Seher Hone Ko Hai - Masterpiece Banane Ke Chakkar Mein Mazak Bana Diya

JustRandomGirl thumbnail
Posted: 20 days ago
#1

Don’t get me wrong this show actually started out well and had potential to be a masterpiece. Unfortunately, it will be remembered as a controversial show. The storyline itself has already raised question due to the possible promotion of underage marriage and romanticizing such couple.

However due to how the lead characters were written individually, and the amazing chemistry of the leads, this show managed to create a decent fanbase for itself.


But the recent offscreen drama has grabbed more headlines than the show itself. And that is not good. Firstly, Rangu/Colors is a biased channel. But this is the first time they have been extremely biased towards a show I liked smiley37 Let’s be honest. This show NEVER had good trps, yeah I get the timeslot was bad, but how is it 2 shows of the rival channel can gain high trps in that timeslot but not this?! I dont understand TRP but all I know is the higher the TRP longer the show will survive.

And on top of that they even listened to fans demand and gave this show a prime time slot of 8.30pm smiley3 despite the low trps. Yeah I get the show has probably the most social media buzz even without the offscreen controversies but at the end of the day it is trp that matters. There were many more ITV shows that had great social media buzz but low trps, and those eventually ended way earlier. SHKH makers have been lucky the channel favoured their show a lot. Colors even promote this show more than their other shows.

But they have not utilized it at all lol! Firstly to the makers of the show, if you have a timeslot change to a better timings you make the best use of it! They had such a golden opportunity and great setup (since Mahid found out Seher age and declared divorce)

to take a leap from timeslot change onwards.
Many fans have been demanding to get rid of the problematic underage factor, but no adamant makers are hell bent to promote romance despite the illegal age?! Why even show the divorce then?! The whole Gazala mystery could have been shown after the leap also cause that track is actually interesting!


And then the lead actors offscreen. Male lead is already a popular face and let me be honest I really disliked him in his prev shows , but he has managed to somewhat change my perspective on him in this show. I thought he has been extremely dedicated to his character and done well so far.

The female lead is a newbie and actually talented. She has actually been quite good in some of her scenes, but in some she has been flat. But she doesnt seem to be very passionate about her work. She seems to be more invested in other things but the show. Its a pity cause she does have potential.

I dont like to talk about actors/actresses personal life but why is the partner allowed to be on the sets always?! Its obvious that the partner will get insecure seeing their other half doing romantic scenes with someone else though its a shoot! Very unprofessional from both the female lead and the makers to even allow it lol!

Looks like the main purpose was not to show message against underage marriage or romance, but to create controversies. What could have been masterpiece is now a joke!

Created

Last reply

Replies

10

Views

1k

Users

6

Likes

19

Frequent Posters

RockingSunny thumbnail
Posted: 20 days ago
#2

I don't understand. Can't drama and entertainment be shown when seher is trying to build her career?? The writers could have done lots of things to save the show. But instead they focused on underage romance hence this result. The leap could have made it better but instead it became worse. Anyways this is not new. There are many more shows which started off progressive but got ruined in a worse way. Some like anupama still survives but other shows gets low trps and hence shuts down

JustRandomGirl thumbnail
Posted: 20 days ago
#3

Originally posted by: RockingSunny

I don't understand. Can't drama and entertainment be shown when seher is trying to build her career?? The writers could have done lots of things to save the show. But instead they focused on underage romance hence this result. The leap could have made it better but instead it became worse. Anyways this is not new. There are many more shows which started off progressive but got ruined in a worse way. Some like anupama still survives but other shows gets low trps and hence shuts down

Seher in recent episode looks like she forgot her dream is to be a doctor. Her husband divorced her and clearly told her she should focus on her dreams but she is lovesick smiley44Before the divorce, I really loved Seher’s character but after that she has been weird. I couldnt fully connect to her confession to Mahid on Eid only cause she is too young. Strong words but Seher girl focus on your studies pls don’t be a Nibbi smiley18

They could have still shown the care and affection she has for Mahid that was enough. They only brought a 15 days leap smiley36 To probably show suspense their divorce can be nullified within 3 months due to the Islamic rules.

Also I feel Seher band Mahid are well written characters, but last week episodes look so out of character for both especially Seher. Yeah they are good support for each other but it would have been better if they reunited after Seher was of age. They already show Mahid being supportive they could have shown him supporting her while she is doing her MBBS.

Edited by JustRandomGirl - 20 days ago
Phir_Mohabbat thumbnail
Posted: 20 days ago
#4

16 year old KID busy to give moony eyes to ex husband and crying cause he's giving divorce


I also say writing is trash cause mahid can chipko with his wife but can't make her understand how wrong their marriage was and they should move on in life. What a stupid character.


And these fls are always poking their nose into house drama. Mahids mother has been dead for long time, why seher getting into it? She want to be in cid not doctor..would be a trash one where she kill her patient to notice mahid

RockingSunny thumbnail
Posted: 20 days ago
#5

Originally posted by: JustRandomGirl

Seher in recent episode looks like she forgot her dream is to be a doctor. Her husband divorced her and clearly told her she should focus on her dreams but she is lovesick smiley44Before the divorce, I really loved Seher’s character but after that she has been weird. I couldnt fully connect to her confession to Mahid on Eid only cause she is too young. Strong words but Seher girl focus on your studies pls don’t be a Nibbi smiley18

They could have still shown the care and affection she has for Mahid that was enough. They only brought a 15 days leap smiley36 To probably show suspense their divorce can be nullified within 3 months due to the Islamic rules.

Also I feel Seher band Mahid are well written characters, but last week episodes look so out of character for both especially Seher. Yeah they are good support for each other but it would have been better if they reunited after Seher was of age. They already show Mahid being supportive they could have shown him supporting her while she is doing her MBBS.

Exactly. I mean OK there can be love. But atleast show that in a friendly manner for now coz sehar's purpose is to complete her MBBS and become a doctor. If they wanted to attract viewers there are lots of ways to attract them but writers choosed the wrong way

And if offscreen controversy is hampering the show then there's somewhere a fault in the management by the production house

awida thumbnail
Deal or No Deal Thumbnail 12th Anniversary Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 20 days ago
#6

I have no problem with Seher's age, or romance between leads.. it is allowed in my religion. And many ppl start romancing at such age even in other religions. Seher is mature, and not behaving like a child.

I am happy this show didn't take leap. It is important to get matters solved and secrets come out. I hate it when separation happens where 2 leads are heart broken.

I don't find channel decision to change the timeslot strange. As this show is a hit off screen. And even TRPs system is getting changed soon, because the popularity of the show in social media and other platforms is no less important, and should be considered.. as it reaches more audience, and the channels benefit of it .

I am only sad that Rishita chose to be unprofessional. The girl is talented. And I am afraid she may get replaced if she doesn't change her attitude.

rachufan thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 19 days ago
#7

Do you know sabse mazedaar baat ye hai their divorce process has not been competed yet he is doing engagement

Pehle high standard set karte hai phir character ka kachra kar dete hai 🤷‍♀️



And off screen drama on the day of celebration day it was looking fine

Jada close to kabhi lage hi nahi . Mujhe to pehle bhi lagta tha they are only professional cordial


But time slot change hote hi kya bomb blast kiya hai kya hua agar writer wahi atki hui hai hmare leads ne khud hi pura show famous kar diya 😂😂now everybody knows there is a show sehar hone ko hai 😂😂


Tbh I have seen ivs parth was also mentioned audience is not liking nazima track

tvfan75 thumbnail
Posted: 19 days ago
#8

Originally posted by: JustRandomGirl

Don’t get me wrong this show actually started out well and had potential to be a masterpiece. Unfortunately, it will be remembered as a controversial show. The storyline itself has already raised question due to the possible promotion of underage marriage and romanticizing such couple.

However due to how the lead characters were written individually, and the amazing chemistry of the leads, this show managed to create a decent fanbase for itself.


But the recent offscreen drama has grabbed more headlines than the show itself. And that is not good. Firstly, Rangu/Colors is a biased channel. But this is the first time they have been extremely biased towards a show I liked smiley37 Let’s be honest. This show NEVER had good trps, yeah I get the timeslot was bad, but how is it 2 shows of the rival channel can gain high trps in that timeslot but not this?! I dont understand TRP but all I know is the higher the TRP longer the show will survive.

And on top of that they even listened to fans demand and gave this show a prime time slot of 8.30pm smiley3 despite the low trps. Yeah I get the show has probably the most social media buzz even without the offscreen controversies but at the end of the day it is trp that matters. There were many more ITV shows that had great social media buzz but low trps, and those eventually ended way earlier. SHKH makers have been lucky the channel favoured their show a lot. Colors even promote this show more than their other shows.

But they have not utilized it at all lol! Firstly to the makers of the show, if you have a timeslot change to a better timings you make the best use of it! They had such a golden opportunity and great setup (since Mahid found out Seher age and declared divorce)

to take a leap from timeslot change onwards.
Many fans have been demanding to get rid of the problematic underage factor, but no adamant makers are hell bent to promote romance despite the illegal age?! Why even show the divorce then?! The whole Gazala mystery could have been shown after the leap also cause that track is actually interesting!


And then the lead actors offscreen. Male lead is already a popular face and let me be honest I really disliked him in his prev shows , but he has managed to somewhat change my perspective on him in this show. I thought he has been extremely dedicated to his character and done well so far.

The female lead is a newbie and actually talented. She has actually been quite good in some of her scenes, but in some she has been flat. But she doesnt seem to be very passionate about her work. She seems to be more invested in other things but the show. Its a pity cause she does have potential.

I dont like to talk about actors/actresses personal life but why is the partner allowed to be on the sets always?! Its obvious that the partner will get insecure seeing their other half doing romantic scenes with someone else though its a shoot! Very unprofessional from both the female lead and the makers to even allow it lol!

Looks like the main purpose was not to show message against underage marriage or romance, but to create controversies. What could have been masterpiece is now a joke!

Very sad.

tvfan75 thumbnail
Posted: 19 days ago
#9
Just catching up on all the controversies. This show had so much potential, based on Kizil Goncalar or inspired by KG as some times they say here. In KG the makers were very careful with the romance. Am not from Turkey and don't know how things work there. But my guess is that in that show the senior actors pair -Ozcan Deniz (Dr. Levent) and Ozgu Namal (Meryem) were expected to become more popular. But somehow Mert Yaziciouglu (Cuneyd) and Mina Demirtas (Zeyneb) pair became popular with audience. Zeyned was 16 at the start of the serial. In real life Mina was 17 I think, and Mert was 31. So the makers never really showed romantic scenes. But gave many hints and subtly showed their liking for each other. It was almost poetic. Very beautifully done. Don't know why here the makers started showing romance more strongly and overtly like Sehere confessing to Mahid. She's just 16. They should have been careful. Now that and this off screen drama is putting strain on the show. Sad.
JustRandomGirl thumbnail
Posted: 19 days ago
#10

Originally posted by: awida

I have no problem with Seher's age, or romance between leads.. it is allowed in my religion. And many ppl start romancing at such age even in other religions. Seher is mature, and not behaving like a child.

I am happy this show didn't take leap. It is important to get matters solved and secrets come out. I hate it when separation happens where 2 leads are heart broken.

I don't find channel decision to change the timeslot strange. As this show is a hit off screen. And even TRPs system is getting changed soon, because the popularity of the show in social media and other platforms is no less important, and should be considered.. as it reaches more audience, and the channels benefit of it .

I am only sad that Rishita chose to be unprofessional. The girl is talented. And I am afraid she may get replaced if she doesn't change her attitude.

I am a Muslim too, and do know girls who got married at 16-17 yrs old. And I am aware 16 is the legal age for Shariah laws but in India and my country the min age of consent is 18 and below 18 is counted as minor. Interestingly in the western countries and first world countries the age of consent is 16.

Personally I feel a lady should get married when her age is at least 21, but thats just my opinion cause teens are more emotionally vulnerable and their body isnt as ready to adapt. More pregnancy or health complications for those who get married off young.


Yeah I do appreciate they are clearing the misunderstandings between the leads.Given the original, I have a feeling a 2nd talaaq might happen but after the misunderstandings are cleared.

Well this is the first show where I liked and it got favoured a lot cause colors usually ignore low trp shows, but they promote this one a lot though it has one of the lowest trps. The new trp system will start from Sept but I doubt if the show can survive that long the way things are going. It would surely have gotten much better trps if this system was there earlier.

Well whatever she is doing in her personal life that is her personal matter but she shouldnt mix with professional. Rishita seems to be a humble girl and if she is innocent, hope her mental health is okay. Parth looked really down and drained since some episodes.

Related Topics

Seher Hone Ko Hai thumbnail

Posted by: priya185 · 5 months ago

4th December Episode Discussion thread

Expand ▼
Seher Hone Ko Hai thumbnail

Posted by: PutijaChalhov · 5 months ago

@GossipsTv #SuperExclusive #TRP #TRPDay @ColorsTV ALL SHOWS #Noyontara 0.8 #TuJulietJattDi 1.2 #Mannat 1.2 #ShivShakti 1.1 #Binddii 0.9...

Expand ▼
Seher Hone Ko Hai thumbnail

Posted by: MJ_1009 · 5 months ago

hello folks, this is the first chat club thread for the Seher Hone Ko Hai show. please follow IF rules and regulations. thanks! permission...

Expand ▼
Seher Hone Ko Hai thumbnail

Posted by: priya185 · 24 days ago

Celebrating 100 episodes of Seher hone ko hai What do you like most about the show? https://www.instagram.com/reel/DXW4Koqk8lG/

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DXW4Koqk8lG/
Expand ▼
Seher Hone Ko Hai thumbnail

Posted by: missFiesty_69 · 5 months ago

Rules -You are allowed to post pictures related to Seher Hone Ko Hai only. -Onscreen and Off-screen pictures are allowed. -Do not post morphed...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".