judges are sooooooounfair,pls read.

Page

Next Last

ilovenach

@ilovenach

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

Hi guys,

i saw this weeks episode thrice, and u know what i obsrved?THAT THE JUDGES ARE VERY UNFAIR.

I think Naman did a gr8 piece of dance, but their concept was "LOVE &SACRAFICE" which the judges did not understand and said both their expressions were the same, ther was no conflict........ok agreed they did not keep up to the "Aamne saamne concept(which is hum vs tum).

now Shalin &daljit(whose act was gr8 too)made the same mistake, they were shadow vs human, but they were not against each other nor was there any kind of conflict, infact we could not see daljit's expressions but her body language and shalins body language was the same,

for that the judges gave them a full 30.if this is not cheating than what is.

pls comment on this 😡

Quote

Frequent Posters

rihaab

@Rihaab

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: ilovenach
Hi guys,
i saw this weeks episode thrice, and u know what i obsrved?THAT THE JUDGES ARE VERY UNFAIR.

I think Naman did a gr8 piece of dance, but their concept was "LOVE &SACRAFICE" which the judges did not understand and said both their expressions were the same, ther was no conflict........ok agreed they did not keep up to the "Aamne saamne concept(which is hum vs tum).

now Shalin &daljit(whose act was gr8 too)made the same mistake, they were shadow vs human, but they were not against each other nor was there any kind of conflict, infact we could not see daljit's expressions but her body language and shalins body language was the same,

for that the judges gave them a full 30.if this is not cheating than what is.

pls comment on this 😡

i absolutely 100% agree with u. no doubt that daljit and shaleen did an awesome job, but where were dalijits expressions?????????? i mean .....its a shadow dance true, but expessions are the main......this has gone too far....i am sure is rakhie was in the nach she would say something !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Rajji

@-Rajji-

Navigator

Posted: 16 years ago

I disagree! And I'm not baised because I had no favourite jodi before that episode; I was considering going for Mohit-Aditte. I swear when I saw Naman and Megha's preformance, before the judges commented, I was thinking hmm... where's the opposites is this? I thought it was just me, but the judges confirmed that it wasn't. And as for the expressions, obviously they couldn't be seen if she was a shadow. The problem with Naman and Megha's was that when they could be seen they were supposed to show expression. Although I feel besides the fact of the opposites not working for them, their dance was really nice. If only the confusion wasn't lingering throughout it, it would have been great. The only point that I can see as being valid is maybe no conflict, but I'm not sure as I don't really know exactly what the two couples had mapped out for their performances...

Quote

Kavya

@Bazinga

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 16 years ago

I am sorry I disagree with both of you, Shaleen Daljit's concept was reality vs dream(it is this dream which was presented to us in the form of a shadow which also speaks of the choreographers' creativity👏👏) and that they depicted very beautifully. The expressions part was taken as a criterion for the other jodis because the judges could see both their faces, here Daljit's Shadow itself was her expression. Plus it is the theme that is important and not the criterion as criterion keeps changing for each presentation. Shaleen Daljit deserved the marks they got because they stuck to the theme and presented something challenging,unique and different for the first time in NB4. They deserved every mark they got. Please do not take any offense I was only trying to clarify your doubts and express my opinion.

Edited by kavya_luvseizy - 16 years ago

Quote

Sehar Sheikh

@Sehar_Sheikh

Dazzler

Posted: 16 years ago

raj_star and kavya_luvseizy both of you exactly expressed my thoughts.

Quote

Darshana

@darshana23

Inactive

+ 3

Posted: 16 years ago

I am not Shaleen-Daljit fan and nor Naman-Megha..... But whatever comments judges made was correct..... Theme of episode was CONTRAST so hey should have prepared something based on that theme......... About Shaleen-Daljit it was pretty clear from their performance theme was Dream Vs. Reality.......

May be they danced well, but giving them nice scores based on that would be unfair for rest of the jodis who put their effort for this theme....

Quote

Shruti

@shruti

Alumni

+ 9

Posted: 16 years ago

I disagree. The concept was contrast. When Naman-Megha performance stared the first thing that came n my head was what's the concept. They danced extremely well but the concept was not there. About ShaJit it was human & shadow. As a member mentioned reality v/s dream & it suited the theme perfectly.

Quote

jaya

@spyrulzdworld

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

xcuse me naman and megha's dance was gud but they dint perform it according to the concept the concept was opposite whereas shajit were toooo gud they were in sync they performed according to the concept and there was no need of xpressions here as it was a shadow wid a human daljeets body language only showed everything it isnt tht easy to perform like this without seeing each other and u talk abt xpressions even if daljeet wouldnt have been the shadow i am sure she would have had the correct expressions the judges are fair enough they deserved much more than a 30 wooooot

Quote

365702

Suspended

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: ilovenach
Hi guys,
i saw this weeks episode thrice, and u know what i obsrved?THAT THE JUDGES ARE VERY UNFAIR.

I think Naman did a gr8 piece of dance, but their concept was "LOVE &SACRAFICE" which the judges did not understand and said both their expressions were the same, ther was no conflict........ok agreed they did not keep up to the "Aamne saamne concept(which is hum vs tum).

now Shalin &daljit(whose act was gr8 too)made the same mistake, they were shadow vs human, but they were not against each other nor was there any kind of conflict, infact we could not see daljit's expressions but her body language and shalins body language was the same,

for that the judges gave them a full 30.if this is not cheating than what is.

pls comment on this 😡

Yaa yaar Am 100% agree with u......

its really really unfair judges.....😡