smrth thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#1

Friends

I wanted to share an epochal event taking place in India. May be this forum is not entirely appropriate place to discuss something political but there is a remote connection. Besides I wanted to put this very important event to the notice of friends abroad where news concerning India is generally given a miniscule address.

Today, after 14 years of dithering, at least ten false starts in Parliament and umpteenth maneuvers 'Woman Reservation bill' is slated to be adopted as low in this country. Both the houses are primed to see the passage of the bill. The 108th (auspicious number!) amendment of Indian Constitution will force minimum 33% representation in all elected forums across the country. Just see the few implications-Upcoming elections in Tamilnadu and W.Bengal will see no less then 78 and 98 women MLAs. Loksabha will have at least 181 women MPs from the present 59.

Of course initially we may see many representatives who would be merely puppets in the hands of their male relatives but gradually we will see true representation and hence this can be a step in right direction. Why is this representation so important? There is no direct explanation but it is observed that quality of governance improves in direct proportion to the women representation .For instance Scandinavian countries ,where traditionally women are elected in large numbers, are the best democracies in the world. And this can be one of the most important steps towards the strengthening of Indian Democracy. In a hugely uneducated society such as India the appearance of many women rulers do influence the mind set of mass up to an extent.

Reservation per se is a word anathema to me. It scuttles the quality and engenders partiality. I would more happily see the elections of women on their own capacities and strength. But this requires education of girls at grass root level and here the 'result' may help create the 'remedy'. So this reservation is appropriate and necessary in our society.

Then we may see the disappearance of uneducated Archanas and illiterate Savitas.

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

1.2k

Users

4

Likes

16

Frequent Posters

Spartacus thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#2
I strongly feel the same that women need to fight out in the open, rather than have a reserved category!
May be i am wrong when i say this they would be mere puppets at their hands of relatives and husband who will call all the shorts.
It takes away the right of anyone who's baston would be reserved so he has no place too stand for.
Even the lion roars its own backyard or territory, but when u don't have ur own backyard, then this biased i strongly feel!
smrth thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#3

Friends,

The passage of the bill is again hindered.

'The Woman quota bill' plot is proving more sensational then our wildest daily soap, in the process it is churning out more twists and turns then our imaginative script writes can dish out!

Rajyasabha is adjourned!

Edited by samarth_050 - 15 years ago
smrth thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#4

Under the head line 'These men win battle', Times of India had front page photograph of that incorrigible Yadav duo raising their hands in solidarity and victory cry.

1. Mulayam Singh Yadav- Exact copy of Gollum.

2. Lalu Prasad Yadav-Exact copy of Lallu Yadav the abomination

smrth thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#5
Cheers Rajya Sabha Passes The Bill.
Orcs are defeated at the bettle of Helm's Deep. The stage is moved to Minas Tirith for final war-Lok Sabha.
Tanyaz thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#6
Very happy to know this .
Congratulations on this huge reform ......
smrth thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#7

Thanks Tanyadi for sharing my happiness. This bill has given us much frustration and disappointment in the past when sexiest and castiest politics had stalled it for quite sometime. Today we are a step forward, no matter how strongly the skeptics reject it for its direct usefulness. Now we are awaiting the final maneuvers in Loksabha with bated breath.

P.S. Today when Sonia Gandhi met Lalu Prasad Yadav (her old friend but staunch opponent to this bill), She told in light vein, "Laluji, You should support this bill as a father of seven daughters!"

commentator thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#8
Thought this might be of interest to those who are, like me, also happy about this Bill, whatever its real or perceived shortcomings may be :
"Gender quotas...are...contentious. Despite this they have become a widely used policy tool in the past decade, and over fifty countries have implemented gender quotas. Of these, countries as different as Rwanda, Sweden, and Argentina - rich and poor, long-term democracies or not, and regardless of their type of electoral and parliamentary systems - have used quotas to put a critical mass of 30 percent or more women into national legislatures....While this can be read as a sign of gender concerns having entered mainstream policy making, it is also a direct result - especially across the global South - of the development project constituting women as the essential bodies around whom a great push forward can be generated. Moving women into formal politics fits this agenda: it is expected to meet crucial governance criteria of inclusion, reduced corruption, increased transparency, and accountable governments, even as it is expected to bring a sharper focus to broader societal concerns and interests."
From 'Gender Quotas: The Politics of Presence and the Feminist Project: What Does the Indian Experience Tell US?' by Neema Kudva and Kajri Misra, Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society 2008, Vol 34, No.1.
And here is Soutik Biswas, BBC's India correspondent: "(W)ith barely 10% of its parliamentary seats held by women, India needs to play catch up. Its neighbours fare much better - Bangladesh reserves 15% of its parliamentary seats for women, Pakistan 30% and Afghanistan, after its new constitution, more than 27%."
(And here we were thinking we were the Big Brother of the subcontinent?....... Big Brother possibly, but clearly NOT Big Sister. In any case, when sisters have more of a say in matters of war and peace and governance, no country will NEED to be "bigger" or "smaller".)
Edited by commentator - 15 years ago
smrth thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#9

@ commentator

Thanks for posting such informative and relevant article. It was surprising to know that such countries who are not considered so open have already implemented this useful tool. Though politics are well discussed in some other sites and blogs, I found posting this immensely important topic some what relevant here.

Any kind of quota, for that matter, is contentious. But this quota is surely useful. How the enhanced women participation is catalyzing all those improvements, cited in that article, is not clear to me but one direct result is self evident-the better education and empowerment of the women. (Especially so in the case of 'global south' the undeveloped or semi developed nations.) This is a very important factor in creation of a healthy society as Women as mothers or life partner are single most important influence in development of a wholesome individual.

Soutik must be happy to know about the catching up process-more relevant in this case as Legislators are more relevant here.( I didn't know about the neighbours!)

commentator thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#10
@ Samarth,
You don't need to explain why you posted on this topic. This is a historic bill, furiously opposed and 14 years in the passing, that will hopefully make a real difference to legislation in our country. Yes, there's the strongish possibility of abuse, but that's the case with almost every proposed improvement to social circumstances; we can't or shouldn't stop something right from happening merely because it can potentially fall into the wrong hands. If there's a challenge here, let's hope women take it up. I'm sure lots of people talking about gender issues on this forum - and particularly PR, where it's so big - will have found this thread uplifting after yet another day of moaning / grieving / ranting over Archana's travails.
C
Edited by commentator - 15 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".