Anyone tell me concept of Shankar's 14th medly??

navaneeta thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#1
Well some comment on Shankar's medly (I watched it again to understand the concept) ....
Started with some kissan singing and dancing happily .....
- Desh ki dharti .. more of a partriotic song ... then khushi ke din awo re .. so what was the initial dukh and why khushi ???? Q1
- Then Rahul with a bit smile on his face told ab mere pass ek-hi option hein and started Jala Do (Guru Dutt movie song no link to kisaan) ... no one knew why he is commiting suicide .. he does not have money/ too much Lagaan/ got TB/ Brain Cancer/ Biwi bhag gayi .... no clue ... but Javed A cried .... dono ki biwi ek saat bhagi thi ... Q2
- Then suddenly no Lagan no Lagan ... and then Ghana Ghana ... well a song from MOVIE Lagaan but that has nothing to do with Lagaan, that was more of a song to call rain so that they get Fasal and come out of drought ... so Rahul was suiciding because of Laggan/ Rain/ Health/ Biwi ???? ... Q3
- Then end ......
So the problem was everyone was happy .. then Rahul without knowing reason try to commit suicide and then all pray for rain and dance .... so kissan wanted rain???? then why lagaan/ no lagaan ... pls clear Rain or Lagaan ... kissan were happy that desh ki dharti gives gold, then sad for Rahul's wife and then again happy for rain so that they do a rain dance and family problem gets solved ......
What they wanted to say ???? Anyone has Javed A's mail id .. I would ask him .. he would send in detail ....
What was the concept yaar .....

Created

Last reply

Replies

24

Views

2.6k

Users

12

Likes

27

Frequent Posters

Kyahikahoon thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Match Winner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#2

read abt farmer suicides in india..watch the movie lagaan..

u will understand the depth of the concept and know the relevance

navaneeta thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#3
how many suicides in lagaan movie? that was a protest against Lagaan ....
but they started from desh ki dharti .... khushi ke din awo ... where I failed to understand why after that Rahul was thinking of suicide .... then they told No Lagaan .. and then a song for rain welcome (from the movie Lagaan) and then thinks are fine people happy ....
The problem was not portrayed .... kisaan .. why only kisaan all people has some or the other problem .., so many people under poverty line .. no food, shelter ... but to tell something you have to portray what problem they wanted to show ... was it something to do with Lagaan, Drought, even family problem ...
In West Bengal ... maybe a Nano would have come and gone ...
So what problem of kisaan during which history period ... and why 'All was well' at end?
hikamosa thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#4
Bakwas concept.......We love you Shaan.
Ranbir4ever! thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: navaneeta

Well some comment on Shankar's medly (I watched it again to understand the concept) ....


Started with some kissan singing and dancing happily .....


- Desh ki dharti .. more of a partriotic song ... then khushi ke din awo re .. so what was the initial dukh and why khushi ????Q1


- Then Rahul with a bit smile on his face told ab mere pass ek-hi option hein and started Jala Do (Guru Dutt movie song no link to kisaan) ... no one knew why he is commiting suicide .. he does not have money/ too much Lagaan/got TB/ Brain Cancer/ Biwi bhag gayi .... no clue ... but Javed A cried .... dono ki biwi ek saat bhagi thi ... Q2
🤣

- Then suddenly no Lagan no Lagan ... and then Ghana Ghana ... well a song from MOVIE Lagaan but that has nothing to do with Lagaan, that was more of a song to call rain so that they get Fasal and come out of drought ... so Rahul was suiciding because of Laggan/ Rain/ Health/ Biwi ???? ... Q3


- Then end ......


So the problem was everyone was happy .. then Rahul without knowing reason try to commit suicide and then all pray for rain and dance .... so kissan wanted rain???? then why lagaan/ no lagaan ... pls clear Rain or Lagaan ... kissan were happy that desh ki dharti gives gold, then sad for Rahul's wife and then again happy for rain so that they do a rain dance and family problem gets solved ......


What they wanted to say ???? Anyone has Javed A's mail id .. I would ask him .. he would send in detail ....


What was the concept yaar .....





Very well said! I ddnt und d concept n d way it was put into action yer i cnt und hw come javed cried! 🤣 🤣
428419 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: navaneeta

Well some comment on Shankar's medly (I watched it again to understand the concept) ....
Started with some kissan singing and dancing happily .....
- Desh ki dharti .. more of a partriotic song ... then khushi ke din awo re .. so what was the initial dukh and why khushi ???? Q1
- Then Rahul with a bit smile on his face told ab mere pass ek-hi option hein and started Jala Do (Guru Dutt movie song no link to kisaan) ... no one knew why he is commiting suicide .. he does not have money/ too much Lagaan/ got TB/ Brain Cancer/ Biwi bhag gayi .... no clue ... but Javed A cried .... dono ki biwi ek saat bhagi thi ... Q2
- Then suddenly no Lagan no Lagan ... and then Ghana Ghana ... well a song from MOVIE Lagaan but that has nothing to do with Lagaan, that was more of a song to call rain so that they get Fasal and come out of drought ... so Rahul was suiciding because of Laggan/ Rain/ Health/ Biwi ???? ... Q3
- Then end ......
So the problem was everyone was happy .. then Rahul without knowing reason try to commit suicide and then all pray for rain and dance .... so kissan wanted rain???? then why lagaan/ no lagaan ... pls clear Rain or Lagaan ... kissan were happy that desh ki dharti gives gold, then sad for Rahul's wife and then again happy for rain so that they do a rain dance and family problem gets solved ......
What they wanted to say ???? Anyone has Javed A's mail id .. I would ask him .. he would send in detail ....
What was the concept yaar .....




Well said.btw i didnt understand one thing................when Shankar's Rockstars were performing a medley about a serious topic like farmer suicide,what was the need of shankar n his team shouting"hey","come on " again and again ..........what was the need of saying "come on " in a serious medley I simply dont understand...and ya agree with u...why ghanan ghana in farmer suicide????..................why???
bambooshoot thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#7

navaneeta, that was hilarious!😆😆😆😆

I haven't seen the episode yet, so can't comment.
But your post was really funny and I enjoyed reading it.😆😆
navaneeta thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#8
@rijul1 .... farmer suicide concept ... no no all farmers were happy singing dancing ... ek ka hi personal problem ... so kahani ek tragic suicide attempt ki ... kisaan ki aduri prem kahani ????
and not only come-on .. full of Dhintaka ... dhin tak stuff .... when Rahul was sitting (pre-suicide attempt) all others were singing and dancing with lead busy dhin tak .. tak ....
So this made me feel that problem was only for Rahul as all others were damn happy and all surprized to see sad Rahul (see their expression ... are is khusi ke mauke pe yeh devdas bana kiyu bytha hein)
And one point .... significance of Neeti dressed up like Sonia Gandhi in kisaan track ....
Fully confused ... posted my query to starplus MKMM forum as well ... let's see anyone can tell the concept 😕 and JA's rone ke peeche raaz kya thi ....
Edited by navaneeta - 15 years ago
redapple1 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: bambooshoot

navaneeta, that was hilarious!😆

I haven't seen the episode yet, so can't comment.
But your post was really funny and I enjoyed reading it.😆😆


You should see the expression of Shaan when he won the toss. It is priceless. He looked so happy just to win the toss. Little did he know he will be later insulted by Javed by calling his medley almost pathetic attempt to entertain. He won the toss for the first time and kept the coin.
In Shankar's medley I couldn't follow the flow of the songs. When the farmer tries to commit suicide, Sharib says from now on no farmer will die. Then they all start to shout together, with Shankar's dhin thak, followed by rain song.. We can only assume, they all sung to bring rain like lagaan movie with ganana song and solved the kissan's problem.


.Alluring. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#10
Shankar's rockstar's medleys was entertaining BEFORE.. few recent that they did was kind of boring... no not their concept! but the way they presented it.. and this last one was completely disaster.... i didn't see the whole concept..fast forwarded it..

Javed Akhtar said that he was smiling while watching Shaan's medley.. then how come he said it was the LOWEST DENOMINATOR of entertainment... he didn't have any other better words or what?
If they would had allow the audience to vote for the medley instead of this maha jury than Shaan would have won it.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".