Let's talk Sid and Armaan

Rhimjhimsawan thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#1
1. Did Sid help Armaan or not?

Sid fixed their first metting. Sid kept pushing Rids to talk to Armaan. Sid listened to Armaan. Almost every new intern was against Armaan when he first arrived. He is the only one who genuinely talked to him without having a secret agenda of his own.

Granted he wasn't very successful but his intentions were good.

2. What will make him a good husband?


This question is really to all the AR fans. You guys call him a bad husband. Did you want him to tie his wife to bed and lock her in the room so she never gets to see Arman again? would that prove his love?

Or did you want him to set her free on the first day saying the line " Jao Riddhima jao. Go be with Armaan" Would that make him a good husband?

Sid is such an amazing amazing character. Seriously I write stories now and then, read books all day long, watch almost every other show in every other language and it's rare to come upon such amazing characters. He has so much depth. he is a husband who loves his wife, he wants to hold on to her but not at the cost of her happiness. Even after Armaan came back he protected Riddhima. He let AR's nokjhok go on. He expected Rids to announce her decision and when she didn't he bought her more time.

3. Did he betray Armaan? Was it his job to tell the truth?

NO! Riddhima's job was to tell Armaan the truth. Armaan deserves that much. I honestly think he believed Riddhima will eventually go on to Armaan, so there was no point to tell him the earth shattering truth and crush his soul. Think about it what did Sid have to gain from hiding the truth from Armaan. It wasn;t as if he was laughing behind his back. He was more troubled in past few weeks than Armaan.

4. Was Armaan right by punching him?

Yes!! Though I do not believe in violence it would abnormal be of Armaan to not vent out his anger.

5. Does Sid deserve Riddhima?


Unfortunately yes. Very much so. In my opinion even more than Armaan at the moment. People should live in present not the past. What happened to Armaan is not Sid's fault. he shouldn;t pay for it. His unhappiness was not caused by Sid. He didn't ask to be part of Riddhima's life. But over and over again fate brought him in her path. He has always helped her, supported her, had her back.. Even if I was a die hard AR fan I would think of him as a good candidate for Rids.



Edited by Perfangel5655 - 15 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

1.1k

Users

10

Likes

26

Frequent Posters

princess1 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#2
OMG !! Angel you wrote ! !
Such an Amazing post !!
I do not know what DMG future for SID, Ridz and ARmaan..!! For me Sid is an excellent portrayal by Karan wahi !!
Muje hamesha Sid se pyar ho jata hai, no wonder why even shanky has fully belief in him !! And Ridz put Sid next to his Dad !!
Love SID akka Karan Wahi's character something new and very fresh in TV.
After Rajiv Khadelwal As Sujal....this second most wonderful portrayal of Karan Wahi as Siddhant Modi ....Attract me to core !!
termi thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#3
aapki saar baatein aik taraf yaar liken as a loyal fan of AR cvz have betrayed us n we watched n adore each n every moment of AR so we want AR together n sid's character has been so unacceptable just coz he is a wanna be ammy so AR shall be together or they should just die
ShiningStar18 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#4

I totally loved your post Angel..😊

Sid DID help Armaan to get his love back which I would like to say is a very brave act he did considering he is Riddhima's husband...
He had the full right to stop Riddhima from going near Armaan but thats where he proved himself....
Sid is indeed an awesome husband who knows how to keep his wife happy even if that means,sending her back to her former love...I don't get why AR fans say that he is a bad husband....
I agree with them that Sid should have supported Riddhima in the current situation and shouldn't have hid his marriage but if you look at him,he's a great guy...
As you said,it was not Sid's job to tell Armaan about Riddhima being his wife because he was SILENT because of Riddhima!
He chose not to tell Armaan because he knew he wouldn't be able to take it and Riddhima should have told Armaan about her marriage the first time she met him....
Sid totally deserves Riddhima because he was the one who supported Riddhima in her difficult times..
Before their marriage,he didn't love her but still decided to sacrifice his life for Riddhima's honour,...
-Su- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#5
Agree with every word except dis..." In my opinion even more than Armaan at the moment"...i don't think so, both of dem deserve Ridzi, but unfortunately only 1 of dem can get her... :(
sonia_92 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 15 years ago
#6
i disagree wid every single poiunt of urs hunny
sorry
and btw ur topic says "Lets talk sid AND armaan" so where the AND ARMAAN, u r only talkin SID!
no offense but I am a die hard fan n it feels lyk an insult to our love for armaan when u say tht "Even if I was a die hard AR fan I would think of him as a good candidate for Rids. " no AR fan wud ever think of sid as a better candidate than armaan! as u have mentioned above in ur post tht ryt now sid is better for riddhima than armaan
well honestly, i dont blame sidhant for cuming into riddhimas lyf but i do feel tht his attitude towards life n the problems he has been dealt wid is ryt, he has not handled the problems in a mature manner in my opinion
no offense
its just my P.O.V
tc
sonia

KaJen.xoxo thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#7
That's your opinion



. Did Sid help Armaan or not?


Sid fixed their first metting. Sid kept pushing Rids to talk to Armaan. Sid listened to Armaan. Almost every new intern was against Armaan when he first arrived. He is the only one who genuinely talked to him without having a secret agenda of his own.

Granted he wasn't very successful but his intentions were good. yes but eventually Armaan made an effort to bring Ridhima closer in FE sid didn't push her to go to FE if you think Sid pushed Ridhima and tried every best to bring her close to Armaan.. but Armaan wasn't sitting macchar maraoing he tried his level best to apologize to Ridhima and forget the interns they were just for fun scenes it didn't make much difference if all interns were supporting Sid but just because of you see sainty Sid, you can't ignore Armaan what was his fault....if Armaan would have known the truth he would have backed off

2. What will make him a good husband?


This question is really to all the AR fans. You guys call him a bad husband. Did you want him to tie his wife to bed and lock her in the room so she never gets to see Arman again? would that prove his love?

Or did you want him to set her free on the first day saying the line " Jao Riddhima jao. Go be with Armaan" Would that make him a good husband?

Sid is such an amazing amazing character. Seriously I write stories now and then, read books all day long, watch almost every other show in every other language and it's rare to come upon such amazing characters. He has so much depth. he is a husband who loves his wife, he wants to hold on to her but not at the cost of her happiness. Even after Armaan came back he protected Riddhima. He let AR's nokjhok go on. He expected Rids to announce her decision and when she didn't he bought her more time. No it still not after they got married i never seen Ridhima happy he treated her like servant to clean his shoes and threw her to the table and was just getting angry on her for no reason plus he hide the truth to his mom for soo long what happenned when he told truth she accpeted it na than what was makig him sooo coward and keeping num about everything he might be good sometimes i don't think he's the ideal husband..

3. Did he betray Armaan? Was it his job to tell the truth?

NO! Riddhima's job was to tell Armaan the truth. Armaan deserves that much. I honestly think he believed Riddhima will eventually go on to Armaan, so there was no point to tell him the earth shattering truth and crush his soul. Think about it what did Sid have to gain from hiding the truth from Armaan. It wasn;t as if he was laughing behind his back. He was more troubled in past few weeks than Armaan. yes its quite obvious he hide the truth and lied him in the name of friendship if Armaan would have done like sid did ya'll must be supporting Sid right now so let's not play blame game and try to prove who's wrong & right...

4. Was Armaan right by punching him?

Yes!! Though I do not believe in violence it would abnormal be of Armaan to not vent out his anger. its human nature i would punch or slap someone if they backstab me behind my back but let's wait till the episode airs Armaan might ask an apology after his anger calms down Armaan isn't hearltess like them..

5. Does Sid deserve Riddhima?


Unfortunately yes. Very much so. In my opinion even more than Armaan at the moment. People should live in present not the past. What happened to Armaan is not Sid's fault. he shouldn;t pay for it. His unhappiness was not caused by Sid. He didn't ask to be part of Riddhima's life. But over and over again fate brought him in her path. He has always helped her, supported her, had her back.. Even if I was a die hard AR fan I would think of him as a good candidate for Rids. Soooo does Armaan don't forget 2 years realtionship over 2 months marriage soo what she's married Ridhima is confused soul...Armana has done lot of things for her and always wanted best for her and he will back off now since he knows the truth let's not jump to conlcusion cause you like sid and i like armaan so we will decide who deserves who and who should end up together Armaan deserve it as well stop overshadowing his acts by Sid they both are way different and let's not comapre please...
...Noorya... thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: -PZlicious-

That's your opinion



. Did Sid help Armaan or not?


Sid fixed their first metting. Sid kept pushing Rids to talk to Armaan. Sid listened to Armaan. Almost every new intern was against Armaan when he first arrived. He is the only one who genuinely talked to him without having a secret agenda of his own.

Granted he wasn't very successful but his intentions were good. "yes but eventually Armaan made an effort to bring Ridhima closer in FE sid didn't push her to go to FE if you think Sid pushed Ridhima and tried every best to bring her close to Armaan.. but Armaan wasn't sitting macchar maraoing he tried his level best to apologize to Ridhima and forget the interns they were just for fun scenes it didn't make much difference if all interns were supporting Sid but just because of you see sainty Sid, you can't ignore Armaan what was his fault....if Armaan would have known the truth he would have backed off"

what did u expect???? Sid will push Riddhima to bring her close to Armaan...Sid is not a robot dear he is a human with feelings..he loves Riddhima
didn't u saw whatever he has been throught when he sent Riddhima to Pune?
and no one is ignoring Armaan we can understand hw he feels n what will happen next we'll have to wait n watch


2. What will make him a good husband?


This question is really to all the AR fans. You guys call him a bad husband. Did you want him to tie his wife to bed and lock her in the room so she never gets to see Arman again? would that prove his love?

Or did you want him to set her free on the first day saying the line " Jao Riddhima jao. Go be with Armaan" Would that make him a good husband?

Sid is such an amazing amazing character. Seriously I write stories now and then, read books all day long, watch almost every other show in every other language and it's rare to come upon such amazing characters. He has so much depth. he is a husband who loves his wife, he wants to hold on to her but not at the cost of her happiness. Even after Armaan came back he protected Riddhima. He let AR's nokjhok go on. He expected Rids to announce her decision and when she didn't he bought her more time. "
No it still not after they got married i never seen Ridhima happy he treated her like servant to clean his shoes and threw her to the table and was just getting angry on her for no reason plus he hide the truth to his mom for soo long what happenned when he told truth she accpeted it na than what was makig him sooo coward and keeping num about everything he might be good sometimes i don't think he's the ideal husband.."
The way Sid was treating Riddhima after marriage was just to make her realize that she became a robot...she is not living but doin a duty and Sid didnt wanted that...
when he asked her to clean his shoes she was ready to do it.....i mean if that was me i would give a mast tappar to my hubby😆..and this is what Sid wanted to make her realize
3. Did he betray Armaan? Was it his job to tell the truth?

NO! Riddhima's job was to tell Armaan the truth. Armaan deserves that much. I honestly think he believed Riddhima will eventually go on to Armaan, so there was no point to tell him the earth shattering truth and crush his soul. Think about it what did Sid have to gain from hiding the truth from Armaan. It wasn;t as if he was laughing behind his back. He was more troubled in past few weeks than Armaan. "yes its quite obvious he hide the truth and lied him in the name of friendship if Armaan would have done like sid did ya'll must be supporting Sid right now so let's not play blame game and try to prove who's wrong & right..."
It was more Riddhima's jobe to say the truth to Armaan and its Armaan who proposed friendship to Sid...so cant say like no i dont wanna be ur friend😕 he had no choice left so for me he did not betrayed Armaan...but its my opinion

4. Was Armaan right by punching him?

Yes!! Though I do not believe in violence it would abnormal be of Armaan to not vent out his anger. its human nature i would punch or slap someone if they backstab me behind my back but let's wait till the episode airs Armaan might ask an apology after his anger calms down Armaan isn't hearltess like them..

5. Does Sid deserve Riddhima?


Unfortunately yes. Very much so. In my opinion even more than Armaan at the moment. People should live in present not the past. What happened to Armaan is not Sid's fault. he shouldn;t pay for it. His unhappiness was not caused by Sid. He didn't ask to be part of Riddhima's life. But over and over again fate brought him in her path. He has always helped her, supported her, had her back.. Even if I was a die hard AR fan I would think of him as a good candidate for Rids. Soooo does Armaan don't forget 2 years realtionship over 2 months marriage soo what she's married Ridhima is confused soul...Armana has done lot of things for her and always wanted best for her and he will back off now since he knows the truth let's not jump to conlcusion cause you like sid and i like armaan so we will decide who deserves who and who should end up together Armaan deserve it as well stop overshadowing his acts by Sid they both are way different and let's not comapre please...

Here i agree lets not compare Armaan and Sid both are diff characters and both deserve Riddhima...so here also we'll have to wait and watch...
Edited by ...Noorya... - 15 years ago
desigrl05 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: Perfangel5655

5. Does Sid deserve Riddhima?

Unfortunately yes. Very much so. In my opinion even more than Armaan at the moment. People should live in present not the past. What happened to Armaan is not Sid's fault. he shouldn;t pay for it. His unhappiness was not caused by Sid. He didn't ask to be part of Riddhima's life. But over and over again fate brought him in her path. He has always helped her, supported her, had her back.. Even if I was a die hard AR fan I would think of him as a good candidate for Rids.



basically sums up everything...I was a die hard AR fan but when SId came in and I saw his perspective, I loved him... Im not gonna say i was unfaithful to the jodi, but like you mentioned...live in the present not the past!!
-Veena- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#10

Good topic..

And I am plainly assuming you like Sid as a character.. fair enough.

Here are my answers to your questions and please read them with an open mind.. I am just stating what I feel:

. Did Sid help Armaan or not? 3. Did he betray Armaan? Was it his job to tell the truth?

Yes he did start off with good intentions at first.. but down the line.. it became something of what he wanted from Ridz.. for Ridz to make a decision..

He shouldn't have shaken the 'friendship' hand with Armaan! Armaan trusted him.. Armaan has no friends right now…Sid could have been his support .. right now I am sure Armaan feels like he is more of a back stabber! And I agree with you .. it was not his job to tell him the truth.. but if you were in Armaan's shoes think about it.. He knew all this and Armaan was make a fool in front of everyone by doing the wedding rituals and all that drama!

I wouldn't like my 'friend' to do that to me.. would you!?

2. What will make him a good husband?

I respect the space he has given Ridz in making the decision..he understands Ridz ..but in the process I don't not like and do not agree that he repeatedly listened when his mum degraded Ridz.. when she make Ridz go thru the AR love story.. Ridz was pleading with her eyes for help.. well .. but he kept quiet.. that was the worst thing for any woman to go thru… listen about her love story while the husband is right there listening to the intensity of it all! And going thru the wedding rituals…While his sister and his friends thought he should speak up he chose not to!! That is where I lost respect for Sid.. (sorry to say!)

4. Was Armaan right by punching him?

Human nature… I am absolutely against violence .. but men react differently than women!

5. Does Sid deserve Riddhima?

Hummm.. that is for Ridz to decide..

All I can say Armaan don't deserve Ridz right now.. !! And really can't compare Sid and Armaan….

What Sid did was out of the situation.. at that time.. Sid nor Ridz even liked each other.. they just knew each other..

What Armaan and Ridz have is much more stronger and we witnessed that today! Ridz was justifying her wedding to Armaan .. or herself!! It was more to herself!

@ the end of the day… regardless of how we justify ourselves our love for our character is always make them right!! So I think what happened with Armaan is not right.. or could have happened differently ….likewise you feel about Sid.. and really there is nothing wrong in that. I respect that!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".