Jhanak Written Update And Episode Discussion thread No 85. - Page 130

Originally posted by: sanfan

Yahan har koi paltu ram hain…

Kabhi kuch toh kabhi kuch

I don’t think even the audience takes anything anyone says seriously 😂😂

On a different note, I happen to watch a couple of clips of Jhanak BBG convos… Ideally this dynamic was supposed to provide some great emotional content given Jhanak’s backstory ( whether her father was the evil twin or wig baba) but the interactions look so ott… Everything is off… mainly the writing, situation in the story, therefore the acting 😂😂 looks like a scene acted out for a school play

Specifically in the case of J and her father, Leena has registered in our minds from the beginning that it will be a hateful relationship...but suddenly she changed the basic narrative and has been trying to project a different reality between baap beti...that is one of the reasons why we are not convinced with the new development, along with the ott acting..

Why don't they play 'Papa mere Papa' during every Jhanak bbg scene so that we can get a better connection.

Originally posted by: Dibya_C

Specifically in the case of J and her father, Leena has registered in our minds from the beginning that it will be a hateful relationship...but suddenly she changed the basic narrative and has been trying to project a different reality between baap beti...that is one of the reasons why we are not convinced with the new development, along with the ott acting..

my point was situationally they did not create the ground to let anything sink in…. It was like a bitter tonic shoved down the throat…I don’t think they lingered on the feelings enough for us to warm up to the new dynamic… Having a parent who is at least stays accountable for past mistakes would be a better option than a parent who wilfully refuses to acknowledge your existence!! But the writing is so pathetic that the dynamic hardly makes any impact…Jhanak’s lines are so bookish and the acting sub-par ( I don’t blame the actor… really tuf to feel the emotion which does not exist😂😂) Her memory loss, her decision to stay anonymous, taking on a new identity, finding a parent in this stage of life when all is seemingly lost could have been important points in the story of the leads had been involved with each other’s story in a more significant way…

For instance that scene of sending flowers to Nutan was so mindless; the audience is supposed to imagine that Ani who sits with a pillow staring vacantly fending off baby making demands had the mind space to send flowers to Nutan for her competition 😂😂😂 what even was that nonsense?

Originally posted by: sanfan

while I agree that the narrative was building towards a hateful relationship given BBG evil twin as shown to us… it is in a writer’s ability to make a narrative shift…and get the buy-in

my point was situationally they did not create the ground to let anything sink in…. It was like a bitter tonic shoved down the throat…I don’t think they lingered on the feelings enough for us to warm up to the new dynamic… Having a parent who is at least stays accountable for past mistakes would be a better option than a parent who wilfully refuses to acknowledge your existence!! But the writing is so pathetic that the dynamic hardly makes any impact…Jhanak’s lines are so bookish and the acting sub-par ( I don’t blame the actor… really tuf to feel the emotion which does not exist😂😂) Her memory loss, her decision to stay anonymous, taking on a new identity, finding a parent in this stage of life when all is seemingly lost could have been important points in the story of the leads had been involved with each other’s story in a more significant way…

For instance that scene of sending flowers to Nutan was so mindless; the audience is supposed to imagine that Ani who sits with a pillow staring vacantly fending off baby making demands had the mind space to send flowers to Nutan for her competition 😂😂😂 what even was that nonsense?

Rekha ji, my request to you would be to not consider Leena as an able writer or story teller..I have said it multiple times in a humourous way that the initial episodes were written by someone else..Well I strongly believe so... When I got to know that it is Leena's show, I still decided to stick to it as I thought may be for national audience she has changed her style...but since Anishit marriage, whatever is shown, is actually Leena's style of storytelling...this is the trademark storyline that she follows in most of her shows..So anything logical and organic from the show atp is implausible..

..Despite this, I still find it to be a dumb approach to not focus on leads' journeys and their inner turmoils, even if separately and focussing more on unnecessary BH drama and side characters with no real contribution to the story, even if we only consider the business side of it...if they think that they will stay in the business for a long time with this shit, it is a distant dream given their current approach to progress the story.

Originally posted by: sanfan

Yahan har koi paltu ram hain…

Kabhi kuch toh kabhi kuch

I don’t think even the audience takes anything anyone says seriously 😂😂

On a different note, I happen to watch a couple of clips of Jhanak BBG convos… Ideally this dynamic was supposed to provide some great emotional content given Jhanak’s backstory ( whether her father was the evil twin or wig baba) but the interactions look so ott… Everything is off… mainly the writing, situation in the story, therefore the acting 😂😂 looks like a scene acted out for a school play

Haww you’re saying you weren’t convinced by the scene of Wig waale Papa making KHEER for his beloved bitiya and both of them feeding kheer oh so lovingly to each other? 😂😂

Also that oh so “touching” speech from Jhanak about how chhoti Jhanak was always craving for Papa

Hiba has posted this reel they shot during that ad shoot

Looks like advance lollipop for Runak fans to expect them to tolerate the baby trap drama. Lol

https://x.com/vina__1508/status/1855571015851733205?s=46&t=RsHIH4xUBXmE535rNmz_9A

Originally posted by: AreYaar

Hiba has posted this reel they shot during that ad shoot

Looks like advance lollipop for Runak fans to expect them to tolerate the baby trap drama. Lol

https://x.com/vina__1508/status/1855571015851733205?s=46&t=RsHIH4xUBXmE535rNmz_9A

No one will buy it now! Their chindi tactics are exposed long back!

Originally posted by: AreYaar

Hiba has posted this reel they shot during that ad shoot

Looks like advance lollipop for Runak fans to expect them to tolerate the baby trap drama. Lol

https://x.com/vina__1508/status/1855571015851733205?s=46&t=RsHIH4xUBXmE535rNmz_9A

That's what I was thinking . Bhot bakwas hone Wali hai aane wale episodes main 😑 . I hope rc didi is not like Malini didi ....you know like izzat lutne Wali real dayan. I hope she's just a chindi vamp.

Originally posted by: ninaMAXWELL08

That's what I was thinking . Bhot bakwas hone Wali hai aane wale episodes main 😑 . I hope rc didi is not like Malini didi ....you know like izzat lutne Wali real dayan. I hope she's just a chindi vamp.

Agr makers ne Ani ko Arshi k saath Sula diya na, that too without legal marriage, iss show me aur dekh ne k liye kuchh bachega nahi. I will not root for Runak then. Ani must stay with Arshi only.

Originally posted by: Dibya_C

Agr makers ne Ani ko Arshi k saath Sula diya na, that too without legal marriage, iss show me aur dekh ne k liye kuchh bachega nahi. I will not root for Runak then. Ani must stay with Arshi only.

I don't want to get in to " ani must stay with arshi" argument just because shemay do something which will not be Ani's fault .

I'm more focused on him saving his izzat somehow ....even when he's drunk or drugged.