Credibility of Maans character

I think if they show sameera to be his old flame, it'll seriously lead to doubts on the credibility of Maans character...
Oiyeee( Brij ishtyle) & chup (Maan meri jaan Ishtyle).
Nahiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii
Alay ppl think that Mom's impact can't make him so crazy n burn him bad!!
Wat yaar???? I personally don think so (no offence)...

Firstly he is not bad, as some1 said... Had he been bad he wouldn't have regretted him twisting geets arm n certainly wouldn't have gone to get madicines for her...
He is a loner for life who does not know how to handle his emos since he hates them..
He has bottled them up tightly as a defence mechanism so that they don hurt him...
He said he hates emotional talks coz they remind him of his own bottled emos...
Only geet has been able to break the high walls he has erected around him, so she is the only 1 who can c him his emo side.. MSK BY DEFAULT IS NOT PROGRAMMED TO DISPLAY HIS EMOS SO WHEN THEY DO COME OUT HE DOES NOT KNOW HOW TO HANDLE THEM N HANDLE HIMSELF...I think MSK has very very rarely displayed his emos in front of an outsider.. I think only dadi has seen him like this till date.. He has bottled his emos, his dissapointments, bitterness etc for a very long time... This had made his indifferent to others problems...
He trusts geet n when he saw her Manupulating him he lost it all...
Also except dadi i doubt he has spent any considerable time with any other women in his life, so he does not completely know how to behave/handle a girl... He does not know how to conduct himself infront of a girl coz he has never spent so much time with one n has never been so close to one (that y in office he used to pull or push her too close to himself). I think this is also the reason of his arm twisting sessions with geet.. He could normally do that to a guy who is eating the hell out of him rather than a girl...
thats y i presume that sameera is his mum n not gf.. Also the poor bloke is so confused regarding his feling for geet.. Had he been in love b4, he would have understood by now that he loves her...I think Mk does not have an exp with how to handle his emos n how to be around a girl.
Also tell me how many mum-in-laws call their daughter-in-laws as bahu rani or bahu???? Only in serials (ekta maiia's).. Dadi is an open minded women n it is completely justified she addressing her bahu with her name....
Maan has bottled his emos for so long that today they errupted like a volcano infront of geet...
He had began trusting her n he was hurt when he understood that geet was manupulating him... So all his emos from his bitter past errupted... Also he considers Geet to be his own, cause when dadi asked y he did that to geet he replied that he can do wat ever he wants with her n she should not be bothered.. He subconsiously thinks he can get away with anything he does to her cause she is his n he has a right on her to do it... Mind u even i am against his physical actions with geet...
The wall he has created around him cannot be built in a short span of time... It takes a long time to become indifferent to ones own emos let alone to indifferent to others. He has done it over a span of time..
If his failed atremp on love has made him like that then i must say he has a very weak character, n it does not suit MSK.. Him being i don give a damn attitude steaming from a failed relationship does not suit his character... His characterization till now has been very good n extermely strong... The girls swoon over his cause he is mighty n has a strong characterization, a love travk will create doubts regarding his credebility as a strong character... N i belive he CV's will not risk it... Lets be honest atleast half of us watch geet coz of MSK, of course the story is also good but the binding factor is Maneet...

Also ppl want Maan to have a failed affair so that he can connect with it n accepts her with her past..
I feel it will give out the wrong signal... Y is it necessary that a person has to undergo the same situ to understand the others plight????? Y one cannot appreciate the others past without having a past of his own????
Watever happened to geet is very much practical, so for a girl like her to be able to live happily she must only have a guy with a simillar past only???? How practical is it... Y can't we appreciate n sympathise with some1's pain without having suffered the same...
Wouldn't it be great if they show Maan accepting geet with her past without him having the same..I feel it would be the best thing shown... It'll greatly increase the respect n love ppl have for MSK's character.. It'll give out a strong msg that we can be considerate to others difficulties n can help them or accept them with it...
Other wise it'll be a been there n done that kind of a scenario...
Geet is supposed to be different n i hope it will be...

I want Maan to accept geet for wat n how she is. Sympathise with her n love her for wat she is n not bcoz wat u have gone through... I want love n only pure selfless love to bind Maneet n not sympathy... If maan has a past then it'll be sympathy that will attract him to geet not love...

Uff wat a long post... Also forgive me for my clumsy writing abilities...
Sorry.... Just couldn't bottle up my views on this matter... Plz do comment...
Press the like button in case u have any energy left..

Originally posted by: swatichowdhury

I think if they show sameera to be his old flame, it'll seriously lead to doubts on the credibility of Maans character...
Oiyeee( Brij ishtyle) & chup (Maan meri jaan Ishtyle).
Nahiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii
Alay ppl think that Mom's impact can't make him so crazy n burn him bad!!
Wat yaar???? I personally don think so (no offence)...

Firstly he is not bad, as some1 said... Had he been bad he wouldn't have regretted him twisting geets arm n certainly wouldn't have gone to get madicines for her...
He is a loner for life who does not know how to handle his emos since he hates them..
He has bottled them up tightly as a defence mechanism so that they don hurt him...
He said he hates emotional talks coz they remind him of his own bottled emos...
Only geet has been able to break the high walls he has erected around him, so she is the only 1 who can c him his emo side.. MSK BY DEFAULT IS NOT PROGRAMMED TO DISPLAY HIS EMOS SO WHEN THEY DO COME OUT HE DOES NOT KNOW HOW TO HANDLE THEM N HANDLE HIMSELF...I think MSK has very very rarely displayed his emos in front of an outsider.. I think only dadi has seen him like this till date.. He has bottled his emos, his dissapointments, bitterness etc for a very long time... This had made his indifferent to others problems...
He trusts geet n when he saw her Manupulating him he lost it all...
Also except dadi i doubt he has spent any considerable time with any other women in his life, so he does not completely know how to behave/handle a girl... He does not know how to conduct himself infront of a girl coz he has never spent so much time with one n has never been so close to one (that y in office he used to pull or push her too close to himself). I think this is also the reason of his arm twisting sessions with geet.. He could normally do that to a guy who is eating the hell out of him rather than a girl...
thats y i presume that sameera is his mum n not gf.. Also the poor bloke is so confused regarding his feling for geet.. Had he been in love b4, he would have understood by now that he loves her...I think Mk does not have an exp with how to handle his emos n how to be around a girl.
Also tell me how many mum-in-laws call their daughter-in-laws as bahu rani or bahu???? Only in serials (ekta maiia's).. Dadi is an open minded women n it is completely justified she addressing her bahu with her name....
Maan has bottled his emos for so long that today they errupted like a volcano infront of geet...
He had began trusting her n he was hurt when he understood that geet was manupulating him... So all his emos from his bitter past errupted... Also he considers Geet to be his own, cause when dadi asked y he did that to geet he replied that he can do wat ever he wants with her n she should not be bothered.. He subconsiously thinks he can get away with anything he does to her cause she is his n he has a right on her to do it... Mind u even i am against his physical actions with geet...
The wall he has created around him cannot be built in a short span of time... It takes a long time to become indifferent to ones own emos let alone to indifferent to others. He has done it over a span of time..
If his failed atremp on love has made him like that then i must say he has a very weak character, n it does not suit MSK.. Him being i don give a damn attitude steaming from a failed relationship does not suit his character... His characterization till now has been very good n extermely strong... The girls swoon over his cause he is mighty n has a strong characterization, a love travk will create doubts regarding his credebility as a strong character... N i belive he CV's will not risk it... Lets be honest atleast half of us watch geet coz of MSK, of course the story is also good but the binding factor is Maneet...

Also ppl want Maan to have a failed affair so that he can connect with it n accepts her with her past..
I feel it will give out the wrong signal... Y is it necessary that a person has to undergo the same situ to understand the others plight????? Y one cannot appreciate the others past without having a past of his own????
Watever happened to geet is very much practical, so for a girl like her to be able to live happily she must only have a guy with a simillar past only???? How practical is it... Y can't we appreciate n sympathise with some1's pain without having suffered the same...
Wouldn't it be great if they show Maan accepting geet with her past without him having the same..I feel it would be the best thing shown... It'll greatly increase the respect n love ppl have for MSK's character.. It'll give out a strong msg that we can be considerate to others difficulties n can help them or accept them with it...
Other wise it'll be a been there n done that kind of a scenario...
Geet is supposed to be different n i hope it will be...

I want Maan to accept geet for wat n how she is. Sympathise with her n love her for wat she is n not bcoz wat u have gone through... I want love n only pure selfless love to bind Maneet n not sympathy... If maan has a past then it'll be sympathy that will attract him to geet not love...

A son is usually very close to his mum.. If Maans mum ditched him, it perfectly explains his detachment from relationships n emos... It'll justify his bitterness n views regarding women... A mum's betrayal will give more authenticity to the story than a GF's disloyality..

So am keeping my fingers crossed that Sameera is his mum or else she was related to vicky or some thing...Plz no GF buisness...

Uff wat a long post... Also forgive me for my clumsy writing abilities...
Sorry.... Just couldn't bottle up my views on this matter... Plz do comment...
Press the like button in case u have any energy left..

i just love your post....even i was thinking the same...
they show maan's character so strong...and ifa girl ditches him,he'l just know wats happening wid him..but he always says.."ye larki mujhe pagal kar degi...!!'
"ye kya ho raha hai mujhe?"
n all that...ussey ye tho pata hotha ki he's in love..
n coming to the point,
i'll strongly agree...that he need not 2 have a same painful past 2 accept geet...
i believe maan geet ko accept karega despite her past coz there's no mistake of her....n above that he loves her soooo much..
so am just praying god that sameera is not his girl frnd...!!
lets wait n watch anyway...

i so agree babe! I also want sameera to be the mom and not the ex! But it would make more sense that he is this way b/c of a lack of a mother in his life! But I remember when maan was ignoring geet's calls prior to dinner date dev told him he's changing...so dev must know everything about him! So if maan's changing than he's always been angry and rough, and geet is changing him! one would think that if maan had been in love before than he wouldn't be angry and rough, but soft and gentle and smiling...so dev would know what maan's GF and his feelings b/c they're bros and live together! But nevr got that knid of indication from dev so i don't think sameera is a GF!

But in Friday's epi he said to himself,"Sameera ke jaane ke baad to har aurat ko khudse dur karna bahut asaan hogaya the mere liye. Par fir kyun mei Geet ko khud se dur nahi kar pata."

I know that your analysis is fine, but who is such a jerk that he would call his own mother by name.... Isn't it????

I agree that Sameera needn't be his g/f but from my POV, she can't be her mother either...

I don't mean to hurt you, but a small thing that I noticed.

@Swati

Thank u every 1 for reading n commenting on my post..
I have written this post very much b4 sameera came into pic, when ppl were linking NT-maan. At that time the weak mum logic seemed right to me.
After darling sameera came into pic even am a bit confused...

hey everybody i dont think so sameera is maan's mother bcz on one site i saw all the characters of geet n the name of dev mother was something else i dont remeber it rite now but it was definetely not sameera & obviously maan n dev have same mother that lady in white in hoshiarpur

Samira cant be his mom, girlz...wake up ...two days back they showed him saying "Samira ke jaane ke baad ladkiyon ko door rakhna aasaan ho gaya tha"...that definitely means she was his ex,hai na? he can't take his mom's name that casually anyways...

i love tis point of msk tat he hides his emotions so perfectly n plans everything bt geet ruins all 4 him.he z such a unique character bt i wander if sameera ws his gf n he ws heart broken coz of her,then he shud b shown a fun loving guy b4 tat incident.it wud b fun 2 watch him like tat.desperately awaiting 4 sameera track 2 open up!!