Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 38 - Page 130

Now this BTS gives some different thoughts to me..why is he acting in a way to get some reactions from Mannu....her ignorance is annoying him completely now and he is becoming that kid who starts throwing tantrums of not paid any attention

Originally posted by: Bettyscar

Keep fingers crossed they won't send DK in his place for protection. They did that when they introduced DK and Vikrant didn't reach the warehouse on time.

And they sent Vik to save Mannat when Aish planted a bomb (her confession)... they sent Vik to save Mannat in hospital (when DK shot Aish) and they sent Vik to save Mannat on Lohri...

The makers know what they are doing... audience is being played into ML vs FL.

Originally posted by: Resham

Now this BTS gives some different thoughts to me..why is he acting in a way to get some reactions from Mannu....her ignorance is annoying him completely now and he is becoming that kid who starts throwing tantrums of not paid any attention

Adult Yuvi ho gaya hai...

Mere pass itna paisa hai... main ye karunga main vo karunga

Indore wali Bad aunty is irritating both Yuvis

Yesterday's episode was quite telling. Remember before leap I said one thing, that Vikrant, Mannat and dk situation is gonna be Vimal reverse? I can see that happening. It wont be a marriage, but Dk Mannat are bound due to Dua & attachment of 7 years. Vikrant has to break that & win his family over. Its gonna be long road of redemption and reformation for him. Mannat wont fall in love with Dk, but for time being she will choose peace, trust and stability over love and passion. She is not a 23 years old lover Mannat but a 30 year old mother who will put her child as her priority. Till the Vikrant reforms, Mannat wont run back to him this time.

Vikrant truly went out of line yesterday and there are several reasons for that. Major one I can see is they wanna make him go through severe redemption where he will break down completely. People need to keep in mind that all the characters have gone through 7 years of time period. The difference is, indore side hustled. They had to change because they were together and raising a kid, Dua. They couldnt afford to be stuck. They had each other to bounce back meanwhile Vikrant was all alone with his thoughts. He was stuck and his questions were unanswered. He had no way out and his company was toxic which made him bitter. Cut to 7 years later, he finally got his answers and in those, his nightmare came true. The old accusations were proven true and now he thinks everything happened between him and Mannat was a lie. Finally after 7 years he got a chance to react and now he is venting out bitterly.

Yes, his words were harsh but I feel they all are paving ways for future tracks for his redemption. Be it gold digger, yuvi's upbringing, possibility of him losing his wealth etc. He uses toxic words because he is still seeking his answers from Mannat which she refuses to give. Mannat a mother, has now become a mindful and till now has never indulged Vikrant in a verbal exchange. She avoids him and leaves him hanging to go to DK. Vikrant hates this. He wants her to fight with him, give him answers, accuse him but talk. Thats it. His method is wrong of instigation, but thats how Vikrant is.

Contrary to others, I dont think they are elevating dk and putting down Vikrant. This is exactly how these two are always. Vikrant is going extreme because finally he is venting out unlike Dk who has always been Mannat's support for past 7 years. Her comparing both is quite natural and maybe this will be a larger track where she will choose stability over love for herself and her kid. Young Mannat always used to run back to Vikrant due to their love and attachment. Mature Mannat who has a kid attached to her will think deeply before being impulsive. This has been ManVik's loop since the start and they have to break it which will pave the way for their relationship to be mature. Mannat's hesitance to return back to Vikrant immediately will give him a chance to reform himself and be a better version than his past self for his family. This is what Adnan said that Vikrant has to win back his love.

Originally posted by: Daman17

I don’t understand why people are comparing our show with other one. I haven’t watched that show but whatever heard so far doesn’t fit this narrative at all. DK’s character was introduced before the leap and that too as Vik’s brother, a blood relative. In other show, the FL meets another man during her separation with no family around her. Here, Mannat is already taking care of Vik’s family. The makers have consistently addressed DK as the elder brother of Vik and he himself has acknowledged that relationship. In our society, no matter how good a person is or how dynamics change over the years such relationships are still not accepted. That’s why after constant pushing the makers had to introduce Y’s character instead of continuing with Malla–Vik equation. Now of course the makers will explore this DM angle to create suspense and confusion but ultimately it’s meant for Vik to realise his own mistakes. Mannat is still deeply in love with Vik. It’s just that hurt and pain have overtaken her emotions. She is reacting based on half-truths that she knows and which woman after being rejected along with her unborn child after years of separation, would not feel shaken when she meets the same man again only to find him still accusing her apparently moved on in life has his family according to her, extremely sensitive and loving towards a child but rejected her child? Her emotional conflict is natural. When Mannat met Vik for the first time after the leap, she recalled the dessert flashback, later when she saw him with Y and assumed he had moved on it was over for her like Vik seeing happy family and felt it’s over for hil. Still, she went to Mezbaani and couldn’t stop herself from getting emotional on seeing him there. Her love hasn’t faded, it’s just clouded by MU. The DM scene yesterday, where she compared DK and Vik, was symbolic. It showed how DK is taking care of her family while Vik is doing the opposite. If she hated Vik and didn’t want him around why would she silently expect his support? That expectation itself speaks volumes. DK was not a saint when he entered SM. He carried anger and grudges, especially against Rotu and saw Mannat as a roadblock. He believed the version of truth fed to him and lived with those people for years. That’s why he understands their pain and situations. He evolved in Mannat’s company. Vik, on the other hand, was left alone, isolated and surrounded by toxic and disgusting people which slowly stripped away his goodness. Mannat and Vikrant are two wounded souls, standing on opposite ends right now, judging each other through the haze of MU. Their reactions are natural because deep down they still consider each other their own even if they refuse to accept it. The moment these clouds begin to clear, we’ll see shifts not just in their equation, but in how everyone around them is affected. Rotu and Mannat are holding onto grudges over the rejection of the baby and the divorce, which Vik never actually did. The makers have deliberately kept these loopholes so that when the truth comes out, Vik will react and Mannat will realise that he wasn’t entirely wrong either. Using CA was a brutal move to justify the leap and once again, Vik character was used as bait. But to soften its impact, the makers showed a shift in DK’s feelings proving that what Vik said years ago was true while same time giving Mannat a clean chit through Neetu making it clear that the fault lay with DK, not her. Every character played a role in the separation and the changed dynamics. Now, with the Indore gang moving to Mumbai, those dynamics will shift again. Personally, I liked yesterday’s ManVik scene. It was confrontational, raw, and full of anger, hurt, and pain. It was necessary to establish that ManVik are still holding grudges, which is why Y and Y were present in the scene to let other SM vamps knows about it. Despite such a long gap only Mannat can speak to Vik in that tone and no one else. Yes, the repetitive dialogues can be irritating because we have seen similar scenes before. But this repetition is important, Mannat venting out and showing Vik the mirror is crucial for future tracks. Regret only deepens when the fall is deeper. Until Vik accepts that he was wrong, how will he truly change? At their core, Mannat and Vikrant remain the same. Mannat’s ability to switch off her emotions, just as Vik pointed out in the first episode and Vik’s obsession with Mannat, in any form, still define them. Vik lives by that one line he once said after the Vimal marriage during the kitchen scene when Mannat burnt her hand “Jo insaan humara sab kuch hota hai… jab woh insaan humara dil tod ke chala jaata hai, palat kar nahi dekhta, jisse koi farq nahi padta ki hum jeeyein ya mar jaayein—tab jo dard hota hai, wahi asli dard hota hai. Aur woh dard waqt ke saath kam nahi hota.” To end on a positive note, ManVik will always be reflections of each other. That’s the foundation of this story. No matter how circumstances change, what’s written by God cannot be erased. They will make mistakes, learn from them, and grow and that’s their journey.

Daman I really admire your ability to decipher and explain the complexities of the characters and their povs so well, and so positively too.

It’s a shame the average tv viewer doesn’t get yours and our other forum experts insights as footnotes, as writers are leaving much unsaid and confusing 🤣 so thank you.

The brilliant dialogue from Vik you highlighted in pink was shared by an X user yesterday too, so sharing …..

https://x.com/estheticsf78170/status/2018823919835533325

He so wants the answers from Mannu only ke why is she back in Mumbai? Why she wants money? He is terribly getting impatient with Mannus aloofness and non answering. Also look closely the BTS , when she says she is now not going to be revolving around him he feels bad and so gets annoyed. He wants her back to involve him in her doings....yeh Banda kya hi nafrat karega Mannu se aur kya hi dur reh payega...more than Rotu he is damn more affected by Mannu....

Originally posted by: Resham

He so wants the answers from Mannu only ke why is she back in Mumbai? Why she wants money? He is terribly getting impatient with Mannus aloofness and non answering. Also look closely the BTS , when she says she is now not going to be revolving around him he feels bad and so gets annoyed. He wants her back to involve him in her doings....yeh Banda kya hi nafrat karega Mannu se aur kya hi dur reh payega...more than Rotu he is damn more affected by Mannu....

Banda ATTENTION ke liye tadap raha hai from Mannat..

🤣🤣🤣🤣

Originally posted by: Resham

He so wants the answers from Mannu only ke why is she back in Mumbai? Why she wants money? He is terribly getting impatient with Mannus aloofness and non answering. Also look closely the BTS , when she says she is now not going to be revolving around him he feels bad and so gets annoyed. He wants her back to involve him in her doings....yeh Banda kya hi nafrat karega Mannu se aur kya hi dur reh payega...more than Rotu he is damn more affected by Mannu....

Its clear from post leap situations that his hurt is over the fact that he thinks Mannat chose DK over him...

And Vikku boy is digging his pity grave deeper and deeper everytime he blames Dua and DK to Mannat.

But simply because they can stretch it... ye truth itni jaldi Bahar nahi aane wala 😆

@chaotic... this is why I was saying Mumbai episodes will give an insight into Viks side.

Trust Dua and Bunty to go and create drama

I bet Dua is back to fundraising for Neetu's treatment in the enemy camp

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0xSKZyfdawo