I don't think it's fair (wild card) - Page 2

i dont know i kind of liked this wild card approach. Not only does it has the contestants who got eliminated but the ones who barely didnt reach it. Who knows maybe one of them has the foturne of reaching till the end. I just want paulson to be in.

Originally posted by: Tamedtempest

Two things actually.

1) Paulson should be a part of the top 12 regardless of public voting. He was not eliminated like everyone else, he was injured. He shouldn't have to try to get back in like eliminated contestants.

2) The contestants that did not make it into the top 18 (i'll call them the 'new guys').

I don't think it's fair for the new guys to have to compete against previous top 18 contestants. The public already knows and likes the ones that were eliminated, such as sunita, jigar, mandakhani, mangesh, etc. The new guys don't have the same exposure and backing the eliminated contestants do...

what do you guys think??


Also, is Kiran a part of the chance pe dance (or is dance pe chance..?) I don't remember seeing her

i agree totally with the topic starter...i had these point going through my mind since they mentiond who will come through wildcard..last week

i want jigar bak so badly :(

I think Paulson should comptete and come back in the WC that would be fair, competition is competition, you cn be good one day and tank the next so we haven't seen much of his dnce to say he is perfect and needs to be in there directly. We know he is good and he can come back. What happ to Jigar was his bad luck, he tried to take the wieght on his shoulders after Paulson's injury and got out. I also think it is very unfair to the recent eliminated dancers Noni and Prince for not being invited for the WC. And then why do they have Salmans two friends there, if they were good they should have been selected in the top 18, since they weren't that means they weren't good enough. I don't know why but I have a feeling that they have called these two and one of them ( I think the girl) will be selected. The show guys have something up their sleeve otherwise they wouldn't have called them I think. Because of these two newbees the chances of the eliminated contestants have reduced. Mayuresh is an awesome dancer and I think he deserves nother chance but hope he lands up in somebody else's team, I don't like Remo that much so hope none of the returning WC contestnts go to him. Lastly in girls I hope Mandkini gets chance she is good.

Originally posted by: snowflake0555

I agree w/ your first point. Paulson should automatically be in Top 12 since he was "disqualified, not eliminated" because it's not fair...if he comes back as 1/3 Wild Card enteries then it's still not fair..cuz if they automatically re-enter him, they can have THREE extra contestants instead of two... (that is if he even comes back..but I bet he will)

&& I dont think Tanvi and her friend (Salman's friends) should be allowed back since they didn't even make it to the Top 18.

Only the eliminated contestants should be brought back and given a 2nd chance...so yeah I pretty much agree with you..

But w/e...I guess we can't always have what we want =/

i agree. its not fair to the top 18 if the top 40 people start pouring in.

Paulson can't be taken back directly. It is not correct as he didn't perform for two(?) weeks.
I think they wanted to make a round figure(10) and so they included Tanvi, Anshul and Vijay(this guy does only feminine moves.. donno how he ended up getting this chance).

Doesn't anyone like mandakini??? i think she is FABULOUS!! what a body & what a dancer.. don't know many girls who could do the stuf she does.. what say???

Originally posted by: DID-Star

Doesn't anyone like mandakini??? i think she is FABULOUS!! what a body & what a dancer.. don't know many girls who could do the stuf she does.. what say???

Was that girl Kiran or Jayati?

Is it going to be public choice or judge/grand master's choice?