Why Baichung has two 30's and Karan has none

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

manzanas_asadas

@manzanas_asadas

Dazzler

Posted: 16 years ago

#101

I totally agree with you!

Look guys, what is hard for Baichung is no biggie for Karan! It's too easy for Karan!
Expressions for an Actor are the easiest thing! Lip singing is easy for Karan too because he is more used to the industry! I mean onbiously he is in comparison to Baichung!

Why doesn't anyone think before complaining each time? The judges are professionals and before blaming them, you guys should think that the performed would have lacked in at least some place!

The only time I thought judges were unfair are those with Parul! When the professionals gave 10, Juhi gave 9 and that didn't make sense but she has her rights so, oh well!

But guys see ,no bashing and no offense but I am just saying that there is a big difference between a football player becoming a dancer and an actor becoming a dancer! It's easier for the actor!

If you remember, in the first episode, one of the judges (I think Saroj Ji) told Karan that they will be looking forward to him because he is an actor so it will be easy or something! I am not sure about the exact words but it was something like that!

This is my opinion and I really feel that people should look at both the sides of the coin before throwing it away!

Quote

Sonia

@sonia_92

Rocker

+ 6

Posted: 16 years ago

#102

hey hun
i am reelly sorry i am not gonna comment here...coz i knw em not wrong n wht i myt say myt hurt others...n ya jus to tell u whtever i wud b abt to rite if i wud have commented wud not at all b biased!!!
luv sonia

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

srkbest

@srkbest

Inactive

+ 3

Posted: 16 years ago

#103

but if it is a dancing competition then everyone should be put on an equal scale and not compare since he is not an actor its harder for him.....just because they are an actor doesn't mean they know dancing or are a good dancer.

Quote

nandini

@Riddikulus

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 16 years ago

#104

Originally posted by: Wentholic
This was posted by a fan on the DMG forum...hope he/she doesn't mind me posting it here

hey guys ,
my friend visited d jhalak set on saturday ...
Karan is gonna perform with skates
He gets 27 !!!
He does a cartwheel with d skates ..
it was amazing ..
Only Saroj Khan said dat d balance was not good dat was d onli bad comment ...
so watch out for d episode on Friday
tune into Sony entertainment television at 9 PM

@ highlighted....The guy is a freaking non-dancer...those of us who have been watching DMG from the start would testify to this...and he has improved on JDJ with leaps and bounds. Not only that he has taken whatever Nicole has thrown at him as a challenge and put his heart and soul in doing justice to that dance form. But none of these things have impressed the judges... This week he has danced to Disco and that too on skates with an injured foot...but even then SK didn't cut him slack. Can she kindly plz demonstrate to me that exact step with an injured foot with a flawless perf?....If BB had done the same perf a 30 would have been guaranteed....Aakhir mein where BB is concerned.. the judges fav line is... tumko sab mauf hai...whether he forgets to lip sync... or doesn't do a move flawlessly....sab mauf hai.

I so agree with with what Toby and Bhagyashree said... judges have their favs and have a diff criteria for judging each contestant. There is no consistency to their allocation of marks and their comments!

well said Mahez...agreed with the Baichung ko sab maaf bit in perticular...i mean, no offense to any of hi fans, i think he's really sweet and hard-working too, and it's cool if they want to be encouraging and everything, but sometimes a 30 is just over the top...his Rumba with the stairs was good, but i'd give Sonia more credit for the way it turned out...blindfold performance at least in my opinion did not deserve a 30...and even more so because it isn't like the judges didn't see the flaws, they just decided to entirely overlook them, which i thought was extremely unfair, especially to Hard Kaur who had a full 2 marks cut for the exact same fault in the same damn episode...as for the upcoming performance of Karan though, i think i'll reserve my comments till i see the actual performance and the step in question...though i won't be surprised if the Teen Deviyan are at it again, but i think it's only fair that i see it first...

cheers!😃

Quote

monika

@dmgheroARMAAN

Explorer

Posted: 16 years ago

#105

😡😡aik to is forum pe karan ka naam bhi ka naam tak lena aise lagta jaise gunah kar diya hai😕

agar hum fan karan k wajah se judges ya bb ko kuch kahe rahi hain to wo Bhagyashree n Toby ne kyun kaha tha k judge r ubfair

KIA WO BI KARAN K FAN HAIN😆?

if u rmmber hard kour ne bi kise epd m kaa tha k judge r givg coment somethg and marks r somthg?

and one thing more kis bi game show m ye nahi dekha jatna k kis ka kon se background hain

ye important hota hai k ur contstant n how ur r doing ur jb every one is on equally scle

phir chye aap dancer ho ya singer ho ya actor ya aap ka so call nation hero😡

u know what karan fan

jab tak kis achi cheez pe nishan na lage na logn ko maza nahi aata.

so its better k aap yhn karan ke perfms ko dcse na karo.reply m aap ko bashing hi mil gi😡

apna dmg forum hai na wahn chalo bindas ho bol jo bolna hai😆

my first and last post in this jdj forum😃

Quote

Henna 786

@Henna 786

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 16 years ago

#106

Here Here (or K(G)ambae!) *Glass Clinks*

Im rootin for Baichung cuz i think he has improved the most out of the men in the competition, hes showing improvement with each and every performance.. so if he gets 30, it shows. Everyone is at different levels when it comes to getting 30. Hard Kaur proved herself in the first episode, that was her 'standard' in the judges eyes, now when she tops that 'standard bar' she gets higher marks... If Baichung got to the first standard Hard Kaur raised then he would get higher marks as it looks like hes improved - i dnt know if that made sense but yeh .. lol

Quote

Fatima

@Rhimjhimsawan

Sparkler

+ 5

Posted: 16 years ago

#107

Originally posted by: Henna 786
Here Here (or K(G)ambae!) *Glass Clinks*
Im rootin for Baichung cuz i think he has improved the most out of the men in the competition, hes showing improvement with each and every performance.. so if he gets 30, it shows. Everyone is at different levels when it comes to getting 30. Hard Kaur proved herself in the first episode, that was her 'standard' in the judges eyes, now when she tops that 'standard bar' she gets higher marks... If Baichung got to the first standard Hard Kaur raised then he would get higher marks as it looks like hes improved - i dnt know if that made sense but yeh .. lol

😆😆 made sense to me. That's what I think too, and that is one of the resons why Gauhar didn't get 30 even though almost everyone admits she is the best dancer. When you score you don't just take in what you see, the choreography and compare to other performances on that day but a big part of it is how much have you improved from the last one.

Karan might've been bad on his 1st performance, but he got 29 (almost perfect) for his second one. That became his standard. I am sure when the judges gave him that scroe they kept in mind the horrible score from the 1st round. That's why it was a big deal.

For Baichung the guy was horrible in 1st 1-3 rounds, then all of a sudden he loosened up, and started enjoying his performances!