I watched few scenes from past few days... I found two scenes where i would like to compare Ro-Ki and Ro-Ka..
1) Cottage Scene -
Robbie-Kasturi ->
Remember the scene when Ro-Ka confesses their love and they got stranded over their... It was starting of Tu hai wohi.... There was no actual kissing scene but that one scene where Ro tries to kiss Kasturi makes the blast....
Forget about this, lets say they were closed to each other.. But remember another cottage scene because of Massi's plan.. There was so much distance but still it puts fire...
Robbie-Kiran ->
When Ro-Ki gets stranded... there was everything....closeness,distance... In fact they showed that Kiran changes clothes.. But still this doesnt do anything.... I was so much irritated in watching this scene... I simply fast-forwarded..............
2) Door-Scene ->
Robbie-Kasturi -
It was scene after Raunak's entry with memory lost.... Ro and Ka standing behind door and crying for each other.. in back ground Kabhi Alvida na kehna.....so much passion, so much pain... Even i feel like crying.......
Robbie-Kiran ->
Same situation........Ro and Ki standing behind door and crying.... dont know for whom.... and in background Kabhi alvida na kehna......
I feel Kiran even dont know how to cry?????? I think director forgot to ask her to put some glycerine.....
There was no feeling at all... Even I feel that though Karan was brilliant actor that scene was not worth...
I know you will also have some scenes to discuss.. you can share your opinion.... This was only two scenes i watched till now in last two weeks.... Even I know now, i wont be able to tolerate such scenes.. so its better to stay away from it.........