Created

Last reply

Replies

6

Views

385

Users

3

Likes

7

Frequent Posters

Clochette thumbnail
The Fun Food Fight Participant Thumbnail Book Talk Reading Challenge - Pride Prose Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 5 days ago
#2

Although not having watched the movie, I know the story.

I always find it interesting how the idea for a story nurtures similar stories, in this case = 'posing as a husband to help a damsel in distress'. Helping out an unmarried pregnant girl by playing her husband because of existing social norms is the ground idea (created already 1942 for an Italian black-and-white movie). I didn't watch the Original (Four Steps in the Clouds), but the 1956 copy-remake with Fernandel (famous French comedy actor). The Kannada remake (28 years ago) of the Italian original combined with the US-Film A Walk in the Clouds (30 years ago, with Keanu Reeves, which I also have watched) brought the idea to India - with several following Indian 'remakes'.

Instead of Kunwara, I watched the Abhishek-Aishwarya movie (also 2000 release and Abhishek's 3rd movie and 1st with Aish) which again - in a changed way - used the idea of posing as a husband for a 'damsel in distress'.

To me, the most interesting part of those stories is the reason why the man helps the woman and agrees to pose as her husband. The most impressive one, imo, is the original one where an already married man does this favour but then makes the parents change their opinion about a cruel social norm and goes back to his family.

Edit: When in Chennai Express Rahul makes the speech to Meenamma's father, it reminded me of what Paul said to Maria's parents in The Virtuous Bigamist (the 1956 film) - not by words but by intent.

Edited by Clochette - 5 days ago
Elvis12 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 5 days ago
#3

Originally posted by: Clochette

Although not having watched the movie, I know the story.

I always find it interesting how the idea for a story nurtures similar stories, in this case = 'posing as a husband to help a damsel in distress'. Helping out an unmarried pregnant girl by playing her husband because of existing social norms is the ground idea (created already 1942 for an Italian black-and-white movie). I didn't watch the Original (Four Steps in the Clouds), but the 1956 copy-remake with Fernandel (famous French comedy actor). The Kannada remake (28 years ago) of the Italian original combined with the US-Film A Walk in the Clouds (30 years ago, with Keanu Reeves, which I also have watched) brought the idea to India - with several following Indian 'remakes'.

Instead of Kunwara, I watched the Abhishek-Aishwarya movie (also 2000 release and Abhishek's 3rd movie and 1st with Aish) which again - in a changed way - used the idea of posing as a husband for a 'damsel in distress'.

To me, the most interesting part of those stories is the reason why the man helps the woman and agrees to pose as her husband. The most impressive one, imo, is the original one where an already married man does this favour but then makes the parents change their opinion about a cruel social norm and goes back to his family.

Edit: When in Chennai Express Rahul makes the speech to Meenamma's father, it reminded me of what Paul said to Maria's parents in The Virtuous Bigamist (the 1956 film) - not by words but by intent.

An insightful comment as always.Yes Kunwara and Dhai Akshar Prem Ke were both inspired by "A walk in the clouds"..However the treatment of both the movies were as different as chalk and cheese.Kunwara took the comical route whereas DAP had bit of a romantic flavour..

Also did not know anything abt the 1942 (or 1956 ) version.

Edited by Elvis12 - 5 days ago
Clochette thumbnail
The Fun Food Fight Participant Thumbnail Book Talk Reading Challenge - Pride Prose Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 5 days ago
#4

It is very interesting to experience the connection between Indian Cinema and European Cinema... France has since long a very close bond to Indian Cinema...my first books about Indian Cinema had been in French narrating the dawn especially of Hindi and Bengali Cinema. I noticed that I would need the triple of time to watch and read everything that interests me. Since years, I neglect the Western Cinema but it doesn't matter as I grew up with it and through the kids, I keep track of at least the Marvel Universe and some very good Amimation movies ... and sometimes I watch Oscar-rewarded US movies (and wonder why they got an Oscar) smiley1

Elvis12 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 5 days ago
#5

Originally posted by: Clochette

It is very interesting to experience the connection between Indian Cinema and European Cinema... France has since long a very close bond to Indian Cinema...my first books about Indian Cinema had been in French narrating the dawn especially of Hindi and Bengali Cinema. I noticed that I would need the triple of time to watch and read everything that interests me. Since years, I neglect the Western Cinema but it doesn't matter as I grew up with it and through the kids, I keep track of at least the Marvel Universe and some very good Amimation movies ... and sometimes I watch Oscar-rewarded US movies (and wonder why they got an Oscar) smiley1

Keep going!

Posted: 5 days ago
#6

How do you all remember the release date if a movie? Any movie?

I don't even remember this movie. Was this a superhit one? How do you remember?? 😦😦

Elvis12 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 5 days ago
#7

Originally posted by: Caillou

How do you all remember the release date if a movie? Any movie?

I don't even remember this movie. Was this a superhit one? How do you remember?? 😦😦

😂 Hahaha..I am actually a big movie buff so I do remember these dates in most cases ..in case there is a confusion I visit Boxofficeindia where a movie that released on that date is listed .

No Kunwara actually underperformed..The film had a decent opening but did not sustain in the long run.

Related Topics

Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: Maroonporsche

7 days ago

18 Years Of Partner

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tJHMbry4CWY

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tJHMbry4CWY
Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: Elvis12

6 days ago

7 years of Dhadak

https://youtu.be/qWnzMwT6SKo?si=Dpv4PpCf3D9rqtLb

https://youtu.be/qWnzMwT6SKo?si=Dpv4PpCf3D9rqtLb
Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: Elvis12

9 days ago

28 years of Yes Boss

https://youtu.be/90Q5bMN6u2w?si=QHMoUUw3IrY43QZU

https://youtu.be/90Q5bMN6u2w?si=QHMoUUw3IrY43QZU
Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: Elvis12

8 days ago

12 years of Ramaiya Vastavaiya

https://youtu.be/pkzOBl1p7y4?si=qTlGp9ulgezoxohM

https://youtu.be/pkzOBl1p7y4?si=qTlGp9ulgezoxohM
Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: Elvis12

10 days ago

10 years of Bajrangi Bhaijaan

https://youtu.be/zuvla6ABKbs?si=x0rWZ40QfR9n_AlR

https://youtu.be/zuvla6ABKbs?si=x0rWZ40QfR9n_AlR
Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".