Why her???

I just dont understand why would shimak choose the girl from W.Y to perform in the semi final and the final when she wasnt even there for like 3 weeks of the competetion

she was not there due to her injury and whenever she did perform, she did really well

She was missing in action due to her ankle injury...other than that, she's been really good whenever she's performed...and she was phenomenal with Puneet last night, which tilts the stakes more in her favour in the performance department...😊

She honestly shud have been eliminated.

It's not fair for other contestents as karishma was missing from last few epi while they were dnacing their asses off and she got a free ride to the semi finals?

yeah yeahh she danced well last night but other ppl like vishal has been constantly setting the stage on firrrree!!!!!!

irrespective of the number of times karishma has performed...i think she is a better dancer than vishal and hence deserved to be in the semis

thats just my personal opinion... i ADMIRE vishal and his talent but at the end of the day karishma is a better dancer

I think Shiamak's criteria in choosing the final contenders for the semi's has more to do with quality than quantity, as would anyone else's in his place...there is no denying the fact that Vishal worked hard...everybody worked hard...and that includes Karishma as well...not being on stage the last couple of weeks doesn't really take away from the fact that she might have been rehearsing for last night's routine...there are varying levels of hard work, of course...Puneet's had continuous performances for the past couple of weeks...and it is completely to his credit that he's pulled off each one of them to perfection...so a couple of dancers have had to work harder than others...but that is bound to happen when you're working as a team...and a team is the unit that is contending for the title at this stage, not individual dancers...besides, not being on stage wasn't really Karishma's fault...it was an injury, which is not an excuse...but to make up for the absense of a member is what a team is for...which is exactly what WYs did...

It was NOT fair, i didn't like wht shamak did, wht was the reason Vishal wasn't in the semi final, i seriously didn't it. I always thought shiamak took grttt decision, but this was Ridiculous! Karishma did not deserve ut at all. Karishma is good, but in evry single dance performence Vishal did well. Yesterday there was this performence of Puneet (i think the long guy,) who danced wth Karishma, i have to say they both were sooooooooooo good, but then again, Puneet was 100 times better then Karishma, the ONLY reason for i didn't think it was perfect was coz of Karishma.

This is really disappointing.

But i do like Karishma, i just feel Vishal is a better dancer.

I think his reason for choosing Karishma was more for the purpose of letting WY have at least one girl so that they have variety in the types of dances they can do when it comes to duets etc. People like to see romantic dances with lots of lifts, so sometimes its neccessary to have a girl on the team, even if she is slightly overweight.

I also seriously hated Shiamak's decision of choosing that girl over Vishal 😡. She might be a good dancer but she is no way better than Vishal who has been 'man of the match' more than once... She also has given too less performances as compared to Vishal... And if Shiamak chose her only to have a female in the team, then I don't think it was right coz I think even the guys can dress and perform like a girl if necessary in the competition (and if girls are necessary, then why did WY have only one girl from the beginning itself??).....

Originally posted by: nandinidev

I think Shiamak's criteria in choosing the final contenders for the semi's has more to do with quality than quantity, as would anyone else's in his place...there is no denying the fact that Vishal worked hard...everybody worked hard...and that includes Karishma as well...not being on stage the last couple of weeks doesn't really take away from the fact that she might have been rehearsing for last night's routine...there are varying levels of hard work, of course...Puneet's had continuous performances for the past couple of weeks...and it is completely to his credit that he's pulled off each one of them to perfection...so a couple of dancers have had to work harder than others...but that is bound to happen when you're working as a team...and a team is the unit that is contending for the title at this stage, not individual dancers...besides, not being on stage wasn't really Karishma's fault...it was an injury, which is not an excuse...but to make up for the absense of a member is what a team is for...which is exactly what WYs did...

Last night, Vishal was good, but Karishma took the bar alot higher when she hit the stage...they cannot be compared in terms of dance forms being different, and one being a solo while the other is a duet, but the fact remains that she left more of an impact on alot of people, which might have included Shiamak as well...and she's registered noticeable growth from her past performances as well, while Vishal has been good, and is still good, but on the same plane...

Having said that, I do really admire Vishal...and I also think that he is a very talented dancer...would have liked to see him in the semis, but well...such is life...all the best to him for everything...

Cheers! 😊

Very very well said.....!!! 👏