Would "Abhira" be called Abheera and hated had she been baby Birla? - Page 12

It has become too jarring to see that every other day a new account is created just to bash FL and defend the ReaL FL, Ruhi, the witch. 🧙

Originally posted by: shahsb_26

I am really curious and probably may not believe (or even be able to read) lot of responses.

Still wondering of a few scenarios.. I will never agree that amount of hate fictional character gets and obsession of people with hating her just stems from character herself but mostly because of her history...

Scenario 1: keep it simple

Assume ManRa would have married, they would have a child who became FL of the show... Would Chuhi still get so much of support?

Scenario 2- Like Abhir - Like Abhira...

Baby would have been AkshNav's child by birth but would have been bought up for say 10 years this time by ManRa... And she would have actually called Trashmanyu her papa, and not spoken much about Abhinav at all... Would she still be hated?

Scenario 3 - undo Gen 2

Here we completely write of Chuhi... This is also for AkshNav fans... Had there be two daughters one with Abhinav and after his death, Akshu married and moved on with Trashmanyu... Had a daughter.. BUT..

Twist here is that ManRa bought up Abhira together, their parvarish, and their daughter as soul for let's say 5-10 years ... And Akshara would have been pregnant again with ManRa kid and before she was out in the world her Dad died and mom died during birth... So, she had legit bought up as an orphan cuz well Birlas were on road after Parth's scam...

But you know Manra would be FL and not AkshNav wali Abhira... Cuz you know na.. Rule book says Child of *Leads* is FL.

Scenario 4: Changed scenario

Abhir was indeed Abhira (Girl Child) who was bought up by Akshnav. And after years Akshnavi was born after death of Abhinav.

Abhira was lost after tragic lanslide and grew up on her own.

ManRa raised Akshnavi for 6 years and she was their parvarish.

Basically Biological Swap:

Akshnavi Birla and Abhira Sharma..

And who would have been lead and loved more?

I like how your brain works.

Originally posted by: Ankitanair

They way she has always abused abhira na uske liye she has never regretted and also once arman threw her mandap fer b Rohit ko use karke ghr aayi to hasil arman uska kya dhood ki dhuli nhi hei voh just because you lost many people won't give you the license to harrass an innocent soul and let me tell you abhira was in shock esliye baby lekar gayi badmei usko lake diya b yeh mat bhulo and also ab daksh usko mila hei abhira usse neeche k position mei hei esliye chup hei Varna ek sec nhi lagega isko chudail banne.

And Abhira has also abused her(especially when she lost her baby) and was rude to her. Ruhi just didn't want Abhira around her and she used to constantly barge into her space. So obviously she'll listen. And according to your own logic just because Abhira lost her child and was in trauma doesn't mean she'll steal someone else's baby. And if you can show Abhira sympathy and justify her crime then Ruhi was also in trauma after being left at the altar and tried to win Armaan and"yeh mat bhulo" that she also apologised to Abhira after Armaan and Abhira's wedding.

Originally posted by: shahsb_26

There is difference between being selfish and coward!! Ruhi was purely evil and selfish...

Armaan never imagined that he wanted to romance or find beech ka rasta with his brother's wife.. He didn't commit adultry, he didn't agree to marry her while she was married to his brother.

Akshara took the blame for sake of Ruhi. Her poppy was the one who kept her on hook way more than Armaan.. He had promised her world, and to never love anyone else more than her but the moment his khoon ka beta entered he just left off Ruhi and went to Kasauli to ruin a happy family that Abhir, Akshara and Abhinav had... We all called out how moronic and pathetic was poppy... But, it's not like only Ruhi had such issues... Abhir had most traumatic past among all... Yet, he has managed to be accha at heart...

Firstly I don't think being selfish is wrong but I don't see where Ruhi has been evil. Armaan didn't marry her while she was married but as an idiot just before her wedding festivities when she was asking him to tell everyone the truth he asked her to marry his brother and he'll always keep her in his heart and not love anyone else, something along these lines. He was crying and being absolutely miserable. He fed into her delusions. Not once Armaan made a boundary with Ruhi that he is married to Abhira now and therefore she should stay away. Instead he did a couple dance with her. What was the need to tell Ruhi out of all people that he and Abhira have a contract marriage, again feeding into her delusions. Coward or not, he did feed her delusions and when he left Abhira he agreed to marry Ruhi so at what point would Ruhi know that Armaan actually loves Abhira? She believed he has feelings for her like he used to.

Rohit left and didn't give a shit about his wife, didn't think to actually talk to her about her past, he just left. What great love they had that the adultery would make such a big impact at that time? And if we are talking about hiding things then both Arman and Ruhi hid the truth from their spouses and even their sibling/cousin.

Akshara took the blame for Ruhi or anyone else in the world who cares. In the eyes of a 6 year old she was a criminal and killed her mom. Akshara should have just talked about it being an accident and lived with Ruhi, she should have honoured the promise she made to her sister but she left like she has done before as well, I suppose. Also no one's saying Ruhi's poppy is great to leave a little girl behind who considered him her father. He's the worst of the lot. He used Ruhi as an emotional crutch when he had nothing then Ruhi was everything as soon as he got his family back then who cares about Ruhi.

Abhir also has hatred. He hates Manish Goenka and rightfully so. Ruhi also has hatred but her heart is also fine, if her heart wasn't accha she wouldn't have helped Abhira as many times as she did.

Originally posted by: Lostin90s

It has become too jarring to see that every other day a new account is created just to bash FL and defend the ReaL FL, Ruhi, the witch. 🧙

If you are talking about me since my account is also relatively new then you can check when my account was created because I made this account for commenting on KMKT not specifically bashing a fl.