Round 3: K.K. - Page 4

Oh btw that score of 1 is from me - I keyed it in by mistake!

Guys I seriously don't understand what is the need of getting so personal as if the loser of this competition will not be a great singer. If our favourite doesn't win does that mean it will belittle his/her greatness in our eyes. Or if a particular singer after winning this competition will get more work. No, not at all. So what is the need to fight I don't understand.

^ completely agree! but all this drama is quite entertaining 😆

Originally posted by: xobile

^ completely agree! but all this drama is quite entertaining 😆

Ya everyone is taking a leaf out of Gajju Uncle's book. 😊

Much as i said Himesh's personal attacks did not bother me. actually they did and i felt i should defend myself. I mean just because he is a judge and has some strong opinions doesnt mean he can vilify anyone. I dont intend to take it lying down. I've asked risingabove to tell me if he thinks i am wrong and should leave this competition. Also, asked him to remove Himesh as judge because his behaviour has been unbecoming of a judge. Waiting for his reply.

Originally posted by: saq123

I agree with u on the part that something needed to be done and had been advocating the same for a long time. Glad that its happened. The only thing i would reiterate here is that you are thinking narrowly in terms of only KK & Shankar. I guess if u luk at the overall picture there r some odd scores for all the singers.For eg. Shaan has a lot of 10s, Sonu has a lot of avg. to below avg. scores. So, does the person love only KK and Shaan and hate Shankar and Sonu. U talk about my 8. You have given 7 to KK and less marks in every round. I had given Shankarji 10 in the previous rounds when i liked his performances more. Am not partial like u. Its obvious u want KK out and are giving him poor marks accordingly.1 other thing i will say once and for all. Wat was dat crap about knowing how this poll works. Wat is dere to know, plz tell me. Its simple average dear. Will hardly take 5 mins to calculate but perhaps ur thick head cant get it. If I had really wanted KK to win (at all costs), nothing could have prevented KK from winning all the rounds. Every other singer would have just got 3s from me and KK only 10s. I stay in a hostel my friend and if i wanted to play foul, there would be atleast 50 tens for KK each round. There would not be any need for scoring others then i guess. 😛 Anyways wat i and the others could not get done in a civilized manner, u seem to have managed in ur underhand manner. So, i guess u deserve an applause👏 My only grouse that remains is we have such a biased judge amongst us, so the competition cant be fair really. Ur scores for KK have been 7,8,7. Ur scores for Shankarji have been 8,10 and 9. My scores for KK were 10,10and 10(All songs requested by me) For Shankarji i scored 10,10 and 8. Ohh how biased am I??????

KK also getting avg. to below avg. scores from someone who hates KK and has all the time in the world to indulge in bakwaas debates asserting Himesh's superiority as a singer. Now, who exactly is that: Ohhhhh its u ssk😆 For all of u plz chk out my post here https://india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=1348327&TPN=2 and u will know what i feel about the whole thing anyways.

I'm being biased? 😆

Someone999 I think has given the exact same scores for Shankar Mahadevan as I have. 8, 10, and a 9, or maybe even better I can't recall. Does that make them biased as well towards Shankar? 😆 I think summer has given even higher than both of us towards Shankar, does that make them biased as well? 😆 8, 9, and 10 is a good variety of scores for Shankar, showing I have not been biased.


As far as K.K. goes, first of all, I have never gave average or below avg. to K.K. 5 is average. 2nd of all, i doubt any of the other judges think i've given K.K. scores so low it looks like i am totally biased against him. All the scores I have given to K.K. are reasonable.. i didn't award extra points for trying something new, so K.K. gets a 7 in my book, while others might've. When I truly judge K.K.'s singing ability, those are the scores I think he deserves. Its my opinion. And as xobile said for my 7 in this round for K.K., its reasonable. I gave 8 to K.K. last round, just 1 lower than someone999 and 7 in the 1st round, same, just 1 lower. So am i allowed to have 1 mark opinion difference? or 1 mark means = biased 😆

as I said in the PM replying to saq123

i don't think saq123 has been creating the problems, and i want him/her to continue contributing to the competition. However, though it seems ssk likes Shankar more than K.K., I don't think his scores have been totally out of line with others and unreasonable. so i don't think it would be proper to remove him from his judge seat.

Ok first of all i will thank risingabove for his support. Next i will apologise to everyone who did not like my comments (including ssk). Was just trying to point out that it is easy to try and blame others and give ur opinion. Did not actually think that any of the judges were biased. i was most hurt by ssk's repeated personal attacks and thereby decided to put my point across to everyone. So, lets put this controversy behind and enjoy what will hopefully be a rousing finale. @ssk wen i spoke about ur marks for KK and Shankar was just replying to ur post questioning my 8 for Shankar. U didnt question my 9 for Sonu after all. I had given Shankar ji 10 in the previous 2 rounds because had enjoyed those performances more. This time 8 because I felt other performances were much better. I never judge on technicalities so my judgement might not luk reasonable to u. Thats all. Thanks

Polls are now closed!


Audience Score: 9.5
Judges Score: 8.8



Final Score: 9.2*


*Modified Score-Not Counting Poll