Vinit Versus Debo Fans! Fight on music!!

rahul_mehta9999 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#1

Nilima Singh is one of those Debo/IsmailJi Bashers. She is trying to instigate people against them by putting all these masala in the forum, but little does she know that people here are smart and will not simply agree saying "Yes Ismal is bad guy here!!"

For crying out loud, her Favourite HR has been doing this since most can remember him. Then why the double standards.

My observations about Vinit Fans -
1) They are tone-deaf.They cannot see the variation in his voice in a single song. He cannot maintain a single type of voice throughout the song. If I close my eyes, I feel as if I am hearing 2 or 3 singers singing.

2) They like juicy things (love story etc). Maybe they should see Jerry Springer instead of SRGMP.
3) They are highly biased in the name of appreciating music.
4) They are fond of Topis, Kurtas.
5) They are fond of nasal and besura singing.
6) They are will stoop to lowest levels to come up with ideas about false internet voting sites, ULFA etc.

And then if you ask me, most of them are from Vinit's home state, where we get maximum number of bad politicians, so get the idea.

On the other hand, Debo fans -
1) They are not tone-deaf.

2) They do not like juicy things but appreciate the only talent that is left in the show (though both may not be the best).
3) They know the shortcomings of other singers and their own, and appreciate the other goodness in the singing (unlike Vinit Fans who just trounce upon the opponent no matter what).
4) They hate nasal and besura singing.
5) They will not stoop to lowest levels. Most like the way ID treats all contestants performance in an unbiased manner.
Debo's maximu fans come from a neglected part of the Country, that the studio audience does not associate with (most of audience is from Bombay). Now, Assam is trying to integrate with rest by watching/voting for the show, and they are being crucified to do so (by none other than HR and Gang). So what if they vote in multiples and scores. It is within the rules of the game. No one raised objection when Vinit was getting highest for so long (he got max votes from his region too). Now because Debo is getting max, all the hue and cry from the egoistic Vinit Fans. It just does not seem fair that Vinit fans on this forum keep doing so at every chance.

Shame on Vinit Fans for trying to gain points by mud slinging on false notions.

I will post this in a seperate link as well. People should realize and talk about the performances and not about all the peripheral talks (of HR first and now ID, who is trying to beat HR at his game).

I like Nihira, Hema, Ujjaini and Swananda amongst girls.
And Hema, Abhijeet, Debo fan.

I do not hate Vinit or HR. And I have lots of sympathy for HR since he never got good singers to start with (he never got to select first in the raffle round, remember).

Guys now just wait and watch all vinit fans will attack this thread like crazy.

But seriously, good debate of the two's real singing is most welcome and appreciated.


Edited by rahul_mehta9999 - 19 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

722

Users

4

Frequent Posters

rahul_mehta9999 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#2
This is my personal opinion only and am not trying to choose one over the other or its fan base.

People plese have healthy discussion instead of just plain jaw-jabbing.
rahul_mehta9999 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#3
I agree! Why ask for the sympathy votes!! Its not like they are going to do that again. Good if they do. But why play with people's feelings. Play with their love for music if need be. Make each one better than the other.

Its a shame to watch any kind of regionalism. Thanks goodness none of the finalist is from the minority. There would be riots!!
sher_e_Punjab thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#4
vinit has smooth voice and debo has a raw voice...yeh lo ek auir pandit....lagta hai galat type kiya hai......agar aap HEMA ke fan hai...to please mat baniye..kal ko aap kehenge HEMA ki awwaj suresh wadkar jaisi hai..asie fans ke hone se aacha hai na ho..
rahul_mehta9999 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#5
I beg to differ Monxx, Vinit has jhalaks (traces) of Rafi Saheb or Sonu Nigam and thats the problem. I wish he was complete, he is incomplete.

Debo's voice has originality.
Hema's voice was original too. I liked him over any other. But I think Debo is more versatile than either 3.
Himani was the least versatile of the lot. All she could sing was those folky numbers. She is made for art movies. Nihira was best.
sher_e_Punjab thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#6
NIHIRA IS THE BEST FOLLOWED DEBO/HEMA.. par apni haryana di puttar bhi kamal ki hai ji......usko trainign milegi to aur aacha gayegi.....
rahul_mehta9999 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#7
Himani is good too. Her singing is perfect but her voice will not let her be a versatile playback singer. Her voice will not suite every actress.
Will be glad for her if she proves this wrong.
sher_e_Punjab thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#8
every body will shine ...vinti too but only if he leaves HR..HR ke din bahr gaye..woh kehete hai na bujhne se pehele diya jyaada jalta hai..Hr ka bhi wohi haal hoga..
bvsamrat thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#9
Though I do not agree with Monxx, the only factor that goes for Vinith is that

He made less mistakes than others!

He is the youngest!

He was given maximum coverage. like announcing is next movie songs/Topi etc. etc.

Finally he always got songs which suited him, till the last episode.

If you remember any Judge in any contest will say
'' we want original voice. not Rafi or Sonu'
See what happenned now.


zinga thumbnail
Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#10
Fight on music is over with Nihira & Hemu's exit....
it just a dead game for me....

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".