Originally posted by: PhoeniXof_Hades
I think it would be unfair to label 'luck' as the only factor behind Aamir taking her into the film. If Aamir wanted to revive her career, he could have taken her in 3I as well. We should not forget that Rani was approached by directors like Mira Nair...what do you think was that for? As for Rani - I don't think there's much hope left for her. Even if she does revive her declining career, people will still regard her as an actress of the "past". She can get awards and all, but she won't become the "hot topic" of the town anymore.
But Amir wasn't casting in 3 idiots. Isn't it the director's call who to cast in their film? I thought Raju Hirani was the one who choose not Amir. But i could be wrong.
PS some of us need to be a little sensitive to Rani fans. Rani is coming back with two films and they are so happy about that. Let's not spoil it for them.
3