Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 37 - Page 47

Originally posted by: Bettyscar

Well it took you time but you came out of the shadows.

We all knew if we panic and rant on repeat you would come out 🤣🤣🤣🤣

Good to have you back.

I am going to write what my friend said ..that we are seeing a different Mannat and a different Vikrant. Life has made them both move away from their original selves.

Have we ever seen Mannat so scared, and panicked?? Have we ever seen Vikrant look so angry and snap at people around him so much? (not his nagin gang of course)

"For the OG Mannat to come back the OG BDB has to return." (Roch,this is is yours)

I would like to believe the process has started; OG BDB is coming back, his intuition for his soul mate, his child with his soul mate is returning. It may take time, to cut through the web of deception around them, but it will happen.

Don't throw chappals at me...if nothing changes. Mukta..meri izzat rakho.

I am genuinely stumped on one aspect...

Koi mujhe ye batao ki just because DK is supposed to be a good guy... he should have growth and correct things between ManVik...but ye courtesy baki kisi ko to offer nahi hoti.

Why isn't Malla pulled up when she was the one who initiated this truth reveal by doing the skit??? Sirf isliye ki vo vamp hai to uski galti ignore kar de??? Vik doesn't have extra friendship with her... thank god for that... but she still lives like she deserves to be in SM!!!

Why dont RoTu contact Vik??? Vo bhi to koshish kar sakte hai??? Have they??? It is after all their money and their son!!!!

What happened to Gagan??? Who has gone missing and probably written off???

What happened to Shalini... who knows a lot more!!!

My point is and will remain that till DK turns negative, influences Dua against Vik or blackmails Mannat into marrying him... there shouldn't be any importance given to him.... he is just there to keep Mannat away from running back to Vik once MU starts clearing up... and thank God for that...

Vik needs to earn his place in Mannat Duas life... it shouldn't be given to him freely just because he messed up while being unawares. Thats not enough for the trauma he has put everyone through.

I am fully expecting paltu couple to EB Mannat again to give Vik a chance as soon as they find out the truth.

https://x.com/Tulip1917/status/2011337415420756395

https://x.com/aswathygpi7100/status/2011329954580173015

Someone please decipher ..

Originally posted by: Moor278

Do people realise how gullible they are???

Mukta is damn right when she says Vamps and negativity brings the drama...

Currently the vamp of the show disguised as a good man is DK... everyone everywhere rants about him... expects him to take higher ground and absolving Vik of any responsibility or making amends. This is very similar to how Malla was treated... only that people wanted her punished for her crimes.

DK is not for Mannat... he is there for Dua... for Vik to realise where he messed up. Its yet another parallel to the theme of the show ... nature vs nurture.

DK is not supposed to have any growth in his character. He is a sidey. Neither do we need any more scenes on what he thinks 🤔

But Vik needs to.... just because DK Mannat are proxy parents to Dua doesnt mean YV equation is justified.

For that matter YV hone ka jyada chance hai... Y is hell bent on marrying V and V is anyway a volatile person who takes wrong decisions. DK doesnt have romantic intentions for Mannat but the less said the better about what Vik allows Y to do for him.

Give it time and Y would be in focus and the problems would increase for Manvik.

What happenened to people wanting Viks redemption and regret????

Just because Vik shed some tears and is shown pining for Mannat doesnt mean he can be absolved of everything he did pre leap. Neither does Mannat claiming DK as Duas father mean anything.

He hasnt yet realised where he messed up... and he wont till he starts opening his eyes... this is a man who is pally with Malla... who was also equally responsible for the seperation.

Mannat is lying to Dua but she too has been misled. The moment she and RoTu realise Vik was not aware, they will disown DK... phir kya karenge sab????

Why do people forget that for Mannat Vik is not returning and Vik believes Mannat disowned him. This status quo will remain till truths start tumbling out. Audience knows both sides not the characters. They are not supposed to behave the way we want simply because for them a different reality exists.

Ye roj roj rant karke panic kyun hote rehte hai sab????

Wondering the same as to why should we have issues with dk-mannu dynamics more than vik-yash....

Mannat considers dk as only a friend... Where as vik considers yash as his future potential partner... Mannat might seek support from dk but just as a friend.... Where as vik seeks comforts from yash as more than just a friend... He is emotionally connected to her, physically comfortable with her... And I don't think it's normal to share a room with a unrelated person willingly...with malla it was a compulsion to share a room where as with yash it's a choice, whether he slept with her or not, it does mean he shares a lot of comfort with her..no one will share a room with a unrelated person at night unless and until they share a deep bond with them, and are extremely comfortable with them.. It's not a issue that vik is trying to move on, it's the issue that he says he still is not able to move on and have feelings for mannat while in a serious relationship with another woman......

Just because mannat vented out about vikrant in front of dk and reassures him of being dua's father we are so upset with mannat, I wonder what will be the reaction if she behaves with dk the same way vik behaves with yash.. Letting dk call her baby, going on dates with him, sharing a room with him.. All of them being signs of a serious relationship. . ?

Vik is trying to move on but not being able to , is what the makers want to show...... But their scenes are failing them big time at this...their way of dealing with this is not really directing the story that way.. It is seeming like vik has already moved on with yash and it's only time before he realises it completely... Makers should really rework on their way of narration

Was following the discussion: At this point, I like the character of Dharya and his conversations with Mannat. Will he turn negative? Maybe yes and maybe no ... but I am not bothered about that because my interest will most probably take a dive again by then. Do I see him as a potential love interest? No. If he turns one, he will prove Visakha's accusation right that his and Mannat's relationship was immoral. I see him just as a layer added to make the reunion between Mannat and Vikrant a little difficult, and Dua's acceptance of Vikrant as her father a little more difficult. Yashika is playing that role as well. This gives writers the content to play with once the face-off happens.

This is based on what I have read about episodes pre-leap.

Vikrant's world turned upside down on the wedding day. He being confused, angry, and lashing out at everyone was to a great extent right. But then he accused Mannat of having an affair and believed that she accepted Dharya's proposal ... took his character to a point where Mannat lost all her hope ... and then devils played their game. She is right in not trusting him and having an opinion that borders hostility.

At this point, Mannat holds no responsibility to correct things. Dharya too is an accused party. It is neither his responsibility too -- they are brothers but neither know anything about each other. Ronnie and Neetu carry that responsibility as parents who continue to love Vikrant.

Indian shows are TRP-driven ... so things will move and change as per it. Also, this show does not have a family structure with family dynamics and problems that need to be solved by the female protagonist. It is, at the end of the day, a crime show ... when the crime gets solved, things get stuck. So writers will continue to push Shruti's death revelation for as long as possible ... Once it is solved and everything is revealed, the show will again reach a dead-end.

P.S: It is not Vikrant's responsibility to correct things as well at the moment ... because he believes his version of truth.

Originally posted by: scarlett22

https://x.com/aswathygpi7100/status/2011329954580173015

Someone please decipher ..

What a weird way to describe a scene...

Seems like in first paragraph they are indicating that there might be a manvik hit and miss(no.. 629937902902)......and 2 nd one seems like yash proposes vik but even before vik reacts there is divine intervention where vik's attention will be diverted.. Mostly he sees neetu in trouble..???.. So he rushes to her and mannat does too... Thus saving neetu.. 🤣

And the rest might mean that it's during this he witness entire family of mannat... and he might chase in hope to get answers for his unresolved questions(which are driven by past manipulations) .... And thus grand scheme of yash to propose vik might get failed...

Well said !

Well said both of you

I feel the same... as of now all the characters are behaving appropriately .. according to the extent of truth known to them.

A 'growth' for any of them will happen when they are presented with an alternate reality.

Which is exactly why makers are doing this hit and miss and keeping the reunion at bay!!!

Mannats biggest hurt is that Vik CAed her ... she still went to tell him about her pregnancy inspite of all the rejection. And Vik remembers those exact words from cremation ground.

It needs to be seen if he really meant them or just said it in anger. If he does believe the same, then all those words about regrets and mistakes mean nothing. Shruti ke liye rant videos are pointless.

And if he doesn't then yes we can say he has changed/realised a little bit. Then he can show all the anger he has for lying to Dua.

I want to see what he does though ... since Y is readily available to be the jealous new GF .. and who defends him then!!!!