TV refuses to forget memory loss-TOI

divya0011 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
TV refuses to forget memory loss



Inki yaaddasht kho chuki hai..." While this was a common plot in movies from the 70s and 80s, where the protagonist would lose his/her memory courtesy a car/plane crash, it is now frequently used on the small screen. The formula of memory loss, currently seen in " Sasuraal Genda Phool", "Sanjog Se Bani Sangini", " Chhoti Bahu", " Pyar Ki Ek Kahani", and a little while ago, in "Pavitra Rishta", confirms that the hit-on-the-head hasn't lost significance. Arrey, actor ko nai life mil jaati hai na!

Laments Priya Kaur, a DU student, "It is a done-to-death concept. Agar koi show nahin dekh raha toh kuch aisa kar do jo logon ne expect nahin kiya hoga. Why can't they dare to think out of the box? Is it that tough? Ishaan's partial memory loss in "Sasural Genda Phool" which makes him forget only his wife is too weird. But people still watch the show and its TRPs remain unaffected."

Irrespective of how the viewers perceive it, for the scriptwriters, the idea of the actor looking clueless for months, and parents going berserk praying hard for their daughter/son's speedy recovery comes across as a reliable formula, what with broadcasters frequently threatening to axe shows. "Every show begins with an original story. Clichs like memory loss, baarish main phasa hua couple or someone meeting an accident are incorporated when the show has nothing gripping to offer. When interesting ideas get exhausted (usually by the 200th episode) is when showmakers resort to such formulas," says S Farhan, scriptwriter, "Sabki Ladli Bebo". As he tells us, he used the same storyline in "Sab Ki Ladli Bebo" and will think of using it again in the ongoing "Beendh Banunga Ghodi Chadhunga", if he feels the need.

While many think of it as something that is forced on the viewers, what comes next is always blissful, at least for the characters. Ishaan's partial memory loss has enabled his wife Suhana to strengthen their bond. Similarly, docile bahu Archana and monster-in-law, ooops, we mean, mother-in-law Savita in "Pavitra Rishta" succeeded in sorting out their differences while the latter struggled with bouts of memory black-outs.

"This concept may have been shown earlier too, but it has never been dealt with in such a light-hearted way, as was done in "Sasuraal Genda Phool". We don't make the viewers cry, even though Ishaan is suffering from amnesia. The key goal is to iron out the differences," says Suhana aka Ragini Khanna.

While Ishaan regaining his memory hasn't been confirmed yet, Rudra aka Iqbal Khan in "Sanjog Se Bani Sangini" tells us that he'll recover his soon. He says, "The phase when I played the character suffering from amnesia was great! I've always been fascinated by films from the 80s when memory loss was common. I think it
is the easiest role for an actor to perform." And also easy for broadcasters to ensure TRPs don't dip, eh?

Edited by divya0011 - 14 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

15

Views

2.1k

Users

9

Likes

54

Frequent Posters

428419 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: divya0011


Every show begins with an original story. Clichs like memory loss, baarish main phasa hua couple or someone meeting an accident are incorporated when the show has nothing gripping to offer. When interesting ideas get exhausted (usually by the 200th episode) is when showmakers resort to such formulas,"



Suhana starting to work with the Kahsyaps.. launching any business-Ishaan and Suhana thinking of helping in the finances of the family-Bade Papa returning-Rajni's beautiful track-Suhana realizing that just by saying 'I LOVE ISHAAN' standing on the bed is not called REALIZATION of true love-Inder confronting Bade papa once he comes back-Disha and Elesh's baby-The Kashyaps going to the tour they had decided before-Sanju-Deepak's track-KK's marriage incomplete track-Suhana trying to become a mom-Ishaan trying to become a man from a boy..etc etc etc...

Arent these enough to pull the show for the next three-four months?😕and with flashbacks,song sequences,etc...pull it to 5 months..

Why did they had to resort to this Amnesia track?..i am not saying this track is faltu..it is a wayyy lot better than the Cancer track...it has light heartedness etc etc...but flirting=solution to regain Ishaan's memory loss?😕...and though this track is handled differently..but sorry...the whole flirting is becoming very monotonous...

Shwets1502 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#3
i can say...no one knows what to do now...the useless doc has said..yaadhasth will come naturally...and suhana cant be without Ishaan...so she is doing whatever she did before...only that that Ishaan liked and this Ishaan is running for his life...

anyways...this track is not making us think...its going way better than i thought...

and shounak...the tracks u said...is more than enuf to run for a year and more...😆 hope we get to see those tracks...as there will be new tracks coming up...like BP track is coming...
428419 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Shwets1502



and shounak...the tracks u said...is more than enuf to run for a year and more...😆 hope we get to see those tracks...as there will be new tracks coming up...like BP track is coming...



Ohh yeah..i forgot its STAR Plus😆so ek saal ke liye toh chalega for sure...😉btw i found some traces of Rajni's track in Rano's brother..like how he doesnt care about his mom etc..Rajni's track was also somewhat like that.
Shwets1502 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: .sb.



Ohh yeah..i forgot its STAR Plus😆so ek saal ke liye toh chalega for sure...😉btw i found some traces of Rajni's track in Rano's brother..like how he doesnt care about his mom etc..Rajni's track was also somewhat like that.


i thought they could have extended that part for atleast a scene more...that was a very important thing thats actually happening in life...just one scene for that...
may be they will bring back rajini's track, ishika track along with deepak-sanju track...

iam waiting for the scene when deepak and sanju know who they are...and the families know abt them...knowing kashyaps and bajpais...it will be fun..😆
sree_24 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: .sb.



Suhana starting to work with the Kahsyaps.. launching any business-Ishaan and Suhana thinking of helping in the finances of the family-Bade Papa returning-Rajni's beautiful track-Suhana realizing that just by saying 'I LOVE ISHAAN' standing on the bed is not called REALIZATION of true love-Inder confronting Bade papa once he comes back-Disha and Elesh's baby-The Kashyaps going to the tour they had decided before-Sanju-Deepak's track-KK's marriage incomplete track-Suhana trying to become a mom-Ishaan trying to become a man from a boy..etc etc etc...

Arent these enough to pull the show for the next three-four months?😕and with flashbacks,song sequences,etc...pull it to 5 months..

Why did they had to resort to this Amnesia track?..i am not saying this track is faltu..it is a wayyy lot better than the Cancer track...it has light heartedness etc etc...but flirting=solution to regain Ishaan's memory loss?😕...and though this track is handled differently..but sorry...the whole flirting is becoming very monotonous...

like you i too feel the same they can easily run the show for more than 1 year by opening all the above tracks and also can add ishika love track, rajni & rano tracks and in between can show cute sushaan romance & nok jhok as well but kya kare remote control tho SP ke paas rahetha they want leads story?

though the track is proceeding differently but i feel that the sizzling chemistry of Sushaan has been ruined and forced to see the E-bholapan of ishaan and more than that i missing the beautiful setting of Sushaan's room b coz of this track.

Edited by sree_24 - 14 years ago
infinity00 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#7
I am suprised by Ragini,s justification of this track. Its feels kind of sad to see SGP using the same fundas as others, as for me I thought SGP would be the last one to resort to such tactics.
I agree with Shounak , and Shwetha as well,. kay no ned to think about anything just watch.
428419 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: venture

I am suprised by Ragini,s justification of this track. Its feels kind of sad to see SGP using the same fundas as others, as for me I thought SGP would be the last one to resort to such tactics.
I agree with Shounak , and Shwetha as well,. kay no ned to think about anything just watch.



Even i am quite surprised with what ragini said in the article!😕C'mon..I atleast thought her to be different..but cant blame her completely...as she has to do SGP aur SP ka gun gaaoing!
Shwets1502 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#9
May be Ragz is enjoying doing this track...if we see...all the suhana scenes are good..bt when it comes with this raunak track and all others...we get a messed up episode...and i dont think the actors see the entire picture...when it comes as episode...

bt as u both said...ragini saying the track is very nice and different is def...😕
111192 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: .sb.



Ohh yeah..i forgot its STAR Plus😆so ek saal ke liye toh chalega for sure...😉btw i found some traces of Rajni's track in Rano's brother..like how he doesnt care about his mom etc..Rajni's track was also somewhat like that.



Shounak...adat se baaz nahi ayoge...again dropping hint bombs😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".