Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 41 - Page 88

Just to be clear, last time it was Ronnie, this time it is Mannat.

But uska apna kaand that noone knows, about Yuvi, that was in the interval of 7 years. The divorce papers again, was her doing, noone knows. What I am saying is, these issues, will it ever come out in front of the characters? Like she tried to kill Vik twice, while married twice; noone knows about it.

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Moor you missed my last line just for accepting that their lies caused so much damage , I will throw her a bone and nothing else. I never fell for her WW pre-leap and never will in future unless she decides to sacrifice her life for Mannat or Vikrant, maybe I can think about it.

Hey bhagwan ye kya maang liya... ab jo whitewash main itna paisa kharcha hua hai uska kya hoga 😝

Nope they are not, she will be saved by someone or the other even if they come out. She may have a long term contract with the producer's

Our lovely forum is slowly limping back to life

Keep the discussion going ladies... having great fun reading all this...

And please take it lightly... not a dig at anyone... but do you realize why you and everyone else is suddenly pro Vik and anti DK 🙈

This is what I was trying to say... Vik should have been shown redeemed without making DK flip for Mannat... he could have remained a possessive father which makes sense but only a platonic and true supporter of Mannat...

Him developing feelings suddenly makes us question (myself including) about his motives for Mannat!!!!

Unfortunately and indirectly this is not a great writing for Vik... Vik should have been a better man in front of a good man and not a better man in front of dubious man which is what is happening now!!!!

I am all for ManViks reunion... it could have been an even more rewarding redemption for Vik had DK been a secure non grey person 😐

You are free to watch what entertains you and skip when you wish...

What I meant to say is... there are some good scenes in between that keep the story balanced and drama going...

But they dont pick it up due to change in narrative or it doesn't fit the storyline anymore... and thats creates an issue... it does for us loyal viewers too!!!

We too are frustrated with this inconsistency... who's to blame for this... I am not sure...

An important example I can quote for you is Vik/Aman BDB on seashore. The moment they got Vishakha... it was clear it wont matter now. Because as per that FB... Amans mom is dead... but if Vish is alive, that fall from terrace doesnt make sense.

There are countless viewers who have still not come to terms with this.

Vish ke entry ka decision kiska tha... we wont know... so crib as much as we want... that part is not coming back ever. 😭

Yuvi is not Vinu just because he is around Vik... Vinu was their first born and P as surrogate (which was BTW another example of how ITV rules do not follow real life 🤦‍♀️).. cant compare Vinu and Yuvi.

Yuvi is simply a prop used by Malla and Y to be around Vik. Malla is currently ignored so they dont need Yuvi. Same with Y as Vik is her fiance and Yuvis usability is over... they may simply end his character and it would not affect the story. That wasnt the case with Vinu.

Originally posted by: Mona_HappyLife

No I did not say you or anyone forgave RoTu. My comment is for the post stating that Neetu realized her pre leap mistake & implying that she is doing the right thing now is like undermining the entire trauma that Mannat has gone thru...

RoTu are the main catalysts of the issues and they are 99% responsible for the havoc they created in ManVik's life.

Mannat wasn't even born when this happened...Still she tried with whatever she could from her end only to be blamed left & right...

Mona I’ve been absent from the forum with the emotionally heavy drama, but have been watching the show and popping on here to get more insights.

This isn’t directed at you personally, but just a post with interesting discussions of the other influencing characters.

There comes a point when we recognise and give full sympathies for what both leads have suffered, through their own mistakes, at the hands of the other and through the huge web of deceit around them.
And then move on to considering what is best for Dua.

Dua is 6 years old and brought up by her mother, so is her primary carer. DK has held the father’s role since her birth, it’s irrelevant if he’s a good or -ve character.

Vikrant is the birth father, who wasn’t aware Mannat was pregnant, which under new narrative, everyone else accepts. He has requested to be part of Dua life, nothing more, nor to take away her baba’s role.

Dua has developed a very strong bond with Vikrant (and vv), independently and without any influence from anyone else, with no labels attached other than her good friend and hero. In the time they’ve spent together she’s sought out and enjoyed his company. In the bts drew a picture of herself with Vik and Mannat (minus DK) demonstrating at her young age, her bond with Vikrant. The adults can make their own life choices, but who advocates for Dua’s choices and decisions if she wishes that bond to continue? Her mother and baba (who are making decisions on her behalf) carry their own baggage and aren’t taking her already established bond into consideration. At this young age, she will forget and move in easily, but is that fair when in years to come she learns Vikrant is her biological father, hadn’t been aware of her birth, but wanted to keep contact with her when he found out, but her mother and baba denied it. Unless they can justify Vikrant posed a huge danger to Dua by being in her life, it seems unfair to Dua to have denied her that.
You can’t turn to clocks back and relive lost years as Mannat knows from her own relationship with Anirudh.

Originally posted by: Shazia_h

Mona I’ve been absent from the forum with the emotionally heavy drama, but have been watching the show and popping on here to get more insights.

This isn’t directed at you personally, but just a post with interesting discussions of the other influencing characters.

There comes a point when we recognise and give full sympathies for what both leads have suffered, through their own mistakes, at the hands of the other and through the huge web of deceit around them.
And then move on to considering what is best for Dua.

Dua is 6 years old and brought up by her mother, so is her primary carer. DK has held the father’s role since her birth, it’s irrelevant if he’s a good or -ve character.

Vikrant is the birth father, who wasn’t aware Mannat was pregnant, which under new narrative, everyone else accepts. He has requested to be part of Dua life, nothing more, nor to take away her baba’s role.

Dua has developed a very strong bond with Vikrant (and vv), independently and without any influence from anyone else, with no labels attached other than her good friend and hero. In the time they’ve spent together she’s sought out and enjoyed his company. In the bts drew a picture of herself with Vik and Mannat (minus DK) demonstrating at her young age, her bond with Vikrant. The adults can make their own life choices, but who advocates for Dua’s choices and decisions if she wishes that bond to continue? Her mother and baba (who are making decisions on her behalf) carry their own baggage and aren’t taking her already established bond into consideration. At this young age, she will forget and move in easily, but is that fair when in years to come she learns Vikrant is her biological father, hadn’t been aware of her birth, but wanted to keep contact with her when he found out, but her mother and baba denied it. Unless they can justify Vikrant posed a huge danger to Dua by being in her life, it seems unfair to Dua to have denied her that.
You can’t turn to clocks back and relive lost years as Mannat knows from her own relationship with Anirudh.

Hey Shazia !!

Yes you are absolutely right. But as I mentioned before that since ManVik didn't separate under normal circumstances so breaking the truth of Vikrant being Dua's dad right now is a big emotional challenge to overcome. Dua bonding with Vikrant now doesn't mean she would bond the same way once she comes to know the truth.

She will have 100 & 1000s of questions to ask. Also to note the MUs between ManVik are yet to be cleared, there are 100s of other secrets to come out so on what basis Mannat will clear the doubts that little Dua is gonna have now ?

This news should be told to her gradually & not all of a sudden & definitely not through a custody case. Today ManVik even agreed upon the idea but it is Neetu who is spoiling everything just because she want to be the "Mahaan Maata" & wants to do her own 'paap ka prayaschit' even if it is done at the cost of the mental sanity of Mannat & Dua...

And honestly you cannot bring back someone to another person's life zabardasti ka. It takes time for everyone to heal. Mannat is already softening towards him since the time she came to Mumbai, so this issue can be solved even now with grace & maturity....

And to add, we still don't know where Yashika will fit into all of these. DK might end up joining hands later on...

Malla will be here anyways as Yuvi secret still needs to be ousted...

I do not want to see submissive Vikrant

.I want him.to.fight for his kid