Round 1: Madhushree

Note:

This was her debut song. First ever song in Bollywood.

Madushree's tonal quality, expression and sur are spot on. In fact there's much more bounce in the expression and a much more masterful control on pitching then we hear often in Bollywood.

She has such a pure voice that she can sing in a whispering tone without it sounding too breathy or weak. And for so many straight notes with smooth transitions to be sung without a hint of unnecessary vibrato and with such neatness is also commendable.

There were high notes, there was feeling and she fulfilled (if not bettered) the scope of the song. However it didn't touch me as much as Kavita's song. So I can't give this an 8. I'll stick with a 7/10 for now...

Originally posted by: simi_1

First time listening to this one to,

Liked her voice quality, initially thought it was a little shrill,but listened to the song a few times and she definitley has a good voice quality and also a good range

Between a 7 and 7.5

simi why do you keep changing your review based on xobile? 😆

Originally posted by: ssk13809

simi why do you keep changing your review based on xobile? 😆

ssk ab simi ki taang toh mat kheencho!

She made the simple mistake of mixing up her reviews for Tulsi Kumar and Madushree.

sorry ssk, i honestly mixed up the review as i had opened 2 tabs and posted the comments and scoring on the wrong tabs

She has a honey-like voice, and her voice gave that plesant ambience, but the song wasn't a good one, and so, she was fine in this one, as it didn't test her. There weren't many variations, and very simple. Also, she was breaking up on a few low notes. A 7 from me!

My sincere apologies to Madushree ji, her fans, and her gurus/masters if anything I say comes out to be offensive.

Her voice has a beautiful tone to it. She def has a beautiful voice. I see a lot of resemblance to Sadha ji and Mahalaxmi ji. This song, I've heard for the first time. I think there were certain places where she could have done better emphasizing her lines. I've heard a lot better! But she is a very graceful singer!

Overall rating - 6.5 rounded to 7

though her voice was good somehow the song sounded very flat..though I know it is difficult to sing such songs keeping ur voice at the same level is difficult and she has done that👏...somehow this song didnt appeal to me I cant believe it was her breakthrough song...its a 7 from me