Are the judges ALWAYS right

Hi

So do you alwayz agree with the comments of the judges?

Has there been any time when u felt that a contestent has sang well but did not get good remarks or vice-versa?

Plz do Reply

sometimes i feel they r rude n not biased... but we r not singers n they r there n listening them live... so cant say.
but ya somtimes i felt they r biased.

They r correct most of d time but they r pretty rude.

nope nt always right accornding to my discretion..

Their decisions are biased most of the times.

i think they already have their favorites, so they end up passing good coments to them the others are left there with rude remarks. I dint like what anu did to Jolly das although that was his point of view but the others (Farah & Sonu ) dint have to follow his footsteps !I think judges can see others mistakes , they cant see mistakes they make . Last year they choose 2 candidates amit tandon and Ravinder who dint deserve to be in so i figure they should have learnt from their mistakes this time .... seems like nope they havent !!So if they choose them , they got to learn how to deal with the consequence . I dont really know what the future will hold for Jolly now cos she has made it a huge deal episode after episode bringing back the comment that anu passed she should just focus on her singing now and be consistent with it .

I value Sonu's judgement about their singing, sur, taal etc. B'coz i believe he understands music and most of the times explains it without being rude.

Farah's comments about singing............i really don't care b'coz i don't think she understands music that much. But she gives good comments about performance.

And about Anu Malik.............well i do not value his comments, his SHAYARI or music that he makes 🤢 So i really do not care about anything what he does on the show.

Overall i feel the judges are correct most of the times and being rude is a requirement by the channel i guess.

Originally posted by: purva

I value Sonu's judgement about their singing, sur, taal etc. B'coz i believe he understands music and most of the times explains it without being rude.

Farah's comments about singing............i really don't care b'coz i don't think she understands music that much. But she gives good comments about performance.

And about Anu Malik.............well i do not value his comments, his SHAYARI or music that he makes 🤢 So i really do not care about anything what he does on the show.

Overall i feel the judges are correct most of the times and being rude is a requirement by the channel i guess.

well said. exactly my thoughts.

Most of times the comments about singing are okay, because they listen to them live. Anu is very much into his poetry so it is ok. Sonu comments more on music which is good and Farah about the performance and X factor which a singer needs today to match along with stage presence.

i think they are right most of the times