Were they wrong?

Ok,let's just put aside all this fan craze for the time being and think properly,were Pratigya and Aman wrong in asking Krishna to not take the law into his hands and to leave it upto the police since what Krishna was doing was wrong since it's not correct to beat up a person and neither does he have the right to do so.Aman might have crossed his limits by saying that even Krishna desreves to be beaten up but let's face it,he was trying to make him understand things in Krishna's own language.And in what way is Pratigya wrong in supporting what's right?She wasn't insulting him infact she was trying to make him understand that what he was doing is wrong but he's just refusing to see or accept the fact that she is right and walked off in a huff!And now this arguement might affect people within the family and might create misunderstandings.

Yes Shruthi both Pratigya and Amman were grossly wrong. Infact they should have joined the mob in pushing that thief back towards krishna and should have chanted and encouraged Krishna to beat him harder and harder until the poor chap's death. By stopping Krishna they obstructed the street justice system. Krishna should hve punched Amman as well for obstruction and should have slapped Pratigya as well for aiding Amman for his illegal obstruction on Krishna's street justice mantra.

aman cud av done that in a nie polite y
hw dare he called krishu a gunda n dat tumhain b aise hei marne chhaiye n all:O
sumthin ov tis sortttt
eeheh:p

Originally posted by: PRAGMATIC

Yes Shruthi both Pratigya and Amman were grossly wrong. Infact they should have joined the mob in pushing that thief back towards krishna and should have chanted and encouraged Krishna to beat him harder and harder until the poor chap's death. By stopping Krishna they obstructed the street justice system. Krishna should hve punched Amman as well for obstruction and should have slapped Pratigya as well for aiding Amman for his illegal obstruction on Krishna's street justice mantra.

Woah! someone's in full on sarcasm mode today😆 Well let's just say I couldn't agree more😉😆

Originally posted by: ArhainArhaan

aman cud av done that in a nie polite y
hw dare he called krishu a gunda n dat tumhain b aise hei marne chhaiye n all:O
sumthin ov tis sortttt
eeheh:p

Arhaina sis,as far as I remember he was telling him in a very polite way untill Krishna made it very clear to him that he isn't going to listen to a word of what he said and that's when he had to become a little more tough and was trying to make Krishna understand in his own language and honestly tell me,what else would you call a person who is beating up someone so brutally apart from a gunda?I doubt if you'd call him a saviour or a hero.I guess you feel that Aman is wrong since you happen to be afan of Krishna and claim to support him no matter what he does😊

Originally posted by: lucky174

In my point of view, yes they were wrong. In a countries like Pak & India all this "dont take law into ur hands" looks crap. in our country people hand over the culprits to police & police releases them within few hrs or days. to murder someone is definitely wrong but to beat up a thief like krishna did is not wrong. Why wait for the police. if police & law were so efficient these crimes wouldnt have taken place.

I deffinitely have to disagree with you there my friend since no one has the right to treat someone else so brutally.Hitting someone is also taken as an offence.It may seem like crap to you but what they said is right since nobody has the right to take the law into their hands and beat someone else up for what they did regardless of the location.Although the police may not be that efficient but one should let the law deal with such issues.An instead of having the theif beaten up,like Pratigya said,the person whom the theif tried to steal from can punish him with the help of the law.

shruthi ..............y did pratigya slap angad for wat he did to her in d train...........y didn't she wait for d police............?????

its too soon for objectivity Shruthi 😆.......

Well, this time I have to agree with Krishna . I think he was doing the right thing and Aman and Prats were wrong but not completely. The thief did deserve to be beat up. If someone's a criminal then they do need to be taught a lesson and a little beating by Krishna was not bad. I do think however that Krishna went a bit overboard and after a few slaps, he should have stopped,, called the police and they should have taken over. Prats and Aman should not have said Krishna was completely wrong, they should have said Dont overdo the beating.