Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 39 - Page 4

There is something about his swallowing poison for Mannat. Fair point. Are you saying that him keeping the vamps happy is in a way protecting Mannat?

Because the moment she is back, attacks on her have started.

Then the story ends right there. Let her go back to Indore with her Sukhi parivar. And let Vikrant marry Vishakha and be happy.

Manvik to gayo khadde mein

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Now that you mention about the cake, very true. Also the accident in ratnagiri.

So many positive posts in this thread you guys rock 🧿🧿

On this positive note, may God grant everyone unbiased wisdom and good sense 🧿🧿🧿, keep this conversation/thread going strong 👌

Originally posted by: scarlett22

There is something about his swallowing poison for Mannat. Fair point. Are you saying that him keeping the vamps happy is in a way protecting Mannat?

Because the moment she is back, attacks on her have started.

Then the story ends right there. Let her go back to Indore with her Sukhi parivar. And let Vikrant marry Vishakha and be happy.

Manvik to gayo khadde mein

Now, it's more about their child, both mannat and their child has troubles from mannat's birthmother, and by diverting this toofan to Vik, mannat would have space enough in her life to provide a good childhood to their child, but now that the child herself became one strong baby, mannat has space enough to fight the fate along with Vik... they cant escape the fate forever, it was just diverted for sometime so that their child can be protected from mannat's evil birthmother and get a good upbringing

Both Mannat and Vikrant need a comeback after a lot of setbacks

Originally posted by: ChaoticTangles

Mujhe bhi same doubt hai ,because I don't trust writers...

And before people misunderstand me as ML biased, let me be clear that I am manvik biased I will put both manvik's pov whenever I feel makers aren't clear about it...

As far as now though I have issues with vik's behavior I am still giving him bod,ideastically speaking his behavior is not good but thats not how it works in reality....realistically speaking people behave out of emotions, conflicts,trauma, confusion,...idealistically speaking mannat shouldn't have lied to dua about her birth, but realistically I understand her because she too is acting from emotions of mother who wants a complete family for her daughter and dont want her daughter to get effected by her biological parents past,just like that expecting vik to be all calm and sorted is too idealistic which even mannat wasn't after seeing vik move on,idealistically speaking mannat shouldn't have shouted at dua after coming back from mumbai, but realistically I understand her that she acted out of trauma after she saw vik moving on...so I am giving bod to vik because before he had faceoff with mannat, though bitter he was guilty and bit in control too...

But after faceoff he is out of control but as I said mannat healed a little bit because she has no guilt, and rightfully so because she gave her everything and it didn't work, so she accepted her reality and put her past behind, moved ahead... But vik understood his fault and is in guilt cycle but he suppressed his guilt and all feelings and is in denial as a coping mechanism... But with his family back all his emotions are coming out all at once, he is in conflict not able to make out right/wrong, for us it might be weeks but in story it has just been 2-3 days since faceoff...

Waiting for episode but i get vik's turmoil in neetu's case too...from bts i feel like vik didn't give up on neetu nor is he prioritizing vish over neetu.. he anyway will help neetu but if at all he finds some excuse he could do it without hurting vish...its like His plan A is to help neetu and find excuse in front of vish.. Plan b is if he doesn't find any excuse then he will go against vish and help neetu... it's just finding alternative not abandoning... that's what i feel from what they showed in bts, dont know how it will be in episode..

All i am saying idealistically there are a lot of things indore side should and shouldn't have done but we understand them that they are acting realistically through their emotions, pov, trauma and conflicts... but we expect idealistic reactions from vik... we may have to see vik's reactions too from a more realistic perspective.. Not at all absolving him of his mistakes he needs a good redemption arc but can't expect change from him all at once, it will be a slow process with ups and downs.. not definitely a straight upward slope..

On the contrary I do trust the writers

They need their show to run and they/Mukta/Jassi know the craze for AdSha so they know these 2 can pull off any crap they write for them and the audience will watch.

I had not listened to that YT reporter reviews... but I did the latest one... one statement of hers has stuck me.

Vikrant ko sach pata chalega to pagal ho jayega. I feel this is how the writers are approaching the story.

Its foolishness to say that Vikrant doesnt have some faults of his own ... whether its due to Neetus upbringing or some other inherent biases he has. But he does have them... which Aish exploited and Vish is doing the same.

We can go on and on about what led to separation... but the truth is its not Mannats habit to lie or hide things.... she reacted to the circumstances and took some decision which proved wrong. She paid the price for it.

The reason Aish exploited it is exactly because of this... it wasnt Mannats usual nature to do something like this... and Aish knew Vik would react harshly to this. Maybe she didnt anticipate the extremities but she knew there would be massive wedge between ManVik.

In the end, Mannat became a victim of Vikrant whereas Vikrant became a victim of himself.

Its wrong to say that only he suffered just because he is alone. It was his choice to be with Vish.

Vikrants habit of constantly doubting Mannat, his habit of proofs (which Aish eliminated successfully), his insecurities/ biases towards Mannat and his habit of believing everything as it is the core issue.

The reason I am pointing this out is post leap too, nothing has changed, rather it has worsened. The environment around Vik is no help either.

Vik has had no introspection... and no I don't expect him to have realization of his mistakes without some truth reveals... but his habit never investigating on his own has led to this. He still believes the first version told to him. Everyone including YY has clocked it and they are using it.

The reason Mannat or Indore gang looks stable and 'moved on' is because they have. They leaned on each other, trust and support each other and work as a unit.

Preleap Mannat and RoTu tried everything in their might to explain to Vikrant. He didnt accept it. He chose to believe the version which aligned with his own memories. And trusted Vish Malla because they were toying the same line.

And he still keeps believing the same or portrays himself as victim because he simply doesnt want to challenge himself.

The alternative truth is much harsher which probably even he understands but refuses to accept. Thats why he finds it easier to blame the other party. Its shocking to think a mom can sell her biological son.

And this is what Mannat Ronnie and DK have been trying to repeatedly tell him post leap ... look within yourself and use some brains to introspect whether there could be an alternate version.

Thats why Vik has to do major work post leap.... all the truth and all the versions/proofs are out in open. Theres really nothing Mannat or RoTu or even DK can pull out after 7 years thats going to change Vikrant. Until and unless he stops playing a victim and starts looking at things from a different perspective nothing is going to change.

And I do understand why they do this... its not just a character trait but a plot device to keep the episodes going...

Had Vikrant investigated or taken some action on his own... things would have resolved quickly. 😆

Aise hi nahi main use Princess Ana bolti hun 😜. He needs everything on a silver platter.

Just imagine the kind of trauma he will face when he realises what a big time fool he has been to blindly trust Vish Malla and possibly Y when everything starts coming out. His choice of believing half truths and giving leeway to certain people destroyed his life and his happiness. They kept him away from the people who wanted nothing but good for him.

There are multiple contributors to manvik separation and I am not denying their role... but the main characters Mannat and Vikrant should be the ones who have to change.

Mannat has changed to some degree... and she too will soften once she realises the picture is not what is presented to her. She has already seen Aish so I am assuming her brains are active now.

When will Vikrant start using his grey cells is a question writers can answer 😂. Meanwhile he should really tone down his anger.

Mannat will be the key person to pull him out of second trauma but for that he has to make some efforts too. Show some amount of regret/realization/pain for her to reach out to him.

Originally posted by: scarlett22

Both Mannat and Vikrant need a comeback after a lot of setbacks

More than them, we need it but the sad thing is it's not in our hands..

Originally posted by: scarlett22

There is something about his swallowing poison for Mannat. Fair point. Are you saying that him keeping the vamps happy is in a way protecting Mannat?

Because the moment she is back, attacks on her have started.

Then the story ends right there. Let her go back to Indore with her Sukhi parivar. And let Vikrant marry Vishakha and be happy.

Manvik to gayo khadde mein

Per chaotic , Vikrant staying back with them allowed the witches to relax there by letting Mannat and especially Dua to survive. This is in a way true I feel , if Vikrant and the wealth was not there, they would have gone behind Mannat.

And so I remembered the poison dialogue🙈 , I will write a symbolism going with the positivity flow . Vikrant like Lord Shiva swallowed the poison allowing Dua to be born and survive. He there by contained the distruction which the witches could have caused had Mannat stayed back when pregnant. Now Mannat like goddess Parvati stopped the poison from spreading in Lord Shiva's throat has to stop the poison from spreading and save Vikrant.

Ok bye bye 🏃‍♀️🏃‍♀️🏃‍♀️🏃‍♀️

Originally posted by: ChaoticTangles

Now, it's more about their child, both mannat and their child has troubles from mannat's birthmother, and by diverting this toofan to Vik, mannat would have space enough in her life to provide a good childhood to their child, but now that the child herself became one strong baby, mannat has space enough to fight the fate along with Vik... they cant escape the fate forever, it was just diverted for sometime so that their child can be protected from mannat's evil birthmother and get a good upbringing

You articulate really well.

That is the reason I kept that man—umbrella in hand, stuck in the storm, and desperately trying to hold it together—fighting his adverse situation singlehandedly. Implying Vik..

Just tell me one thing ..are we going to head for nothing. If it's just to increasing episodes then go ahead and show whatever they want. With the World Cup on now and then IPL ahead., don't know what more trauma remains to be seen if whatever has shown till now isn't enough.

Plus the slot is such a safe place na ke with the cricket matches on board this show will not be affected much as the main points start to take place in matches post 8.30 pm. So they will drag on and keep Vikrant away from all the truths till eternity.

I find it worthless to even put an analysis to the episodes. And with the BTS sadism continuity I don't find any way out for me as a viewer to catch back as earlier.

So symbolism symbolism debate going on?🤪

These are lollipops served by Mukta Mata😡. TBH I am really scared of these symbolism now since ViMal wedding 🤪.

Definitely carrots dangling for ManVik fans😡