Zeeeeee - Beeeee Original

Page

josh2008

@josh2008

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

All of the audition rounds very ditto copied from Indian Idol auditions. A to Zee copy copy - the queues, the stickers, the sets, the judges desk, the judges comments........ gosh, it was like can u think of at least ONE thing different?????????? oh yeah i forgot one thing was original, kismat ki topi, haha!!

didnt expect that from Zee Tv. Can be more original and creative then that i hope?

I hope going further they dont try to copy the sets, and the comments - and teach the judges to have some minimum sophistication as well.

Quote

Frequent Posters

66567

Suspended

Posted: 17 years ago

Last I heard, Indian Idol was a singing show.. havent really seen a single episode of it.. but when it comes to giving feedback..the comments wont be that different.. there is only so much a judge can say to compliment a contestant unless you want them to carry a thesaurus around..😎.. the words they use are everyday words which one would use when speaking in a casual conversation, ie "fantastic, mindblowing😆,".. is that called imitating another show or another judge..? 😛 ... and i dont think its a big deal if their sets are same..? i mean its an open auditorium.. do you want them to plant flowers around the wall or on the stage..?

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Jessi

@mz.jess

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 17 years ago

I dont really see how its similar?

if you care to explain other then the set, and their comments..

and yeah Indian Idol is a singing contest and this is a dance contest, seems pretty different to me,

Quote

apux

@apux

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

LOL, and who did Indian Idol copy??? But obviously the concepts are different from the two shows and everyone has to have audition rounds for any competition....

Quote

josh2008

@josh2008

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

Originally posted by: mz.jess
I dont really see how its similar?
if you care to explain other then the set, and their comments..

and yeah Indian Idol is a singing contest and this is a dance contest, seems pretty different to me,

gosh, if you need to be explained how it is similar then its better left it at that itself... i mean come on, the way they have packaged and presented all the initial rounds, the people standing in queues, opening doors, contestants running, going inside 2 closed doors, one funny guy standing out trying to ape hussain, judges building suspense to say ohhh u got the topi!, the contestant running out the doors........everything!! only difference is its a dance show as you noticed that!!! they couldnt have copied all of this in a singing competition without stepping on copyright issues so they did it for a dance show!! how very original!!!

Quote

josh2008

@josh2008

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

Originally posted by: apux
LOL, and who did Indian Idol copy??? But obviously the concepts are different from the two shows and everyone has to have audition rounds for any competition....

well, i am not advocating indian idol here, indian idol is based anyways on american idol and it is there in the title page itself saying concept based on blah blah...

Quote

desicrowd

@desicrowd

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 17 years ago

All Indian shows are copies of shows from other countries. This show may not be a copy of Indian idol. However, after seeing the format of the show today, of how the teams were divided into groups of their choreographers. This show is a copy of an American show Dance War: Bruno vs. Carrie Ann

Edited by desicrowd - 17 years ago

Quote

Aamir's Fan

@Aamir's Fan

Voyager

Posted: 17 years ago

Originally posted by: mz.jess
I dont really see how its similar?
if you care to explain other then the set, and their comments..

and yeah Indian Idol is a singing contest and this is a dance contest, seems pretty different to me,

My thoughts exactly 😊

Quote

Simran

@~Simz~

Dazzler

Posted: 17 years ago

It is somewhat similar to American Idol(I haven't watched Indian Idol) but thats the more reason its fun to watch. I loved the concept and every show has its own creativity. The show has just began and I think its fair that we wait for more episodes to make a comparision.

Quote

Zeeeeee - Beeeee Original

Related Topics

Explore Topics