Discuss: 3 Idiots same without Aamir?

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

TallyHo

@TallyHo

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

#51

Originally posted by: Decoder
I would have watched the film anyways because I like Hirani's hilarious and little poignant style films.

Aamir Khan is a good actor, no arguments on that but I felt Sharman Joshi and Omi Vaidya got into the skin of the character more than anyone in the film. Even Kareena in her brief role was at par with Aamir.

I agree 100%...

This wasnt Aamir's best performance for me...Omi, Sharman, Kareena were the ones who stood out...but would it be such a monster hit without Aamir...No...call it his brand equity, involvement in the whole process, marketing...whatever....but as far as acting goes he has given much much better performances in the past...IMHO.. 😊

Quote

Niharika Jain

@Ultimate_Shadow

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

#52

Originally posted by: adios

At the part in bold.. but what is the point of pursuing this one sided discussion? 3 idiots is the biggest box office succes.. and Aamir rocked in it! I personally don't think that anyone would say.. that oh Aamir shouldnt have done it and some x, y or z should have done it.. And if someone does dare to say that do you think that person would be able to hold his or her own in this thread. 😆 I personally find this whole discussion pointless.. Its like asking could any other actor have done DDLJ? And the answer is no.. so no point in pursuing it.. This discussion is a dead end kinda discussion.

adios ji if next time aamir is indirect;y bashed in any thread...nd i m sure he will be...u stay online what is milk nd what is water?😆😆😆

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

395575

Suspended

Posted: 16 years ago

#53

@ adios : criticism on bolly forum has been never fair...if majority walks through a specific..there is no chance for anyone to stand and criticize or in general terms to express themselves...its the few members who always suffers...and the rest this forum is biased

on the topic...the world knows the truth aamir was outstanding and the whole team of 3 idiots did a fantastic job..

if a movie is a success, u can't imagine any actor doing that particular becoz ppl like it so much tht it feels like...it was made fr him and only him

Quote

-Aladin-

@-Aladin-

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#54

Originally posted by: Zareena
What is the need dragging other actors when Aamir already did the role? Could anyone do the role Akshay did in Aankhain? NO, Could you think of anyone the role Srk did in DDLJ, Chak De, Swades and RNBDJ? Can you think of any other in Andaz Apna Apna? NO.

Srk was offered many movies like Lagaan, 3 Idiots, Munnabhai but things didn't happened. Srk himself said no one could had done a better job to what Sanjay Dutt did.

Same goes for Aamir, he was offered Baazigar and Darr. It wasn't meant to be.

We should appreciate actors work instead of just putting other actors and members down. If the actor is your favorite, you will say this is a biased comment. Can we move on please? First post was about aamir and now it's because aamir vs rest of the actors.

Agreed, SPECIALLY the last part. Aamir is a huge name, there is no doubt about that. I don't see anybody trying to put down Aamir or his contribution in any way. Obviously, he is responsible for the blockbuster status of the movie, EVERYONE is saying that.

Fact is also that Salman, Akshay and SRK also get huge openings for their movies. So, we shouldn't take away their contribution to cinema either.

I love Minnie ji's example of Gadar. I loved that movie. Frankly, I don't see anyone doing some of the roles he has done. Could anyone else have given that speech of Tareekh pe Tareekh and the dhai kilo ka mukka. You can try to put down a movie saying 'oh, just silly action', as it happened with Wanted but the HUGE success of the movie speaks for itself, that too with an A certificate and no popular songs. So, who was responsible? Boney? 😆😆 Honestly, it's about time people give due credit to others.

It's funny seeing comments as 'oh, I have praised too instead of criticising', when I can clearly remember many of the movies and actors being put down EVEN AFTER the movie was a huge success and a superhit. It's still making money because it's still running at some of the cinemas, btw. Yes, I am talking about Wanted. It was put down earlier and still it is being put down even now. Not even acknowledged in any of the best films polls, so much so that if someone mentions it, they get a 'oh, stupid action movie, made no sense'. 😆 So, us mein public nahin jaanti kya, wo kaise hit ho gayi? 😆

Some people even made a claim that Akshay fails to draw a crowd even when he got huge openings for his movies. 😛 Yeah, many of his movies failed, but still made crores of rupees. Infact, many of his flops made much more money than some of the hits of the year. The only thing that worked against the movies was their huge budget, unfortunately. 😛

Edited by -Aladin- - 16 years ago

Quote

Niharika Jain

@Ultimate_Shadow

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

#55

^^^

wow how u manage to write so much everytime...quite commendable..

Quote

-Aladin-

@-Aladin-

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#56

Originally posted by: Human_Torch
^^^

wow how u manage to write so much everytime...quite commendable..

😆 Human Torch ji, aap mazaq uda rahe hain?

I guess I am quite the nutcase, so it comes easily to me. 😆

p.s. Also, I have a good memory. 😉😆😆

Edited by -Aladin- - 16 years ago

Quote

Niharika Jain

@Ultimate_Shadow

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

#57

^^^

nah i was serious thats why i didn't use this..😆 good one...lage raho😉

Quote

newsmaker

@newsmaker

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#58

Originally posted by: Zareena
What is the need dragging other actors when Aamir already did the role? Could anyone do the role Akshay did in Aankhain? NO, Could you think of anyone the role Srk did in DDLJ, Chak De, Swades and RNBDJ? Can you think of any other in Andaz Apna Apna? NO.

Srk was offered many movies like Lagaan, 3 Idiots, Munnabhai but things didn't happened. Srk himself said no one could had done a better job to what Sanjay Dutt did.

Same goes for Aamir, he was offered Baazigar and Darr. It wasn't meant to be.

We should appreciate actors work instead of just putting other actors and members down. If the actor is your favorite, you will say this is a biased comment. Can we move on please? First post was about aamir and now it's because aamir vs rest of the actors.

Oh Zareena, you feel offended sooo easily 😭 Please be open minded. 😃

Yes, again it is more analysis question. I am not asking that "Who wins the start race". or "who have rejected more movies". It's a question to go one step behind and think what if film was made with another big actor?

We think that the roles are not meant for them but when Tarun asked this same question to Raju, he said, because ppl liked the character they think nobody could have done it better. But his point of view was, you can't tell until actually you see them playing that role.

Yes i can think of different actors in some roles. For e.g. i can see Salman Khan in Chak De, he could have looked more sophisticated and cool coach. Again just my thinking, it doesn't have to be correct or proved correct.

Mods, you can close the topic now.

Thanks everyone for participating!

Edited by whoru - 16 years ago

Quote

-Aladin-

@-Aladin-

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#59

Originally posted by: whoru

Oh Zareena, you feel offended sooo easily 😭 Please be open minded. 😃

Yes, again it is more analysis question. I am not asking that "Who wins the start race". or "who have rejected more movies". It's a question to go one step behind and think what if film was made with another big actor?

We think that the roles are not meant for them but when Tarun asked this same question to Raju, he said, because ppl liked the character they think nobody could have done it better. But his point of view was, you can't tell until actually you see them playing that role.

Yes i can think of different actors in some roles. For e.g. i can see Salman Khan in Chak De, he could have looked more sophisticated and cool coach. Again just my thinking, it doesn't have to be correct or proved correct.

Mods, you can close the topic now.

Thanks everyone for participating!

I think Zareena ji is right because it seemed that some of the other actors were being put down. If a lot of people feel that way, then there must be something right in that, no? 😛 She gave valid reasons and I definitely would support her.

Yes, there are some roles that even if they are brilliant, you can imagine others doing it too. However, one should not try to bring down others to show their own favourites up, that's wrong. Simple as that.

Why close the topic now? After Swati ji's note, everyone is debating in a healthy manner. 😛

Besides, this is one of the best topics opened after a long time where we are all having a good discussion. So, thanks for opening it. 😃

Quote

newsmaker

@newsmaker

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#60

Originally posted by: -Aladin-

I think Zareena ji is right because it seemed that some of the other actors were being put down. If a lot of people feel that way, then there must be something right in that, no? 😛 She gave valid reasons and I definitely would support her.

Yes, there are some roles that even if they are brilliant, you can imagine others doing it too. However, one should not try to bring down others to show their own favourites up, that's wrong. Simple as that.

Why close the topic now? After Swati ji's note, everyone is debating in a healthy manner. 😛

Besides, this is one of the best topics opened after a long time where we are all having a good discussion. So, thanks for opening it. 😃

Aladin, i think i didn't like Zareena's tone at all. I find it very rude. Healthy discussions should not have allegations on the members such as i am putting other actors down in front of Aamir, which is absolutely not true! I like the way you said it. You conveyed the same message but in a different manner. Human Torch is right! You are sure a very good writer 😃⭐️

I have no problem in continuing the discussion. I thought we are at a saturated point, which is why i asked for closing the topic.

All: please continue the discussion. 😃