Why was Bhanu Silenced ??

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Aisha_86

@Aisha_86

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#11

I agree with all of you!

It's really annoying how the judges choose their favourites. I don't think they should openly say, how much one contestant is THATTT good and from another contestant they do expect bad singing... It doesn't suit judges to be biased, coz why are they judges then?

My opinion is that even during the selection when they first said No to bhanu, he sang better than the to girls he had to sing with (one was torsha, other one i dont know). But just to show the audience a little drama, they showed how they first said NO and afterwards had such a good heart to say YES...

Bhanu is being used from the beginning as a TRP raiser... He has come to the Indian Idol parts too..

I Really don't trust Indian Idol anymore.. maybe he's even one of their people? Maybe they are working on this together? Why would they als have said "no" to such a good singer?

Stupid show

Quote

calizgurl

@calizgurl

Explorer

Posted: 16 years ago

#12

To me shinni is reli fake and she is using marriage as an excsue in this competion. Acting all innocent and she just tries to act gud when she was caught on camera calling bhanu a skinny something whtever whtever she called him the jidges didnt say anything to her but whtever she said about the judges simply believed her and went at bhanu ........... i felt so bad for him and like he didnt even get a chance to clarrify his side of the story. i swear this week i want tht two faced miss im married and inocent out!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

look i am here

@look i am here

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#13

Originally posted by: Aisha_86
I agree with all of you!
My opinion is that even during the selection when they first said No to bhanu, he sang better than the to girls he had to sing with (one was torsha, other one i dont know). But just to show the audience a little drama, they showed how they first said NO and afterwards had such a good heart to say YES...

Bhanu is being used from the beginning as a TRP raiser... He has come to the Indian Idol parts too..

I Really don't trust Indian Idol anymore.. maybe he's even one of their people? Maybe they are working on this together? Why would they als have said "no" to such a good singer?

Stupid show

Bhanu comes an humble background. The channel knows that his family wont be in a position to file a defamation suit or claim damages. So these smart show producers are using his image as per their whims. Isn't there a saying ----- A poor man's wife is everybody's saali.

The channel is raising its TRP at the cost of Bhanu's reputation and mental peace. Imagine what a person's state of mind would be after seeing such things being said and telecast before crores of people. It will definitely affect his performance ......On top of it, they shot the next episode (to be telecast this Friday) on Saturday, immediately after the elimination was shot.

Edited by look i am here - 16 years ago

Quote

Ms.SK

@Ms.SK

Trailblazer

+ 7

Posted: 16 years ago

#14

Agree with you all. Did not like the comments made by Javed Akhtar something like "people will not forget etc". To keep Bhanu in we the people should make sure we do forget the whole scenario and get the shaddi shuda out and her other acompolish (the girls who were agreeing with her). These girls know they are not that great and are jealous. So please vote for Bhanu on the basis of his singing and not on his manners etc.

Quote

tim123

@tim123

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#15

Really, Shini has been pretty cunning in showcasing her "shadi shuda" angle..But she does not realize that she will get votes only if she concentrates on her talent and not on these diplomacies.

I also feel showcasing "visit to grandmother" to garner votes is pretty disgusting. These are so personal and touching moments when somebody in your family is sick. The moment needs genuine praying by family members rather than using it as an opportunity for any gains...!

Earlier I had respect for Shini as I support women for their career (in any field). Now that she showcased her cunningness, I will take a back seat in voting for her...

Quote

Aphrodite

@Showbizz

Dazzler

Posted: 16 years ago

#16

Originally posted by: Ms.S.K.

Agree with you all. Did not like the comments made by Javed Akhtar something like "people will not forget etc". To keep Bhanu in we the people should make sure we do forget the whole scenario and get the shaddi shuda out and her other acompolish (the girls who were agreeing with her). These girls know they are not that great and are jealous. So please vote for Bhanu on the basis of his singing and not on his manners etc.

Javed Aktar doesnt know that people do have brains and maybe have a better sense of judgement😉 . Atleast most of the people found shini's comments more disgusting and wanted to listen to Bhanu's story .

And now if Shini gets voted out they will come out with the shaadi shudha , ladki idol ban nahin sakti saga AAAAAAAAAAArgh😡😡 .

Quote

ritzbitz

@ritzbitz

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#17

there are 14 people squeezed in there. frictions are but obvious. that's so human. what are we doing here? arent we being judgemental, dissecting their nature's?

my only grudge being, dont try to do such a bad job on the editor's table. show some transperancy , which would look real.

Quote

@pksanam

Rocker

Posted: 16 years ago

#18

i just started watching II, so i haven't been following it from the beginning.. but from what i saw, i think Bhanu seems to be targeted..

and i can't believe shini is using this 'i'm shaadi shuda, so respect me' attitude.. what does that mean.. that anyone who is not married does not..?

seems more like they are jeolous of Bhanu.. and surprise, surprise.. they don't let him say a single word.. that means that they know that they are the ones at fault..!!

Quote

Vijay

@cool.aquarian

Explorer

Posted: 16 years ago

#19

Now I hope she is not brought back again (cant tolerate her anymore) and may she rest in peace.

Quote

spunkpattinson

@spunkpattinson

Voyager

Posted: 16 years ago

#20

u noe i wasnt a fan of bhannu before the whole fiasco butt especiallyy after javed ji's remarks that i have still nt forgotten wat u did made me feel that these judges dnt reallyy luk at the two sides of the coin!!

just comment on things without any proper evidences

and after this fiasco i am proudly a bhannu fan!!! and want him to go to top 3!!