Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 23 - Page 98

Originally posted by: Rdigest

I am actually all for Mannat playing with Malla's insecurities. So far she hasn't unless I missed a scene. She has been trying to protect Vikrant from the drug & rape tactics of Malla and keep showing Vikrant she loves him and he loves her so she has enough time to bring out Malla's truth.

Sometimes to defeat negativity and disgust like Malla we have to do what ever it takes which is what Mannat is doing. Mannat, like she told Shurti and Shalini this marriage is illegal though it may have happened and it's just a matter of time for Vikrant to find out he is a sexual abuse victim like Shalini and request for annulment.

Infact even Malla & ARS knows this, the moment Vikrant realizes how she trapped him the scam marriage ends so the urgency to sleep with him. The frustration she is failing is making her act on her criminal instincts and not something Mannat orchestrated.

Even in Teej I was ok since Mannat wanted to show Vikrant they love each other and she did, she managed to open Vikrant's closed heart from the ONS aftermath and cause some confusion.

Regarding "I will get him back", again she says this with the confidence that Vikrant loves her and vice versa. What Malla did to Vikrant was dispecable starting form fake engagement and fooling him( yes Vikrant was at fault too and hoping he realizes soon) . Why should Mannat sacrifice her love for Malla who is deceiving, guilt tripping Vikrant at every step and wants to carry on a marital rape. Infact I am all for Mannat wanting her love back if Vikrant is ok aswell.

When Malla herself has no respect for this scam marriage and all she wants is to sleep with Vikrant by drugging him, why should Mannat be a goody too shoes and wait for opportunities to free Vikrant. She should create opportunities to free Vikrant from this scamster and criminal.

One scene which makes me want Mannat go all out was Gagan and Mannat scene in the kitchen after suicide drama and how Gagan confirmed her fears that this was how ARS trapped him. Mannat was terrified knowing Vikrant might be trapped for life.

I didnt watch the whole episode but from written update and reviews here..Mannat said Vikrant finds reason to talk to her and to avoid Malla, she will get back Vikrant...Isnt that playing with Malla's insecurities?

I mentioned the same..Mannat is right for wanting to free Vikrant from the ons guilt and fail Malla's drug attempt.

Malla will anyway try to sleep with Vikrant but there is no urgency if none knows the ons truth, so no fear of Vikrant finding out and ending the marriage. It became urgent after Mannat said she will bring out the truth, which is the right thing to do.

Will Vikrant knowing Mannat and him love each other stop Malla from drugging and raping him? Did Vikrant being confused about Mannat during Teej stop him from telling Malla he will try to accept their marriage (I dont remember the exact word)? No. It doesnt buy time for Mannat to bring out Malla truth. Mannat cannot be alert 24/7 to save him from Malla's trap either. Vikrant needs to break the marriage himself to be free. Malla created an opportunity by poisoning the kids. But things turned back with her suicide. Gagan's word at the kitchen made exposing the fake suicide more urgent for Mannat.

Vikrant will not back out of the marriage since he feels guilty and Neetu is there to emotionally blackmail him too. Mannat cannot tell him about Shruti liver deal either, so the issue of Mannat selling her love for Mezbaani shares still remains in Vikrant mind. Also if Vikrant wanted to divorce after he found out about the deal and realised they love each other, it would look bad. Vikrant demanding divorce after finding out Malla truth, was the right and better way.

I am all for Mannat wanting her love back if Vikrant is ok aswell..me too, not just saying she will take back Vikrant. He is not an object.

Originally posted by: Coolmeg

The way they are headed Malla khud h uska kaand describe karegi sabke samne…isn’t that what’s happening…

She is so stupid that she disclosed Sonia’s truth infront of everyone …. As if they all will let her go for sending gundas to rape and kidnap Mannat … mast bevakoof vamp hai

It’s going to be difficult watching the attack episode 😭😱

Does Mannat find out the gundas were hired by Malla and that she instructed the SA too?? That’s horrifying for Mannat to deal with but if Mannat feels obligated and grateful to ARS for saving her, for her sake she may not press charges 😡 But I still want Vik to investigate the cctv cameras and have the police look for the goons. Surely he doesn’t know Malla is behind it, I imagine he would drag her to the police himself (but if he sees the cctv, he’ll hear ARS telling to gunda’s Mannat is her daughter, so that doesn’t look like it happened either ?!!)

From the bts of Malla spilling the beans of Sonia’s truth, she’s walking around freely in SM (noticed back to her spoilt brat dressing, not newly married bahu attire) so Vikrant can’t know. What on earth did Malla hope to gain by this confession? She really is so stupid.

Mannat looks ‘well’ helping ARS so hopefully she isn’t traumatised by her ordeal 😢.

Originally posted by: purplegirl7

I didnt watch the whole episode but from written update and reviews here..Mannat said Vikrant finds reason to talk to her and to avoid Malla, she will get back Vikrant...Isnt that playing with Malla's insecurities?

I mentioned the same..Mannat is right for wanting to free Vikrant from the ons guilt and fail Malla's drug attempt.

Malla will anyway try to sleep with Vikrant but there is no urgency if none knows the ons truth, so no fear of Vikrant finding out and ending the marriage. It became urgent after Mannat said she will bring out the truth, which is the right thing to do.

Will Vikrant knowing Mannat and him love each other stop Malla from drugging and raping him? Did Vikrant being confused about Mannat during Teej stop him from telling Malla he will try to accept their marriage (I dont remember the exact word)? No. It doesnt buy time for Mannat to bring out Malla truth. Mannat cannot be alert 24/7 to save him from Malla's trap either. Vikrant needs to break the marriage himself to be free. Malla created an opportunity by poisoning the kids. But things turned back with her suicide. Gagan's word at the kitchen made exposing the fake suicide more urgent for Mannat.

Vikrant will not back out of the marriage since he feels guilty and Neetu is there to emotionally blackmail him too. Mannat cannot tell him about Shruti liver deal either, so the issue of Mannat selling her love for Mezbaani shares still remains in Vikrant mind. Also if Vikrant wanted to divorce after he found out about the deal and realised they love each other, it would look bad. Vikrant demanding divorce after finding out Malla truth, was the right and better way.

I am all for Mannat wanting her love back if Vikrant is ok aswell..me too, not just saying she will take back Vikrant. He is not an object.

Bold blue - this is true naa atleast from what they have shown so far. This wasn't a comment Mannat made to cause insecurities in Malla, she countered Malla's comments about how it doesn't matter who Vikrant loves since now Vikrant is her's and speaks of him like a trophy she won. She infact confirms this in Mezbaani when she Malla says Vikrant will dance to her tunes.

Bold black - Mannat not once spoke of Vikrant like an object or a trophy and she defended Vikrant and his feelings even during the reveal episode. Infact she was shocked Malla would do this to Vikrant when he treated her as his friend. This is where she says she will reveal the ons and her face to Vikrant to end the invalid marriage and get her love back.

There is nothing wrong naa in Mannat wanting to get her love back since she now knows Vikrant loves her , the proposal was fake and he is suffering per Vikrant's own confirmation. Mannat infact in a scene confirms, she walked away since she thought Vikrant was never meant for her after the proposal.

Bold Red - absolutely and it should be an annulment and not even a divorce. I am glad he initiated the divorce right after the poisoning is revealed else it would look like kids poisoning< ONS

Originally posted by: Shazia_h

It’s going to be difficult watching the attack episode 😭😱

Does Mannat find out the gundas were hired by Malla and that she instructed the SA too?? That’s horrifying for Mannat to deal with but if Mannat feels obligated and grateful to ARS for saving her, for her sake she may not press charges 😡 But I still want Vik to investigate the cctv cameras and have the police look for the goons. Surely he doesn’t know Malla is behind it, I imagine he would drag her to the police himself (but if he sees the cctv, he’ll hear ARS telling to gunda’s Mannat is her daughter, so that doesn’t look like it happened either ?!!)

From the bts of Malla spilling the beans of Sonia’s truth, she’s walking around freely in SM (noticed back to her spoilt brat dressing, not newly married bahu attire) so Vikrant can’t know. What on earth did Malla hope to gain by this confession? She really is so stupid.

Mannat looks ‘well’ helping ARS so hopefully she isn’t traumatised by her ordeal 😢.

Looks like Mannat does find out per one BTS and she says ARS may want to save her, but she will reveal her truth which is when she decides to pack her bags and leave.

Hope Mannat deals it just like a transaction, you saved me, I saved you with no attachments. So far BTS is giving mixed feelings. She does seem detached in 1 scene where Malla reveals the truth , but was emotional when telling what happened.

This reveal by Malla just doesn't make sense per story perspective especially when Anirudh just entered. He doesn't even know Mannat is his daughter. This is why my gut feeling this is all ARS's plan to get into Mannat's good books. Malla may not know yet, so she revealed her truth. Hoping this is ARS's plan since she cannot be redeemed.

I didnt mean to say Mannat treats Vikrant as an object, my point is his consent matters too. I was pointing out the dialog. Another one is..Vikrant will spend his days with her and Malla's night will be alone..it can be interpreted wrongly. Its on the writer.

Originally posted by: purplegirl7

I didnt mean to say Mannat treats Vikrant as an object, my point is his consent matters too. I was pointing out the dialog. Another one is..Vikrant will spend his days with her and Malla's night will be alone..it can be interpreted wrongly. Its on the writer.

Yes consent matters. I felt it similar to Vikrant starting the fake drama and him wanting a confession. The fake drama was Vikrant's persepective of him believing Mannat loves him and will want to be with him, similarly Mannat's dialogue was her perspective that Vikrant will want to be with her. Hope I am making sense 😔

Night and day dialogue, I honestly ignored since that seemed more like a punch dialogue for promo rather than anything. Writers definitely need to focus when writing weird dialogues.

I think show is at a point, Ayesha ke liye dekh liya so again a love triangle shayad....

Mannat is good Vikrant ka nhi pta bas he is stucked in problems as what I see and Malla bechari death note mil gaya....woh kya aaram se maro....

Family mein kuch kuch hai will watch....

Originally posted by: Bettyscar

None of them have considered finding jobs. I'm sure if anyone suggests that they will think that person has lost their mind.

The more i think of it, the more i wonder if Gagan was crazy in preparing those documents for Mannat. He signed off putting his own parents on the streets

No no. They have other properties. I remember them talking about a farm house somewhere. They may have other businesses in london as well. I know roni does. So Aishwarya probably does too. How do you think Malla paid for the goons.

Originally posted by: Deepa11q

Infact i want both to just lock killa in a room and elope ..and before that take her sign on the annulment papers or divorce papers ..

Oh yes. They can do it the same way mannat got the sign for property papers. It's Malla. Of course, she will sign without reading

Mallas reason to marry Vikranth is not love but her obsession to have him to show Mannath she is better. Malla is so filled with thoughts that wirh her beuty and charm she can have any man. Thats the parvarish she jas been given. Even in the last episode ARS tutors her how she can keep Vikrant tied to her.

When a person thinks i will get what i want by hook or crook the person will not be able to see any logical reasoning of someone like Gagan who time and again has spoken out that a loveless marriage like the one he is trapped in. Is not what he wants for hus daughter.

He adores Malla and when she fakes that tried to end her life unable to think of life without Vikrant he pleads with Vikranth and admits to Mannat that Mallas well being is his concern. ARS s mind talk of what an amazing actress her only daughter is and Neetus emotional blackmail and Keerats insensitive taunts of Mannat and shruti have only emboldened Malla to think she is invincible.

Just like others Mannat believed initially that Malla loved Vikranth so was okay to sacrifice her live. But when she realised the circumstances leading to the wedding just as she was trying to prove to Vikrant he did no wrong in it all she has to make Malla fret that no matter what she does she cannot get Vikrant to love her.

The teej again was a drama through and through and the way Keerat spike of offsprings was so in line with the thought process of the witches once that happe no s Vikrant is trapped for life. When Malla claims in Mezbani that Vikrant is a mere puppet Mannat had to pay ba cc k Malla in the language and mode she understands. With no proof with her the only way left for her is to capitalise on Mallas zidd and insecurities the teej fast and breaking the fast showed not merely to Malla but Vikrant as well that Mannat is upto a plan.

Vikrant has given his ultimatum by swearing on God that he will not tolerate any badmouthing of Muss Mannat. Malla with her devious plan has hoped to do just that so if Vikrant know it the pandoras box rhat Malla has opened will wreck damage on the entire clan .

Whatever be the reasons your actions are what establishes who you are. It is that we hich sets the two at different points in the spectrum of etical action.