peace_786 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#1
Initially, I have been against public voting bcz I believe that general audience have biases and can sometimes eliminate the more deserving contestant. However, I believe this particular show NEEDS public voting!!
Having only one judge make the decision seems unfair to me, plus mithun does not even be clear on the basis he is judging and on the basis he is making his decisions. We need to know the reasoning!! i think Kiran's elimination today was rlly unjustified. Shubu's elimination made sense coz among the buys he was the weakest but Noni and Rakhee are no better than kiran. Noni is just so overhyped, she does nothing special, infact she is the one who does similar stuff, not Kiran. even rakhee did what she is comfortable in, i clearly remember she did similar stuff in the auditions, can she ever do classical dance??then y were fingers pointed at ONLY kiran?
i rlly hope they introduce public voting on the show OR if that's totally IMPOSSIBLE then atleast they should give the studio audience the right for 50% of the decision. I just think it's NOT fair to have only one person decide!
what do u guys think? should we send an email to zee tv abt this?

Created

Last reply

Replies

8

Views

1k

Users

9

Frequent Posters

Lonelydil4u thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#2
well if theres public voting then 2wks later someone will start complaining that nouni is still in there when she shouldnt be but im glad they theres no public voting...coz towards the end nouni or rakhi will be in the top 2 or 3...which is gonna be funny coz rakhi is not a good dancer at all..n yes kiran is good n all but i thought her expressions n the style of her dance was repetitive as the one in the audtions..n ya rakhi i agree rakhi isnt so great either but i have a feeling she will be like "asma" from saregamapa ...n da only reason nouni is gettin so my hype is coz of her overweight issue..n i guess there jus trying to encourage overweight pplz...i dont know if this is going anywhere but everyone has different opinions ...:)
-JC- thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#3
i was sad to see Kiran go over nouni. I felt Kiran showed more versatility in steps than Nouni. But like Lonelydil4u said.. i think they are making a point by encouraging. They did the same with Kamlesh (guy with the paralysis).. they should have known he could not compete at a highter level with the rest of the contestants.. but for his spirit and encouragement and to allow him the stage to make a point.. they brought him to Mumbai. Nouni can dance but can she beat the flexibility of the rest of them? i don't think so honestly. But they are pushing her forward for encouragement for her and others out there who claim that overweight ppl can't do much.. and also to ecourage people to excersise and be healthier. Its commendable i think.

BUt at the expense of taking the chance from someone who could have gone a longer way? i d k.

I think Rakhi has some raw potential.. so i wouldn't say she is worse than Kiran. Kiran is trained in classical. Rakhi has no training at all.. the difference will show.. but doesn't mean Rakhi can't get better with the training and even beat Kiran at a point. Kiran does use more expression than movements. but her performance was enjoyable. But if this is about Dance and Dance only.. i guess expressions have less importance (though i'd think expressions are very much part of any dance form). Oh well.. i am sure Kiran will continue her dancing and we'll see her again somewhere.

I thought Shubo was awesome in his last performance.. but then the other guys were equally good. I have a feeling Shubo went because he has exams coming up. (don't buy into my conspiracy theories😆 they are just theories). But during auditions he had said that he is in 10th grade and his exams are coming up next month and when asked he said dancing and School both are important to him. I think that might be the reason he was let go of the show.. either its a mutual decision on the part of the show makers and SHubo and his parents.. or maybe the show makers didn't want to be sued for keeping kids away from school.. i heard BV is being sued for something like that.
Edited by jinc118 - 16 years ago
kristie12 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#4
Kiran's elimination was fair. The judges have to eliminate someone by seeing the performance but not by seeing potential. Kiran's performance was not appreciated by the judges and mahaguru. Even Terence looked a bit disappointed with her performance. Nonie's performance on the other hand was appreciated. So, obviously Kiran goes out. That is the rule. They can't send Nonie out giving the reason that Kiran is more versatile. Tht sucks....

As far as public voting is concerned, I think it will be introduced once they have top 12 or 13.
missof77 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#5

i think Kiran's elimination not fair becuzz ,, she dances very well and her expression are too good ,, Nonie is good too but Rakhee should have been out.... becuzz ,, i don't like her dance but i will vote 4 my fav contestant and i think this is not fair wid shubho he not should have been out,, becuzz ,, he is such a too good dancer !!

epilson85 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Andy*

Initially, I have been against public voting bcz I believe that general audience have biases and can sometimes eliminate the more deserving contestant. However, I believe this particular show NEEDS public voting!!

Having only one judge make the decision seems unfair to me, plus mithun does not even be clear on the basis he is judging and on the basis he is making his decisions. We need to know the reasoning!! i think Kiran's elimination today was rlly unjustified. Shubu's elimination made sense coz among the buys he was the weakest but Noni and Rakhee are no better than kiran. Noni is just so overhyped, she does nothing special, infact she is the one who does similar stuff, not Kiran. even rakhee did what she is comfortable in, i clearly remember she did similar stuff in the auditions, can she ever do classical dance??then y were fingers pointed at ONLY kiran?
i rlly hope they introduce public voting on the show OR if that's totally IMPOSSIBLE then atleast they should give the studio audience the right for 50% of the decision. I just think it's NOT fair to have only one person decide!
what do u guys think? should we send an email to zee tv abt this?




Noni sucks like no other! just because she's fat she gets to stay, that's freaking ridiculous!!! she can't dance!!!!!!!!! and rakhi's performance was just club dancing that every other girl is doing! zee tv is pissing me off!!!!!
Aamir's Fan thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: jinc118

i was sad to see Kiran go over nouni. I felt Kiran showed more versatility in steps than Nouni. But like Lonelydil4u said.. i think they are making a point by encouraging. They did the same with Kamlesh (guy with the paralysis).. they should have known he could not compete at a highter level with the rest of the contestants.. but for his spirit and encouragement and to allow him the stage to make a point.. they brought him to Mumbai. Nouni can dance but can she beat the flexibility of the rest of them? i don't think so honestly. But they are pushing her forward for encouragement for her and others out there who claim that overweight ppl can't do much.. and also to ecourage people to excersise and be healthier. Its commendable i think.

BUt at the expense of taking the chance from someone who could have gone a longer way? i d k.

I think Rakhi has some raw potential.. so i wouldn't say she is worse than Kiran. Kiran is trained in classical. Rakhi has no training at all.. the difference will show.. but doesn't mean Rakhi can't get better with the training and even beat Kiran at a point. Kiran does use more expression than movements. but her performance was enjoyable. But if this is about Dance and Dance only.. i guess expressions have less importance (though i'd think expressions are very much part of any dance form). Oh well.. i am sure Kiran will continue her dancing and we'll see her again somewhere.

I thought Shubo was awesome in his last performance.. but then the other guys were equally good. I have a feeling Shubo went because he has exams coming up. (don't buy into my conspiracy theories😆 they are just theories). But during auditions he had said that he is in 10th grade and his exams are coming up next month and when asked he said dancing and School both are important to him. I think that might be the reason he was let go of the show.. either its a mutual decision on the part of the show makers and SHubo and his parents.. or maybe the show makers didn't want to be sued for keeping kids away from school.. i heard BV is being sued for something like that.

Hi! jinc118,
It is so good to see you here.
I completely agree with you on Rakhee. She does have a lot of potential with absolutely no training. I also love her confidence, her attitude and her personality.
desicrowd thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#8
Noni or Rakhee should have been out and not Kiran. This is Dance India and not Dance Bar India. Kiran danced well on her elimination day too and her expressions are her strengths too. It wasn't as if she was standing one place and dacing all the time like what Rakhee did. Kiran's dance represents India and if she was given a good piece to dance she would have executed it well. She was given an Indian Bolly number in the first round and Terrence's choice in the next. Kiran didn't get an opportunity to portray her setern style of dancing. I am sure she can dance western style equally well. As for Noni and Rakhee doing classical...it will be worth watching (in a diff way).
-Ami- thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 16 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: jinc118

i was sad to see Kiran go over nouni. I felt Kiran showed more versatility in steps than Nouni. But like Lonelydil4u said.. i think they are making a point by encouraging. They did the same with Kamlesh (guy with the paralysis).. they should have known he could not compete at a highter level with the rest of the contestants.. but for his spirit and encouragement and to allow him the stage to make a point.. they brought him to Mumbai. Nouni can dance but can she beat the flexibility of the rest of them? i don't think so honestly. But they are pushing her forward for encouragement for her and others out there who claim that overweight ppl can't do much.. and also to ecourage people to excersise and be healthier. Its commendable i think.

BUt at the expense of taking the chance from someone who could have gone a longer way? i d k.

I think Rakhi has some raw potential.. so i wouldn't say she is worse than Kiran. Kiran is trained in classical. Rakhi has no training at all.. the difference will show.. but doesn't mean Rakhi can't get better with the training and even beat Kiran at a point. Kiran does use more expression than movements. but her performance was enjoyable. But if this is about Dance and Dance only.. i guess expressions have less importance (though i'd think expressions are very much part of any dance form). Oh well.. i am sure Kiran will continue her dancing and we'll see her again somewhere.

I thought Shubo was awesome in his last performance.. but then the other guys were equally good. I have a feeling Shubo went because he has exams coming up. (don't buy into my conspiracy theories😆 they are just theories). But during auditions he had said that he is in 10th grade and his exams are coming up next month and when asked he said dancing and School both are important to him. I think that might be the reason he was let go of the show.. either its a mutual decision on the part of the show makers and SHubo and his parents.. or maybe the show makers didn't want to be sued for keeping kids away from school.. i heard BV is being sued for something like that.

I agree wiht you about everything you've said. About your theory of Shubho's, I had never even thought of that much.😛

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".