during vastraharan.In this case, Radhika and Dev were not helpless but confused to fight against the elders like Daimaa and Dadaji. Radhika needed someone to explain to her the dharma, Kartavya, and her karma for his first marriage and society. we didn't see divine intervention of Kanha instead we had to deal with Barkha's lies to Radhika, Dev, and Dadaji. well Kanha stopped the adharma through barkha but it's high time that Radhika understand her Dharma otherwise we are up for Mahabharat and Ramayan combined in CB Land. I feel Radhika, Dev, Dadaji, and Barkha are responsible for this mess but again who am I to judge...The Mahabharata and Krishna concept is very complex and comparing cb is not worthed. CB doesn't even come close to Krishna's concept...It's sad that every single Indian soap use the name of God for the monetary gain. I am getting headache from the twist and turns of Choti bahu.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

premvahini

@premvahini

Inactive

Posted: 14 years ago

#13

As per me its Radhika 's character that does things without thinking or thinking through the consequences . I get the feeling she is not even clear/ sure what she wants .

She entered Purohit Bhavan as Rohan's wife ------ what was she thinking/ or not thinking !? According to me , that was the dumbest part of the show till then she was trying to tell Dev that Kanha does not want Rohan and Radhika's wedding to happen & she was saved by the fire accident from getting married to him ---- that was her chance to tell Dev as well as others about the sancitity of her beleif in the childhood play / marriage . Kanha had given her a chance to tell her father as well as others about it . And , she just does the stupidiest thing of entering as Rohan's wife ------ she did that for pure selfish reasons --- to prove I don't know what to Dev !! Did not think about Purohit family pride / status or her own family status . The child hood play was marriage to her ----- and 6 phera 's with rohan and enetering as his wife was a juat a game to her .

If she can lie like that --- who can trust her in what she does next. Now also she is not thinking about Dev or Barka but wants to project that she is great / she is sacrificing so that her name remains in good books and she is not pointed out as dada ji's killer etc, etc.

Dev does not care for RP ship , he is doing what he has firm belief in and so is Barkha, wheas Radhika does not know what she wants, Ifeel she is just savinf her face nad name. We can say she is doing it for Dev, Dev is an adult he knows what he wants --- she should not be deciding things for him.

The whole thing started with her lie and she wants to lie further by asking Barkha to do muhn dikhai ------ what kind of Dharma path is this which is based on lie ---- to hide one lie keep creating more lies .

Truth is the first Dharma ----- if for truth you have to loose everything ---- rajpurohiti --- your kith and kins should be O.K.

What RP and Radhika are doing is not Dharma but they are just trying to please the Samaj ( Society) and maintain their false status in samaj .

Dharma---- would be to accept the follies that have been made and tell the truth and fight for right .

Howcome Daddaji has not learnt from his past mistakes --- he is commtting same Adarma again ----- I hope Mathadhish comes to know about it and should favor Dev/ Radhika's truth and bash RP for his past and current adharmic deeds.

Quote

Devika.

@Devika.

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#14

coming to the MB battle and CB.. Anu, i always loved reading your post .. it was really brushing those memory back , or sometimes a new door for me to learn things... and coming to this post.. bit surprised me.. but yet.. here is my 2 cents..

MB battle: Arjun was fighting because it was his battle, yes i agree with you..

he faced his own adorable elders and gurus in the name of it, as Krishna stood as a shield, who might have never taken His weapon physically out, but surely used His wise advice (His words) to bring Arjun to get into the battle , to lift that weapon against his will in the name of Karm, Krishna controlled the five elements to bring victory to His parth, for that HE doesn't need that weapon... He did buy that time to give the best advice which ended in 18 parts..

Coming to CB: everybody is questinong Berkha's role. why she is shouting and making those moves. as you said she is not Krishna, she is just a human, who cannot control the Sun or the cloud, who can just spill those words to bring her friend back into her karm. she is trusting Dev and his ability that he can fight with the society.. she mentioned that manyt imes saying "now Dev will handle the situation" ...and telling her friend Radhika that she needs to rise above duty, maybe from that remorseful state to see it how much Dev need her, who is standing alone, who is the real victim of this all dharm adharm talk. to bring justice to chayya and her lost kid, to bring justice to Padma ... because radhika is blind now, she is acting and taking steps with the spark of that moment, who cannot see anyone siffering because of her.

Radhika is ready to leave the battle of getting her KK, her viswas..., to her family, his loved ones, for their honor... and more than karm it is her extream love for him, bringing that honor for his family is more than fighting with the weapon.

Yes, Berkha is not Krishna or above Him, but just a simple human being, just a friend...

Devika

Edited by Devika. - 14 years ago

Quote

Devika.

@Devika.

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#15

Originally posted by: -Shankar-

Krishna had once said (I think, not so sure, correct me if I am wrong) that if a lie can save a life it is better than a 1000 truths. Barkha saved her life, Dev's life, and Rad's life (even though she lost DDji's life in the process)

You are right Shankar.. i heard of it too many times ...also there is another saying "if the truth can give pain/hurt anyone, then don't say it...

nice post...

Edited by Devika. - 14 years ago

Quote

?married with 2 kids

@chayya55

Rocker

Posted: 14 years ago

#16

well put premv

you know how to explain in words much better than me and like someone else said these twists and turns are so unrealistic why did radhika listen to dev and agreed to marry rohan she could have refused and gone away(so many twists and turns could have happenned this way) and try to persuade dev some other way about the child hood marraige at that time dev was cosidered an anaath so he was under certain obligations to the prohits --she did not have any obligations to the prohits

and todays episode here radhika is again trying to be mahan(barkha is refusing to marry dev and she is saying the truth about what the old man did to devs parents and she stops barka ) and why listen to the old man he is pagal all he wants is what the samage will think of him(and this for all those who say she is doing this for dev--what utter nonsence)she is doing this for the old man only when she knows dev does not want to be rajprohit he just wants radhika-so what happened to listening to your pati--balo radshika--you are making him feel low --so you can be mahan

little by little all the symapthies for radhika are going going------

guys pls no chappel throwing inspite of all this still love choti bahu watch it only for avina

Quote

neerjashingla

@Neerjaa

Sparkler

Posted: 14 years ago

#17

Originally posted by: -Shankar-
I mostly agree but strongly disagree that Barkha is completely wrong.

Dont hit me with ur chappals! 🤣

If Barkha had refused to marry Dev:
DDji would have found any 'fit' suitor for Dev and do the shaddi.

Is Barkha married Dev:
Well, she would have been married to Dev, not radhika.

Krishna had once said (I think, not so sure, correct me if I am wrong) that if a lie can save a life it is better than a 1000 truths. Barkha saved her life, Dev's life, and Rad's life (even though she lost DDji's life in the process)

Barkha is not at full fault. Her and RaDev share equal blame. Barkha was right. If Dev was truly in love w/ Rad, he would have moved heaven n' earth to get her but no, he waited for Rad to give her consent. Now, i think he realized his mistake because he said he was glad Barkha lied and got RaDev married. So we should not blame Barkha here. If she were not in the story, RaDev would still be running from Rohan. So please, show some gratitude for the person who saved Dev and got RaDev married.

yada yada hi dharmasya
glanir bhavati bharata
abhyutthanam adharmasya
tadatmanam srjamy aham

whenever there is a decline in dharma, then God will come in some form.
Well, Kanha came as Barkha. I agree that Barkha isn't God and shouldn't pretend she is but God helps those who help themselves. And since radev were not helping themselves, barkha lent a helping hand to retain, as the Buddha would say, "dharma"

Shankar i agree with you , i am not against Barkha ,yes impulsive she is , but has good intentions ...Whatever you have written , i have written so many times ...She cares for her friend , wants to see her happy , in the ME last scene when she was hiding behind the pillar and marriage was completed , she had the real happiness as if some great burden have been lifted ...I do not think Radhika would have married Dev as she has strong character ...I think in our daily life we hear this kind of words that God comes to help you in some form when we need him ...Here fault lies with Creatives , they did not executed the whole episode with logic , just turned Barkha in to God , who single handed did all this and was running from here to there as if was on skates ...

Quote

ekta15

@ekta15

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#18

well said anu
its radev's fight,she should not interfere so much,she is friend and shouldn't cross the limits
today rads cleared to her that she has not given right to take decision on her behalf.

Quote

1 2

Krishna

Krishna - Arjun vs. RaDev - Barkha - Page 2

Related Topics

Explore Topics