Created

Last reply

Replies

82

Views

9.3k

Users

28

Likes

226

Frequent Posters

Phir_Mohabbat thumbnail

Team Critics

Posted: 2 years ago
#71

Originally posted by: Krinya

No..i personally find js a limited actor.. I agree sgp was popular due to badi ma and suhana more than anyone else...I don't think he sits well with akshu either ..I like his character but not the actor. But at the same time I no longer want to see abhimanyu with akshu ...specially when arohi has been made so important here and bec of their past story ...


So I really don't care which way it goes ..


My only point is that makers don't care abt a particular actor or jodi or chemistry..they know how to exploit each to run their show ..I didn't expect aby trps post the leap but they did it..yrkkh is at #3 ,consistently post leap...the longer abhira are separated , there will be an intrigue factor if they will come together and how ..they will do anything to make it possible till the trps run high ..


As far as prev gen actors there should be no comparison as they r the ones who brought yrkkh to this level ..they were all good in their own right ..personally I feel abhira r the worst amongst the three. Yes km was a bit weak in acting but he played his role sincerely and a wide range of audience accepted him ..let's not ruin their 8 yrs of hardwork by saying only abhira runs the show.

who told abhira runs the show? Kuch v



From all the replies if u gathered this nothing else to write . Sayonara

Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8

Team Critics

Posted: 2 years ago
#72

Originally posted by: Snowfally

Thanks for the info.


What do you think worked better with KaiRa and Naksh wedding as compared to AbhiRa wedding?


I am an Abhinav, NavRa and Sharma family fan so I am glad post leap TRPs have been mostly good and consistent for YRKKH so far. 🤞for the future TRPs too.


They were already quite popular before the wedding.. naksh had a perfectly good and realistic arranged marriage track..at that time all the supporting characters were amazing , the emotions were real..everyone related to the arranged marriage scenario and the struggles of a girl post her marriage..they were married pretty quick..it started in Jan 2009 and they were married in jun-july time period..but the festivities , marriage functions etc was highly popular bec of hahk type treatment .


Kaira again, they were extremely populR as a couple before thy got married..they had like 8-9 months of falling in love phase which was beautiful..they wanted to give akshRa an exit so they established kaira before Hina left..and it paid off in a big way..there were so many positive tracks with a huge star cast .. all of them good.




I don't think anything worked for abhira as they were doomed from the start..abhinanyus anger , his obsession with akshu plus his decision to marry aroo , akshus lying and sacrificing for aroo left a bad taste ..falling in love with akshu was quicker than 2 mins Maggie noodles..they were married in a blink of the eye after marriage with aroo broke off..the marriage functions were overshadowed with stupid tracks such as manjaris accident , leading to abhimanyu almost canceling the marriage. There was no positivity left in the show n I don't count dance dreams floating hearts as positive. There was no substance no depth to their love story. Shadi itself was grand but except for their costumes, there was nothing great abt shadi with 10 family members and abhimanyu taking off with akshu on his "bike" . Basically no doli no bidai scenes which were the usp of the prev shadis.

Snowfally thumbnail
Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail 3rd Anniversary Thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago
#73

Originally posted by: Silveraliax


I don't see the point of this post.

You have limited Abhira journey to mere 3 months. Why not compare first 3 months of Abhira to first 3 months of Nav? Then the comparison is fair.

Even then, show is currently running on Abhi too whereas Abhira were managing alone before with such faltu tracks.

Anyways, if you really think it was okay for writers to change Abhi's character midway (which was most definitely done for the leap) then it doesn't seem likely you will ever understand my point. Abhi had some anger issues but he wasn't heartless and we all know how much he cared for Akshara. The change was sudden and rushed for me to digest.

Maybe if they turn Nav negative then you will see my pov.

You said

Abhira were happy too but they still managed 2.5 or 2.2 type trps with minimum drama and no Nav ....

On average, it has maintained 2.5 trp and this is just Abhira centric episodes mind you so Abhira's worst trp days are today's best trp days... I remember members used to say 2.5 trp is bad and now its good? Personally, I look at ranking so for me show has always even good in season 3 minus on 3 occasions

This post was in response to that. AbhiRa 's worst TRP days are not today's best TRP days. It's higher. Ranking has also improved since Oct 22 overall.

I am not limiting the journey of AbhiRa to 3 months. Infact, I have already mentioned in my last post that I agree with you that AbhiRa are more popular than NavRa (atleast online). I agreed that you were right as regards absolute TRPs as well. You can check out my last post to you.

It has been nearly 3 months of post leap so I took the last 3 months of pre leap.The decision for leap was not taken during the first 3 months of AbhiRa, so I didn't take those TRPs. These TRPs show that Abhinav has been accepted as the TRP audience. Comparing last week's TRP to this week's TRP, NavRa from Akshara's side has also been accepted by TRP audience. I will maintain that till the TRPs are good and consistent. If the TRPs fall, I will know that NavRa is no longer working. You mentioned about story being important and these TRPs show that the post leap story has worked.

I hope other people see this post as well that the show is running on Abhi too and if TRPs fall, don't shift the entire blame on 'AA'.

I have already mentioned in my post to you that I don't feel that Abhimanyu has been butchered for Abhinav and have given my reasons for that. I can say that you aren't understanding my perspective either. I will say though, it's best to agree to disagree here. :)

If they do turn Abhinav negative, as I have always mentioned before I will leave the show with Abhinav or when it becomes unbearable. I will certainly be very disappointed that the TRP audience didn't click with Abhinav the way I did. You won't get to see 'Accha Aadmi' type thing on Abhimanyu from my posts, even then.

Edited by Snowfally - 2 years ago
Silvertarax thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 2 years ago
#74

Originally posted by: Snowfally

You said

Abhira were happy too but they still managed 2.5 or 2.2 type trps with minimum drama and no Nav ....

On average, it has maintained 2.5 trp and this is just Abhira centric episodes mind you so Abhira's worst trp days are today's best trp days... I remember members used to say 2.5 trp is bad and now its good? Personally, I look at ranking so for me show has always even good in season 3 minus on 3 occasions

This post was in response to that. AbhiRa 's worst TRP days are not today's best TRP days. It's higher. Ranking has also improved since Oct 22 overall.

I am not limiting the journey of AbhiRa to 3 months. Infact, I have already mentioned in my last post that I agree with you that AbhiRa are more popular than NavRa (atleast online). I agreed that you were right as regards absolute TRPs as well. You can check out my last post to you.

It has been nearly 3 months of post leap so I took the last 3 months of pre leap.The decision for leap was not taken during the first 3 months of AbhiRa, so I didn't take those TRPs. These TRPs show that Abhinav has been accepted as the TRP audience. Comparing last week's TRP to this week's TRP, NavRa from Akshara's side has also been accepted by TRP audience. I will maintain that till the TRPs are good and consistent. If the TRPs fall, I will know that NavRa is no longer working. You mentioned about story being important and these TRPs show that the post leap story has worked.

I hope other people see this post as well that the show is running on Abhi too and if TRPs fall, don't shift the entire blame on 'AA'.

I have already mentioned in my post to you that I don't feel that Abhimanyu has been butchered for Abhinav and have given my reasons for that. I can say that you aren't understanding my perspective either. I will say though, it's best to agree to disagree here. :)

If they do turn Abhinav negative, as I have always mentioned before I will leave the show with Abhinav or when it becomes unbearable. I will certainly be very disappointed that the TRP audience didn't click with Abhinav the way I did. You won't get to see 'Accha Aadmi' type thing on Abhimanyu from my posts, even then.


Okay so you are trying to say that Nav has been accepted just like Abhira. That's fine, I agree.


Let's see how the show fares without Abhi or Akshara though. If Nav and Akshara can hold the show on their own without Abhi then I'll give them full credits. Right now, Abhi becoming the darker shade is helping trps too because audience always needs a Komolika to root for a Prena. I used to give Arohi credit during the 3.0 trp.


If trps fall then you should blame AA because you are crediting him for TRP rise no? I personally don't blame characters or actors, I blame the makers as trp is their department so I will not be blaming AA.

TRP audience is all about content, not same as online audience which is all about actors.


Yes, we will agree to disagree as I have strong feeling about the character development.


@Bold I don't see anything wrong with acha admi tag. It is what it is. People call Abhi and Akshara a lot of names too so same applies to Nav. He will not be left out.

Noorain13 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 2 years ago
#75

Originally posted by: Snowfally

You said

Abhira were happy too but they still managed 2.5 or 2.2 type trps with minimum drama and no Nav ....

On average, it has maintained 2.5 trp and this is just Abhira centric episodes mind you so Abhira's worst trp days are today's best trp days... I remember members used to say 2.5 trp is bad and now its good? Personally, I look at ranking so for me show has always even good in season 3 minus on 3 occasions

This post was in response to that. AbhiRa 's worst TRP days are not today's best TRP days. It's higher. Ranking has also improved since Oct 22 overall.

I am not limiting the journey of AbhiRa to 3 months. Infact, I have already mentioned in my last post that I agree with you that AbhiRa are more popular than NavRa (atleast online). I agreed that you were right as regards absolute TRPs as well. You can check out my last post to you.

It has been nearly 3 months of post leap so I took the last 3 months of pre leap.The decision for leap was not taken during the first 3 months of AbhiRa, so I didn't take those TRPs. These TRPs show that Abhinav has been accepted as the TRP audience. Comparing last week's TRP to this week's TRP, NavRa from Akshara's side has also been accepted by TRP audience. I will maintain that till the TRPs are good and consistent. If the TRPs fall, I will know that NavRa is no longer working. You mentioned about story being important and these TRPs show that the post leap story has worked.

I hope other people see this post as well that the show is running on Abhi too and if TRPs fall, don't shift the entire blame on 'AA'.

I have already mentioned in my post to you that I don't feel that Abhimanyu has been butchered for Abhinav and have given my reasons for that. I can say that you aren't understanding my perspective either. I will say though, it's best to agree to disagree here. :)

If they do turn Abhinav negative, as I have always mentioned before I will leave the show with Abhinav or when it becomes unbearable. I will certainly be very disappointed that the TRP audience didn't click with Abhinav the way I did. You won't get to see 'Accha Aadmi' type thing on Abhimanyu from my posts, even then.


I can already see people blaming Nav if the TRP drops next week but they couldn’t give him credit for the rise this week. Before the TRP came out, people were like watch it drop so low that they have to change episodes over night and some even assumed that they did when there was a delay with posting the episode online but then once the TRP came out people started saying that it was because of Abhi-Abhir scenes lol.
We just have to accept the fact that a single character/actor cannot contribute to the TRP. TRP audience definitely accepted Navra because Nav is a good and supportive husband and if Akshara left her marriage and went back to Abhimanyu, it would have been wrong in so many ways which some of the online audience won’t understand and that’s completely fine.
I’m personally loving Kasauli scenes these days and continue to skip Udaipur be it Birlas or Goenkas and this is coming from someone who loves HC. I can’t relate to Abhimanyu anymore plus he’s not looking good either. I don’t know who’s his stylist these days or they’re intentionally making him look that way. I know some people complain about Akshara’s look after the leap but she looks perfectly fine to me and is looking pretty. Plus she seems natural with Nav whereas Abhi and Arohi don’t even know what they’re doing on the other hand.

Fingers crossed for Nav to not turn negative. I just can’t see cvs butchering a good character to reunite the leads.

Snowfally thumbnail
Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail 3rd Anniversary Thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago
#76

Originally posted by: Noorain13


I can already see people blaming Nav if the TRP drops next week but they couldn’t give him credit for the rise this week. Before the TRP came out, people were like watch it drop so low that they have to change episodes over night and some even assumed that they did when there was a delay with posting the episode online but then once the TRP came out people started saying that it was because of Abhi-Abhir scenes lol.
We just have to accept the fact that a single character/actor cannot contribute to the TRP. TRP audience definitely accepted Navra because Nav is a good and supportive husband and if Akshara left her marriage and went back to Abhimanyu, it would have been wrong in so many ways which some of the online audience won’t understand and that’s completely fine.
I’m personally loving Kasauli scenes these days and continue to skip Udaipur be it Birlas or Goenkas and this is coming from someone who loves HC. I can’t relate to Abhimanyu anymore plus he’s not looking good either. I don’t know who’s his stylist these days or they’re intentionally making him look that way. I know some people complain about Akshara’s look after the leap but she looks perfectly fine to me and is looking pretty. Plus she seems natural with Nav whereas Abhi and Arohi don’t even know what they’re doing on the other hand.

Fingers crossed for Nav to not turn negative. I just can’t see cvs butchering a good character to reunite the leads.

Lol... I have read those comments too when the Thursday episode was delayed 😆

True, a single actor / character cannot run a show and difference of opinion is fine.

I love Kasauli too - domestic vibes, less dramatic more peaceful - I enjoy that now a days. You are the only one I have interacted with who loves both HC and Kasauli track. Good to know :)

What makes you not connect with Abhimanyu anymore?

HC looks good to me except for his hair. A good hairstyle will do wonders for his look. I personally feel even Akshara's hairstyle can be improved upon but yes she does look pretty.

Frankly, I have not warmed up to Karishma 's acting and would have preferred someone new against Abhimanyu, if the makers are going in the parallel stories direction. Abhimanyu and Aarohi do have a certain chemistry together but the acting , IMO, does not let Aarohi connect as much as it can.

Same here. 🤞Fingers crossed for Abhinav (and Kasauli family).

janecastle thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 7

Team AkshNav (Gen 3)

Posted: 2 years ago
#77

Kasauli gives me old Rishta vibes. No negativity, just domestic bliss, small everyday issues, overall peaceful atmosphere. It is a very rare scene in present day ITV. I hope we get some more good Kasauli memories before everything goes for a toss with Abhir's illness.

janecastle thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 7

Team AkshNav (Gen 3)

Posted: 2 years ago
#78

I'm waiting for the responses if TRP falls. Fandom will completely blame Abhinav, but will never give credit to him if TRP increases.

They have a high voltage drama coming up with Abhir's truth reveal and custody battle. That's their trump card for now. Let's see which side Abhimanyu will take this time.

Posted: 2 years ago
#79

Originally posted by: janecastle

Kasauli gives me old Rishta vibes. No negativity, just domestic bliss, small everyday issues, overall peaceful atmosphere. It is a very rare scene in present day ITV. I hope we get some more good Kasauli memories before everything goes for a toss with Abhir's illness.

💯 Hope they continue this for little more time and not rush to Abhira illness. Loving all positive vibes from Kasauli

Noorain13 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 2 years ago
#80

Originally posted by: Snowfally

Lol... I have read those comments too when the Thursday episode was delayed 😆

True, a single actor / character cannot run a show and difference of opinion is fine.

I love Kasauli too - domestic vibes, less dramatic more peaceful - I enjoy that now a days. You are the only one I have interacted with who loves both HC and Kasauli track. Good to know :)

What makes you not connect with Abhimanyu anymore?

HC looks good to me except for his hair. A good hairstyle will do wonders for his look. I personally feel even Akshara's hairstyle can be improved upon but yes she does look pretty.

Frankly, I have not warmed up to Karishma 's acting and would have preferred someone new against Abhimanyu, if the makers are going in the parallel stories direction. Abhimanyu and Aarohi do have a certain chemistry together but the acting , IMO, does not let Aarohi connect as much as it can.

Same here. 🤞Fingers crossed for Abhinav (and Kasauli family).


His promises lol. This man makes 10 promises per episode and we know he ain’t keeping any of them.

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Sutapasima

7 months ago

YRKKH: TRP Thread #14 : 10 Jan 2025

Welcome to the YRKKH Weekly TRP thread! This will be the official thread to post and discuss about the weekly online and offline TRPs of Yeh...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: BangBang_Shilpa

1 months ago

Yrkkh tops trp chart Yrkkh tops trp chart

https://x.com/GossipsTv/status/1948260579694498085?t=_9GSB77jDQYrkbEBC7mE5A s=19...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".