Doctors Vs Swamiji

7387_nidhi

@7387_nidhi

Navigator

10

Posted: 17 years ago

#1

In India, I have heard about a lot of 'Swamiji",Sant Ji" who always have healing touch and I have never heard one person who can really be cared by all these.

They most often turn out to be frauds. I have seen people in my immediate family believe in them more than the doctors.

My question is in 21st century, should they not show that medicine will help. ( OK, not going to evil doctors like varun), but if Saloni does not want to accept defeat, she should go to AIIMS, or the other big hospitals in India, they are so rich they can easily go to US,UK to get treated.

Why do they want to show to the people that it is OK to go to Swamiji fo rtreatment and not consult a better doctor.

Reply

Quote

Reatta23

@Reatta23

Beginner

3

Posted: 17 years ago

#2

umm...coz this is a serial, totally fiction. its not meant as a real life story, or as a moral teaching lesson. you watch it for entertainment. i dont understand why some people take it as something to follow and learn things from...its not meant to be that, hence, the disclaimer at the beginning that says that all characters, and events are fictitious.

Reply

Quote

ramas

@ramas

Alumni

39

+ 5

Posted: 17 years ago

#3

Originally posted by: Reatta23
umm...coz this is a serial, totally fiction. its not meant as a real life story, or as a moral teaching lesson. you watch it for entertainment. i dont understand why some people take it as something to follow and learn things from...its not meant to be that, hence, the disclaimer at the beginning that says that all characters, and events are fictitious.

I agree with you in a way.

But we get too attached to the serials and feel like they are real and get emotional.

Edited by ramas - 17 years ago

Reply

Quote

ramas

@ramas

Alumni

39

+ 5

Posted: 17 years ago

#4

Originally posted by: 7387_nidhi
In India, I have heard about a lot of 'Swamiji",Sant Ji" who always have healing touch and I have never heard one person who can really be cared by all these.
They most often turn out to be frauds. I have seen people in my immediate family believe in them more than the doctors.

My question is in 21st century, should they not show that medicine will help. ( OK, not going to evil doctors like varun), but if Saloni does not want to accept defeat, she should go to AIIMS, or the other big hospitals in India, they are so rich they can easily go to US,UK to get treated.

Why do they want to show to the people that it is OK to go to Swamiji fo rtreatment and not consult a better doctor.

But when a vaid (ayurvedic doctor touches you they can tell you pretty much what is wrong with you.by feeling your pulse.

i have been to vaid who never knew me or nothing about me . One time I jst went with my brother and he told me all what is wrong with my health and what should I do about it.

Also here doctor said you are dying even though falsely. In that case mos ppl turn to nature.

My grand ma had throat cancer in 4th stage and we went to vaidya and he helped for few months when alopathy had said they can do anything. She lived 4 months peacfully then we truned to homeopathy as doctors could not feed her intraveinously. But homeopathy helped her eating small meals and jucie till teh last day.

let us take the ramdevbaba who helps ppl cure with his natural medicines and yoga.

many ppl turn to natropathy here as well when doctors say the case is out of their hand.

In fact ppl who recently visit India who are not Indians many of them go to India to get cure form long term ailment. as they are tired of medicines which has lot more side effects.

Most medicines treat symtoms and are not cure or don't kill the root of problem. Lke ayurved or homeopathy does.

Edited by ramas - 17 years ago

Reply

Quote

Alifya

@Dragonfly

Inactive

3

Posted: 17 years ago

#5

umm...coz this is a serial, totally fiction. its not meant as a real life story, or as a moral teaching lesson. you watch it for entertainment. i dont understand why some people take it as something to follow and learn things from...its not meant to be that, hence, the disclaimer at the beginning that says that all characters, and events are fictitious.

You keep saying this over and over again. It is a serial, fiction and for entertainment. How many of these people are able to understand that this does not apply to real life drama. People who are desperately in need of help may not think rationally at trying times and will resort to anything even something far fetched shown in serials and fall prey to unscrupulous beings who are out there to fleece them instead of helping them. So serials although showing it for entertainment should ensure that there is basis of reality in the shows.

Reply

Quote

02aug30

@02aug30

Inactive

4

Posted: 17 years ago

#6

I agree with you ramas, my fathers has neck problem and doctors in USA said the he need an operation. we consulted 4 best doctors here but all of them said operation which was even more riskier. My father went to india to this person who had "baksh" and in 2 months everything was fine.
so i think there is nothing wrong with going to vaid b/c allopatic medicine does not have the answer for everything, there are limitation for even allopatic medicine. The overall idea is to get better.

Reply

Quote

-Happy4Ever-

@-Happy4Ever-

Inactive

17

Posted: 17 years ago

#7

I agree with Ayrvedic medicines and Vaid concept but Swamiji is not shown as Vaid. He sent the medicine without even seeing Nahar. This seems suspicious.

Reply

Quote

juhi92

@juhi92

Inactive

3

Posted: 17 years ago

#8

that right this is 21 century but some people believe in god that make them to go that kind of places. In India lots Sawamiji help lots of people get better. my one friend grand mom get healthy by that kind of medicines that sawamili gave to her. i also believe is right to show sawamiji to help Nahar.

Reply

Quote

San

@sanw

Sparkler

32