Why her??? - Page 2

Shiamak clearly told Vishal that he is not in the top 5 not bcos he is a bad dancer or not upto the mark but for the finale they needed a girl in the group and the format is such...and WY have almost all phenomenal dancers, its not possible to include everyone. Besides Karishma is fantastic.

Originally posted by: anugupta

I think his reason for choosing Karishma was more for the purpose of letting WY have at least one girl so that they have variety in the types of dances they can do when it comes to duets etc. People like to see romantic dances with lots of lifts, so sometimes its neccessary to have a girl on the team, even if she is slightly overweight.

I think Vishal was just as good as Karishma, but due to the gender aspect I think Shaimak felt it would be more beneficial for WY if she was there insread of Vishal.

Well said this can be a reason, but shiamak shud have said this. It's sooooooooooo stupid to not have bishal, as he's a grrrrt dancer.

Originally posted by: lrl fan

I also seriously hated Shiamak's decision of choosing that girl over Vishal 😡. She might be a good dancer but she is no way better than Vishal who has been 'man of the match' more than once... She also has given too less performances as compared to Vishal... And if Shiamak chose her only to have a female in the team, then I don't think it was right coz I think even the guys can dress and perform like a girl if necessary in the competition (and if girls are necessary, then why did WY have only one girl from the beginning itself??).....

I soo much wanted to see Vishal in the semi-finals but now I am gonna miss him 😭😭😭