Ishq Murshid (Hum TV) - Bilal Abbas Khan, Dur-e-Fishan Saleem - Page 74

Shibra accepting Shameer is understandable. Generally, we say the way is not right but the intention is right. I heard reviews regarding it that he lied but he did not take advantage in a bad way. I agree to it. From the moment he appeared as FB he has been helping the family. And Shibra is in love with Shameer she can’t be harsh with him. And she herself knows what he has done for her family and she also got to know from Sukaina. When a person loves another person they always try to find excuses to be with them or to forgive them. So I understand Shibra’s reaction. Whether the girl is headstrong or meek, I think when they are in love they want to be with the person the initial reaction may be different but at the end they want to be with the person they love. And even Kashaf being a headstrong girl the reason she agreed to marry Zaroon was simple. She knew how he was like in their University days and how he was like in their working days but a small gesture won her over. I feel that for most of the girls gestures matter and here Shameer has done things for Shibra.

Judging by your reaction I’m so glad I didn’t watch 😂 and I actually feel happy about it.

What’s the point if there was never going to be even a minor setback/clash/friction post reveal? What is the bloody point lol.

Shibra is never gonna challenge Shahmeer and that is just pathetic writing. Because she was never shown to be like that. They skipped right to the resolution when both characters haven’t even earned it.

Side note but kya drama hai rated Durre’s acting higher than Bilal this week and I’m just like 🤯🤯🤯😱🤣 BE REAL GUYS

Her life has not been hard like Hala, Zubia, Kashaf or even Aaliya so her reaction has to be different. Her father has been taking the responsibilities of the house, she's loved by her parents so I won't even compare her with the likes of them. I liked Zubia & Aaliya and enjoyed Zubia's growth. Didn't Aaliya give in to Salman's love when she was calling him a typical mard before? Kashaf did that as well. Zaroon questioning her for not talking about Usama's proposal when he had a serious relationship himself with Asmara & still she went back to him. The novel had him believing some letters without a name & questioning her character & she still took him back. Everybody has some flexibility when it comes to love. Understanding a character doesn't mean that the character is right, we just relate to the character. I didn't like Kashaf. There are a few things in a character that I can never relate to, disrespect, ungratefulness, not having empathy. Kashaf was extremely ungrateful. I didn't like her.

If Shahmeer had done anything wrong with Shibra or her family then I would've wanted a strong reaction from her. As of now it's alright for me if his changing of identity hasn't generated it. I can understand her.

Originally posted by: tgota92

Judging by your reaction I’m so glad I didn’t watch 😂 and I actually feel happy about it.

What’s the point if there was never going to be even a minor setback/clash/friction post reveal? What is the bloody point lol.

Shibra is never gonna challenge Shahmeer and that is just pathetic writing. Because she was never shown to be like that. They skipped right to the resolution when both characters haven’t even earned it.

Side note but kya drama hai rated Durre’s acting higher than Bilal this week and I’m just like 🤯🤯🤯😱🤣 BE REAL GUYS

Bold: when?

I watched one episode yesterday & they were literally scared while talking about Bilal

Marina was saying I love him & Rubina was like he has everything to be a superstar, in fact he is a superstar. Shamoon rated him & got done with it

Originally posted by: pressu

Shibra accepting Shameer is understandable. Generally, we say the way is not right but the intention is right. I heard reviews regarding it that he lied but he did not take advantage in a bad way. I agree to it. From the moment he appeared as FB he has been helping the family. And Shibra is in love with Shameer she can’t be harsh with him. And she herself knows what he has done for her family and she also got to know from Sukaina. When a person loves another person they always try to find excuses to be with them or to forgive them. So I understand Shibra’s reaction. Whether the girl is headstrong or meek, I think when they are in love they want to be with the person the initial reaction may be different but at the end they want to be with the person they love. And even Kashaf being a headstrong girl the reason she agreed to marry Zaroon was simple. She knew how he was like in their University days and how he was like in their working days but a small gesture won her over. I feel that for most of the girls gestures matter and here Shameer has done things for Shibra.

We do generally say that but shahmeer wasn't lying for some greater good. He was lying for his own selfish reasons. All this would have made sense if he changed his identity for some other reason and came to stay at Shibra's house, fell in love with her and courted her. But his entire purpose of changing his identity is to make her fall in love with him. He only showed her the side she wanted to see. He did all those nice things for her and her family to make them like him. There is a purpose to everything he did. He manipulated them to like him except sukaina who liked him because he was doing everything her father couldn't and making her life easy. The entire shibra falling for him is orchestrated by him. She didn't fall in love with shahmeer sikander, a rich guy who is gonna be a future pm but Fazal baksh. If it was so easy for shibra to forgive him, shahmeer could have just courted her as shahmeer and just hide the fact that he is dawood's son. Also if shibra was someone who would just forgive a guy simply because of he didn't had any bad intention why is she shown to be someone who can't stand any bit of wrong doing? What was that all I hate rich people speech? Now that she understood the advantages of a rich guy being head over heels for her she is fine with rich people.

Zaroon was very straightforward with what he wanted from her after they met again. He wasn't lying or manipulating her. He straight up proposed her and courted her directly. He proved that he changed and gave her a reason to belive him. Nothing of that sort happened here. One day shibra got to know that the entire identity and personality of the guy she fell for is a fake and the next day after a little ted talk with her system who gaslighted her, everything was swept under the rug and she only cares about her father not agreeing for the alliance for obvious and valid reasons. The drama even shows Sulaiman is in the wrong

How is shibra fine with the fact that shahmeer and Fazal baksh have entirely different personalities?

The episode of Kya Drama Hai released today with Sadia Imam, Marina Khan and Nadia Khan. They’re all disappointed with the climax - as expected. But the ratings on acting was a bit bizarre for me. Maybe they rated Bilal lower coz Shibra had more scenes than him last week. But still… cmon - Bilal is a far better actor than Durre.

This week Jaan e Jahaan won a lot of categories including best actor , actress and drama of the week as well. I’m not watching that show so don’t know, but IM took a step back overall.

Shahmeer is such a red flag, I don’t get why people don’t wanna admit it. His flaws are interesting people. It’s what makes him layered. But the show molding Shibra’s reaction into a non reaction is white washing him, which is what is problematic. If she shuns him for a while, challenges his deceit and then later they reconcile, nobody would be complaining. It’s just that Shibra’s lack of reaction is not doing justice to the story we have been watching and that’s unfair to the character, the story and the audience.

Yes we can find excuses for Shibra’s lack of reaction. But that’s just what it is. Excuses. Literally any other turn of events would have been far more interesting. Not to mention the writing has given them zero good lines post reveal. It’s tragic. This is the friggin climax and I was bored with the “ghareeb aadmi” line which I didn’t even remember was even a thing between them. Like.. what even?

Originally posted by: Haalim

Her life has not been hard like Hala, Zubia, Kashaf or even Aaliya so her reaction has to be different. Her father has been taking the responsibilities of the house, she's loved by her parents so I won't even compare her with the likes of them. I liked Zubia & Aaliya and enjoyed Zubia's growth. Didn't Aaliya give in to Salman's love when she was calling him a typical mard before? Kashaf did that as well. Zaroon questioning her for not talking about Usama's proposal when he had a serious relationship himself with Asmara & still she went back to him. The novel had him believing some letters without a name & questioning her character & she still took him back. Everybody has some flexibility when it comes to love. Understanding a character doesn't mean that the character is right, we just relate to the character. I didn't like Kashaf. There are a few things in a character that I can never relate to, disrespect, ungratefulness, not having empathy. Kashaf was extremely ungrateful. I didn't like her.

If Shahmeer had done anything wrong with Shibra or her family then I would've wanted a strong reaction from her. As of now it's alright for me if his changing of identity hasn't generated it. I can understand her.

In both aaliya and kasaf's case it's only arguments and fight between couple with real identities. Neither salman nor zaroon faked themselves in front of Aaliya or Kasaf (not counting the college time). Good or bad they were themselves. Does shibra know who shahmeer is? Shahmeer is a guy who will kidnap and blackmail people just like that to get things done his way. Shibra got to know the truth one day and the next day she totally adjusted to the fact that Fazal is shahmeer. There is no shock no reaction no anger, nothing. Kasaf left the house when she got to know zaroon was meeting his ex and Aaliya stopped trying to please salman. It look weeks and months for these girls to forgive the guys for lying or showing unwanted anger.

The entire shibra falling for Fazal itself is orchestrated by him. Zaroon in college tried to do that but failed miserably. Forget making Kasaf falling for him he didn't even manage to make her softer towards him. Zaroon didn't gain anything when he tried to fake it. He got her when he was straightforward and real. Salman also lost when he was being unreasonable and he had to realise he was wrong and put efforts to get back Aaliya. If zaroon and Salman were wrong they faced the heat for that and neither of these girls were shown to be the flag barer of righteousness and principles like shibra. They both had their own flaws and principles but never went around preaching that.

The friction is between Shibra & her father this time. They had similar morals, yet their perception of Shahmeer is different. Shibra's perception clouded by love & Suleiman's by betrayal. They have detailed conversations & they are calling each other out, only if Durre had a good dialogue delivery the scenes would have come out to be better.

While Shibra liked FB's innocence & goofiness she started falling for him when they started discussing different things. They have had detailed scenes where she was clearly impressed by FB's deep meaningful talks. It was a Shahmeer inside FB talking. She would clearly get surprised when he talked like Shahmeer & would even say that he sounds different.

Also Shahmeer didn't help the family because he wanted Shibra. He had just met her mother when he helped her without even Shibra knowing. Same with Sukaina, he connected with her on personal level. If he had not been Shahmeer Shibra wouldn't have come out of jail. He never took the credit of doing these things for her family, it was Suleiman who started associating these things with him being a maulayi.

Shahmeer's changing of identity has been wrong on his part though, not denying it.

Originally posted by: tgota92

Shahmeer is such a red flag, I don’t get why people don’t wanna admit it. His flaws are interesting people. It’s what makes him layered. But the show molding Shibra’s reaction into a non reaction is white washing him, which is what is problematic. If she shuns him for a while, challenges his deceit and then later they reconcile, nobody would be complaining. It’s just that Shibra’s lack of reaction is not doing justice to the story we have been watching and that’s unfair to the character, the story and the audience.

Yes we can find excuses for Shibra’s lack of reaction. But that’s just what it is. Excuses. Literally any other turn of events would have been far more interesting. Not to mention the writing has given them zero good lines post reveal. It’s tragic. This is the friggin climax and I was bored with the “ghareeb aadmi” line which I didn’t even remember was even a thing between them. Like.. what even?

Exactly. It's her reaction to his actions that is problematic. Just because he isn't violent doesn't mean he is not problematic. The fact remains shibra didn't fall for him naturally. She was manipulated into it and then gaslighted into forgiving him. She don't even know who shahmeer is and instead of trying to know who he is she is busy blaming her father for not bending to her love

Forgiving a guy one loves who was unreasonable or rude or failed to understand you in a particular matter is entirely different from a relationship that's fully based on lies and manipulation.