style or singing?

what applys you more an indian idol contestent,s singing or his/her style,look, etc.
i want see style and singing both.
but i think india,s janta only like an id contestent,s style they dont choose by voice(isn,t it wrong) which i think is not fair.
no offence to anybody. thats what i think😊

I dont know what people want.
They are not voting for looks, you see Mohit.
They are not even voting for talented singers like Rajdeep

Originally posted by: ana2008

I dont know what people want.
They are not voting for looks, you see Mohit.
They are not even voting for talented singers like Rajdeep

I think there are many things but i will try to put them in order :-

Originally posted by: robaroo

I think there are many things but i will try to put them in order :-

1) Most imp is regional votes - it gulps down everythin else eg Prashant

2) Then comes gender based votes , good looking guys always make it to the top

Cos 15-30 age grp females see things thru their own eyes only ..... lolzzzz

eg Sandeep Acharya

3) Then is overall likeabilty factor , it includes how the channel portrays u too

eg Abhijeet Sawant was very likable and the reverse example was Richa

4) Also if u can throw some X-factor ur thru

eg Ankita Mishra

5) Last but not the least SInging 😕

But one thing for sure Indian Idol has genuine voting pattern , its not rigged - i am sure

hmmm.. nice analysis, i must say. And also the vote count out of total will also be decreasing in that order only.

Indian Idol 1 was the most genuine of the lot....after that the contestants and the producers started appealing for regional voting ... they are more interested in making their money in the course of the show itself rather than make money by putting out a really good album. II2 and 3 winners had horrible albums...

Ok very nice question & its d most confusing question which made me so confused so irratatting & angry throw II3..

Originally posted by: robaroo

I think there are many things but i will try to put them in order :-

1) Most imp is regional votes - it gulps downeverythin else eg Prashant

2) Then comes gender based votes , good looking guys always make it to the top

Cos 15-30 age grp females see things thru their own eyes only ..... lolzzzz

eg Sandeep Acharya

3) Then is overall likeabilty factor ,it includes how the channel portrays u too

eg Abhijeet Sawant was very likable and the reverse examplewas Richa

4) Also if u can throw some X-factor ur thru

eg Ankita Mishra

5) Last but not the least SInging [IMG=http://www.india-forums.com/smileys/smiley5.gif" height="17" width="17]Confused[/IMG]

But one thing for sure Indian Idol has genuine voting pattern , its not rigged - i am sure

If I have to agree with you then why isn't Rajdeep getting too many votes, if the factor is regional?
Good looking guy like Mohit got voted out.
Channel didn't portray anyone negative yet.
X factpr is tehre for Mohit or Prasenjeet.
Bhavya was such a great singer but look where she is.

None of teh ananylysis is working for IL4.
Don't know the secret.