YRKKH Frustration Thread #1 [DT NOTE PG 30,44, 126]- Page 55

Created

Last reply

Replies

1k

Views

67.9k

Users

121

Likes

3k

Frequent Posters

Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: JustaFan13

This is a wrong notion.

Why should women be called characterless if she wants to go back to her ex??

The same woman was hailed when she moved on from her ex and married a stranger just to give her son a father!!!

We are living in 2023 and the society has evolved. It's one's own choice, if they want to remain single or get married to someone.

Getting back to an ex is not characterless and I do not think anyone is saying that here. The post was saying the way they are showing the story here as if AK is made to fall into AbhiMs arms and straight go to his bed even before AbhiN is dying. And whether u agree or not AbhiN is on paper and socially AK's current husband now. So the story treatment is making AK look like characterless. If the story was handled differently and she takes time but eventually goes back I do not think anyone will say she is being characterless.

Posted: 3 years ago

The staying single ship long sailed away in case of Abhira. AK chose to rear the child by getting remarried. If that marriage was not offensive or repulsive for society or trp viewers, her trying to work out her first marriage and really give the relationship another effort and chance should not be repulsive either. We may have not heard or read such real stories becos yeh sab sirf itv mein hota hai. Real life mein, a character such as Abhi who has time and again professed his love for AK, would never cause WD in the first place.

NomadicWonders thumbnail
Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail 3rd Anniversary Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: Chaitu.V

wanting a family is not selfishness , in those 7 months they became friends ,also he was the 1st one to hold the baby even before his mother , so he also got attached to the baby. Ak didn’t want to go back to her family so he agreed , what’s selfishness in that. Who doesn’t want a family, and baby’s mother herself asked him to be baby’s father and being an orphan he knows how it feels living without parents. He was always shown as selfless . if he only wants a kid /kids he could have married some other girl and have kids too, but still selflessly dedicated his life to both of them and now dying for them too.



When Akshara asked him to be father of her child, she was being selfish to think that she can expect a man to be married to her just for being a father and in the same way Abhinav accepting that proposal was selfish too.


It’s not selfish to want a family, he could very well find a girl who wanted to marry him and have children adopted or otherwise, but did he do that? Instead he “married” someone not for her or not for a genuine relationship but to be a “fatherji”. Was he doing this as an ahsaan for Ak, or for the newborn child? Or did he marry Ak out of sympathy for both? No, it was his decision because he also wanted to be father of that child, so how is that selfless decision.

No doubt he did justice to father-son relationship created and went beyond, but I would definitely not applaud his marriage decision and he is going through the aftermath for that decision taken without thinking and understanding the implications.

Both Ak and Abhinav were adults, it was their consent, their choice. So why is Abhinav hailed as selfless and seen to have sacrificed 6 years of life. He chose that life out of his desire to be father of that child and lived that life, so how is that selflessly dedicating 6 years of life to both of them.


And dying hasn’t happened yet, so we will see how that is when it gets telecasted.

NomadicWonders thumbnail
Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail 3rd Anniversary Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: Aashiqanafan

Getting back to an ex is not characterless and I do not think anyone is saying that here. The post was saying the way they are showing the story here as if AK is made to fall into AbhiMs arms and straight go to his bed even before AbhiN is dying. And whether u agree or not AbhiN is on paper and socially AK's current husband now. So the story treatment is making AK look like characterless. If the story was handled differently and she takes time but eventually goes back I do not think anyone will say she is being characterless.

bold above - She fell because she was ill and weak and AbhiM caught her from falling. It wasn’t romantic or anything. And same for “straight go to his bed”. She was ill and was being tended to by her family. What are we taking about being characterless here!!
Noorain13 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: NomadicWonders

I know you mean it as sarcasm, but I would like to know as well why he married Akshara?

Did he think she couldn’t take care of her child, so he did ahsaan on her and married her, mind you they didn’t live a married life though? Or did he do ahsaan on the kid by becoming a father because hey every kid needs a father!!

Please explain his selfless act.

I don’t think I have to answer this because Nav himself answered it in the show saying when he held Abhir is his arms and kept him with him for 3 days while Akshara was unconscious, he developed a bond with him and so that when Akshara asked him to be Abhir’s father, he couldn’t say no. Nav never said he did some kind of favor to them, he has always been grateful for his family. Akshara at one point thought she’s indebted to Nav which Nav cleared hence they moved forward in their relationship. So for people to say he was selfish in these acts is beyond me.

NomadicWonders thumbnail
Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail 3rd Anniversary Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: Noorain13

I don’t think I have to answer this because Nav himself answered it in the show saying when he held Abhir is his arms and kept him with him for 3 days while Akshara was unconscious, he developed a bond with him and so that when Akshara asked him to be Abhir’s father, he couldn’t say no. Nav never said he did some kind of favor to them, he has always been grateful for his family. Akshara at one point thought she’s indebted to Nav which Nav cleared hence they moved forward in their relationship. So for people to say he was selfish in these acts is beyond me.

So it wasn’t ahsaan for Ak, or for the newborn child, nor did he marry Ak out of sympathy for both. It was his decision because he also wanted to be father of that child, so how is that selfless decision.

When Akshara asked him to be father of her child, she was being selfish to think that she can expect a man to be married to her just for being a father and in the same way Abhinav accepting that proposal was selfish too.

Both Ak and Abhinav are adults and marriage decision was their choice with consent. So why is Abhinav hailed as selfless here and seen to have sacrificed 6 years of life. He chose that life out of his desire to be father of that child and lived that life, so how is that selflessly dedicating 6 years of life to both of them.

No doubt he did justice to father-son relationship created and went beyond, but I would definitely not applaud his marriage decision or call it and life that followed his selfless sacrifice act for Ak and Abhir.

Susi26 thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3

Team Critics

Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: Sonali1968

Please make me understand are there any sequence or logic

Nav is dying news news news. A truck hitting Nav s car Akshu anxious Happy Abhira FD last day of Nav Promo comes AK bashing Abhimanyu Nav ji ko chin liya chalo divided opinion

Then precap new Abhir requesting for Mama Papa this is like Har Kar bhi jeet na bazigar vibes compensation to Dr Birla FD Akshu feeling sorry 😢 Cool soulmate Navji was standing there I think I am right in the same pink shirt Seriously please give a new shirt to Nav just bcz he is dying you cannot give him same shirt or it is Nav ji ka ghost

In midst of this comes family fun time 🕰️ this maker has made plan A plan B and totally confused what to show

Really?? I didn’t see the episode yet. So are they telecasting two different plots for tv and Hotstar viewers 😲. Jay soni’s exit interview is only circulating in articles, never telecasted on tv or online. Now even I’m getting doubts.
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: NomadicWonders

When Akshara asked him to be father of her child, she was being selfish to think that she can expect a man to be married to her just for being a father and in the same way Abhinav accepting that proposal was selfish too.


It’s not selfish to want a family, he could very well find a girl who wanted to marry him and have children adopted or otherwise, but did he do that? Instead he “married” someone not for her or not for a genuine relationship but to be a “fatherji”. Was he doing this as an ahsaan for Ak, or for the newborn child? Or did he marry Ak out of sympathy for both? No, it was his decision because he also wanted to be father of that child, so how is that selfless decision.

No doubt he did justice to father-son relationship created and went beyond, but I would definitely not applaud his marriage decision and he is going through the aftermath for that decision taken without thinking and understanding the implications.

Both Ak and Abhinav were adults, it was their consent, their choice. So why is Abhinav hailed as selfless and seen to have sacrificed 6 years of life. He chose that life out of his desire to be father of that child and lived that life, so how is that selflessly dedicating 6 years of life to both of them.


And dying hasn’t happened yet, so we will see how that is when it gets telecasted.

LOL ! Exactly he could have married and got his own kid if it’s just about kids ,but he was there through out the pregnancy with Ak , he risked his life to save them both and he was holding the baby for 3 days continuously ,so he got attached to the kid . From whatever little he knows and also from Ak n AbM’s phone conversation he got an idea that her husband don’t want her or her baby so for him he is fatherless , and he did ahsaan of course and married Ak to become Abhir’s father. His act is pure and selfless and that’s what being shown in the show too. Anyway we can agree to disagree.
sweta2005 thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail 20th Anniversary Thumbnail + 9

Team AbhiRa (Gen 3)

Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: Chaitu.V

LOL ! Exactly he could have married and got his own kid if it’s just about kids ,but he was there through out the pregnancy with Ak , he risked his life to save them both and he was holding the baby for 3 days continuously ,so he got attached to the kid . From whatever little he knows and also from Ak n AbM’s phone conversation he got an idea that her husband don’t want her or her baby so for him he is fatherless , and he did ahsaan of course and married Ak to become Abhir’s father. His act is pure and selfless and that’s what being shown in the show too. Anyway we can agree to disagree.


He married because he was not getting any girl to get married to as he was orphan ,it was said by him in one of episode,he didnt do any selfless act ,it was for his own selfish reason he agreed for contract and post 6 years when he met abhimanyu he started his sympathy card ,

Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: sweta2005


He married because he was not getting any girl to get married to as he was orphan ,it was said by him in one of episode,he didnt do any selfless act ,it was for his own selfish reason he agreed for contract and post 6 years when he met abhimanyu he started his sympathy card ,

So no one marries an orphan? That’s new to me .. he looked/looks young when he met Ak so Neelma could have found a girl for him and got him married ,how is marrying Ak with only become father ji makes him selfish ? Only after 6yrs she accepted him as husband and confessed her love ,how is living in a love less marriage for a kid is selfish. He also have an option to adopt a kid if it’s just abt any kid ,he got attached to that kid.At least he didn’t ask someone else’s wife or didn’t force the kid to accept him as father. By phone convo he know the kids father don’t want the kid or his mom so he selflessly helped them that too only after Ak asked ,if not he would have still helped them the same way he did . He is always selfless . We can agree to disagree.
Edited by Chaitu.V - 3 years ago

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: A_Star39 · 26 days ago

What are we expecting from this track? Maira has definitely lost some braincells in 2 year leap.

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: Starwatcher01 · 23 days ago

On Instagram she celebrates completing 1000 episodes with YRKKH. Her recent interview kinda of confirms she is not leaving the show any time...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: WildestDreams · 6 months ago

Welcome to the YRKKH Weekly TRP thread! This will be the official thread to post and discuss about the weekly online and offline TRPs of Yeh...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: Trollbaaz · 2 months ago

https://www.instagram.com/p/DZhJ9RjsB6Z/

https://www.instagram.com/p/DZhJ9RjsB6Z/
Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: Arziya · 3 months ago

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Banner Contest Voting Thank you all for participating in the banner contest ~Vote for 2 (TWO) banners. ~Participants...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".