Why Baichung has two 30's and Karan has none

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Wentholic

@Wentholic

Dazzler

Posted: 16 years ago

#71

Thanks guys...ok am off

Shero good to see u here hun *hugs*...drop by the CC sometime..muaz

Quote

Wentholic

@Wentholic

Dazzler

Posted: 16 years ago

#72

Originally posted by: Mickee
oh my god..this is terrible..sorry guys..a simple joke was taken in a completely wrong way..ever since i joined the forum i always told good things about karan..even wrote a post about his straight forwardness too..i like him and i respect him as a good dancer and aa a very diplomatic person who always keeps himself away from the dirty politics..but i just got irritated by the way people are fighting with each other in the forums..its a shame for him too..maybe thats why i replied that way..anyways iam really sorry if i made anybody sad..🤢

It's ok...apology accepted...u just chose the wrong time to joke and on the wrong topic...KSG fans are hurting majorly and in no joking mood...esp me... so peace!😊

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Anjali

@Born-star

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

#73

Originally posted by: Wentholic
Thanks guys...ok am off

Shero good to see u here hun *hugs*...drop by the CC sometime..muaz

Same here 😳
will definitely come to cc next time...
bye me
I am signing off as well😳

Quote

-Veena-

@-Veena-

Trailblazer

+ 5

Posted: 16 years ago

#74

Originally posted by: Steff_DMG
it clear isnt it....THEY ARE COMPENSATING FOR POPULARITY......😡

This is exactly what I am thinking of.... BB is not a dancer and Karan is good and he has a strong fan backing... so if they give BB the marks then it compensates with his low votes...
Where Karan makes up with the votes he gets from us fans...

Due to this the judges are extremely bias.. and really are not doing fair judging at all!!! This is supposed to be competition ..just don't feel like one...

Originally posted by: Wentholic
This was posted by a fan on the DMG forum...hope he/she doesn't mind me posting it here

hey guys ,
my friend visited d jhalak set on saturday ...
Karan is gonna perform with skates
He gets 27 !!!
He does a cartwheel with d skates ..
it was amazing ..
Only Saroj Khan said dat d balance was not good dat was d onli bad comment ...
so watch out for d episode on Friday
tune into Sony entertainment television at 9 PM

@ highlighted....The guy is a freaking non-dancer...those of us who have been watching DMG from the start would testify to this...and he has improved on JDJ with leaps and bounds. Not only that he has taken whatever Nicole has thrown at him as a challenge and put his heart and soul in doing justice to that dance form. But none of these things have impressed the judges... This week he has danced to Disco and that too on skates with an injured foot...but even then SK didn't cut him slack. Can she kindly plz demonstrate to me that exact step with an injured foot with a flawless perf?....If BB had done the same perf a 30 would have been guaranteed....Aakhir mein where BB is concerned.. the judges fav line is... tumko sab mauf hai...whether he forgets to lip sync... or doesn't do a move flawlessly....sab mauf hai.

I so agree with with what Toby and Bhagyashree said... judges have their favs and have a diff criteria for judging each contestant. There is no consistency to their allocation of marks and their comments!

Mahez... hun.. I completely agree with you and am with you in this frustration...
with all the hard work that KG has put it... it just is not making a difference and more so each week has been unique in his own way... he has done a fab job.. bless!!!!

Edited by dmg07 - 16 years ago

Quote

rittu_deep

@rittu_deep

Voyager

Posted: 16 years ago

#75

I am a huge fan of KSG....

But Baichung has improved tremendously than other contestants....

I remember, in the 1st episode, Saroj Khan told him that she sees a future artist in him and if he becomes an artist anyday, she should 1st have the priviledge to make him dance.....Do you think that judges are biased towards him from the 1st episode itself???

Dont forget Saroj Khan is the one who made Madhuri Dixit dance to her tunes.....Who made Madhuri the ultimate dancing icon of Bollywood......It is Saroj Khan.....

We should not forget that judges are the one who are aware of dancing more than anyone else in this forum.....including me who has little knowledge about few forms of dancing....They have 20 times more dancing knowledge than me.....

KSG got lowest marks in the 1st episiode but he never came in dance-off.... Because he had the maximum votes..... Honesly, in his jugalbandi dance, I could not make out what jugalbandi he & Nicole were doing.... He was in folk avatar, so there lip-sync is required......

In Baichung's blindfold performance, he was doing Salsa.... There lip-sync with the song is not required..... You can view the international online videos of Salsa where not always, the dancers are necesserily doing lip-sync with the song if the song has any lyrics....

I agree KSG is good but his improvement level is not so much.... Also his performances are not consistent as per his dancing standard.....Baichung on the other hand, is improving amazingly..... It is always a sheer pleasure to watch him dancing on screen.......

The judges are not biased towards BB.... In his disco dance, many people who watched it thought that it was flawless but judges cut 1 mark each just because he got slightly imbalanced while taking turn... I am sure many people would not have noticed it unless it was pointed by judges.... Saroj Khan was one who detected it.... She could have ignored it and given him 10 marks.....

Quote

OM_Peace

@OM_Peace

Dazzler

Posted: 16 years ago

#76

Originally posted by: dmg07
This is exactly what I am thinking of.... BB is not a dancer and Karan is good and he has a strong fan backing... so if they give BB the marks then it compensates with his low votes...
Where Karan makes up with the votes he gets from us fans...

Due to this the judges are extremely bias.. and really are not doing fair judging at all!!! This is supposed to be competition ..just don't feel like one...

Mahez... hun.. I completely agree with you and am with you in this frustration...
with all the hard work that KG has put it... it just is not making a difference and more so each week has been unique in his own way... he has done a fab job.. bless!!!!

Ditto all of you...

I'm not saying that BB does not deserve a 30. But my point is if he does so does KSG. If you take a look he also started off being a non-dancer and has improved quite a bit. Oh he's not at the level of GK probably, but then the girls - I think most of them came in with a knowledge of dance. The guys were all non dancers..

So its seems wierd that what could be taken as faults in one person are not in someone else.. We have voted for BB also because he has danced fairly well.. but this kind of bias should not be there atleast not on the judges end...

The people vote for their favourites and at that point you choose favourites because thats your right. But judges should be above all oif that and should be absolutely fair.. personalities should not come into their judging at all.. and here they do...

Edited by OM_Peace - 16 years ago

Quote

Wrackspurt

@Wrackspurt

Trailblazer

+ 3

Posted: 16 years ago

#77

Hmmmm..........nicely written post.......Baichung not having solid fan base like Karan is the only thing i cannot agree with u.....i have seen crazy Baichung fans cause i live in his city 😉.....not only that i can say that he has got a solid fan base from maximum of West Bengal and North Eastern part of India.........do not under-estimate his fan base 😉

As far as judges giving 30's to Baichung......well they totally love him so u cannot blame them 😉........like we are someone's fans they are also his fans 😉

Quote

rittu_deep

@rittu_deep

Voyager

Posted: 16 years ago

#78

Anyways, now Baichung has 3 30s in his kitty and not 2......😛

Quote

-Veena-

@-Veena-

Trailblazer

+ 5

Posted: 16 years ago

#79

Originally posted by: mysticwater24
As far as judges giving 30's to Baichung......well they totally love him so u cannot blame them 😉........like we are someone's fans they are also his fans 😉

Judges are there for a reason, not to become Fans of the contestants but to Judge them...

They can love him all they want .... but don't mean they have to be bias... and that completely shows... !!!