Aye Musht e Khaak (Geo) Feroz Khan, Sana Javed, Asad Siddiqui, Nimra - Page 118

Did she love him? She divorced him for a petty reason. If she loved him, she would have tried to reform him, make him a believer . I didn't understand the reason behind this whole exercise 😐 good or bad , obsessive or not , at least his love was consistent throughout . They should keep love and religion separate. Nobody seems to get the concept or the actual issue.

Originally posted by: _charu_

Did she love him? She divorced him for a petty reason. If she loved him, she would have tried to reform him, make him a believer . I didn't understand the reason behind this whole exercise 😐 good or bad , obsessive or not , at least his love was consistent throughout . They should keep love and religion separate. Nobody seems to get the concept or the actual issue.

i believe she loved him, and yes her decision was wrong and she should’ve tried to make him realize the religious values but I think she took a hasty decision out of ego and later she clearly regretted and wanted him back. Even after Mustajab punched Taqi, Dua was clearly unaffected and still wanted to go back to him, that’s only because the void in her life which Mustajab had left, she couldn’t fulfill with any other man. And Dua has said it multiple times that ‘I only left him because our ideologies didn’t match, but I know nobody can replace him in my life’

yes his love was more consistent as the writing again is from his POV, about his discovery of spirituality and selflessness, and also Sana isn’t a great actress that’s why at times she confused audience, but at the end it was clear she loved Mustajab ever since she said yes to him in second episode, love was there, the realization how important he’s for her came after the divorce.

Originally posted by: carisma2

Yes he was definitely quite the bully and annoying.

However he supported Dua and Mustajab alliance too.

Taqi was a plot contrivance to push the story to get Dua to deal with her emotions that she loves Mustajab and later the same for Mustajab.

I didn’t like Taqi at all, why did he even say yes after Dua rejected him and literally ran away with Mustajab? What’s this? No self respect and nothing at all. Dua was helpless but every time any man comes near her, she doesn’t care unless it’s Mustajab, she has always been very clear that it’s always Mustajab.

Originally posted by: carisma2

Yes he was definitely quite the bully and annoying.

However he supported Dua and Mustajab alliance too.

Taqi was a plot contrivance to push the story to get Dua to deal with her emotions that she loves Mustajab and later the same for Mustajab.

That was the saving grace of his character- otherwise he would've come across as the stereotypical chauvinistic brother.

Originally posted by: SteFanSalvaTor

i believe she loved him, and yes her decision was wrong and she should’ve tried to make him realize the religious values but I think she took a hasty decision out of ego and later she clearly regretted and wanted him back. Even after Mustajab punched Taqi, Dua was clearly unaffected and still wanted to go back to him, that’s only because the void in her life which Mustajab had left, she couldn’t fulfill with any other man. And Dua has said it multiple times that ‘I only left him because our ideologies didn’t match, but I know nobody can replace him in my life’

yes his love was more consistent as the writing again is from his POV, about his discovery of spirituality and selflessness, and also Sana isn’t a great actress that’s why at times she confused audience, but at the end it was clear she loved Mustajab ever since she said yes to him in second episode, love was there, the realization how important he’s for her came after the divorce.

This can be clearly seen in the last scene where she says Allah returning Mustajab to her felt like He returned her reason to live.....a marked difference from their first wedding night where in response to Mustajab's promise of being always together Dua talks about (using heavy Urdu words) them fulfilling all the duties and responsibilities of husband and wife commanded by Allah- felt a bit preachy to me.

This second Dua felt more natural

Originally posted by: BurakZeynep

This can be clearly seen in the last scene where she says Allah returning Mustajab to her felt like He returned her reason to live.....a marked difference from their first wedding night where in response to Mustajab's promise of being always together Dua talks about (using heavy Urdu words) them fulfilling all the duties and responsibilities of husband and wife commanded by Allah- felt a bit preachy to me.

This second Dua felt more natural

Yes, because the first Dua probably never thought how badly she’ll suffer with a Mustajab-less life, she didn’t know the efffect he and his love has on her existence, this she was cold and even at times not reciprocating his gestures of love. However, second Dua knows how without Mustajab her life was stagnant, no matter who was around her, she always wanted him back, hence her confession of him being the reason of her living. It ended so beautifully, I love the writer here. ❤️

Originally posted by: SteFanSalvaTor

yes his love was more consistent as the writing again is from his POV, about his discovery of spirituality and selflessness, and also Sana isn’t a great actress that’s why at times she confused audience, but at the end it was clear she loved Mustajab ever since she said yes to him in second episode, love was there, the realization how important he’s for her came after the divorce.

I agree . But i still can't wrap my head around their concept that a person is worth only if he/she is a believer . I loved imam sahab the most..😆

Originally posted by: _charu_

Did she love him? She divorced him for a petty reason. If she loved him, she would have tried to reform him, make him a believer . I didn't understand the reason behind this whole exercise 😐 good or bad , obsessive or not , at least his love was consistent throughout . They should keep love and religion separate. Nobody seems to get the concept or the actual issue.

Love isn't everything. Sometimes we have to let go of a lover for different reasons. Mustajab was an obssessive lover, and quite full of himself , and I didn't understand why Dua fell for him in the 1st place.😕 But I have to agree with you , coz the writing could've been more convincing. And Dua shouldn't hurry into marriage before making sure they suit eachother.

Many ppl get married out of love, but those marriages end withing few years. It proves that having a same way of thinking and aproach for married life is important. Here Dua wants to build a muslim family, which is impossible with a hubby who doesn't believe in Allah. 😊

Originally posted by: awida

Love isn't everything. Sometimes we have to let go of a lover for different reasons. Mustajab was an obssessive lover, and quite full of himself , and I didn't understand why Dua fell for him in the 1st place.😕 But I have to agree with you , coz the writing could've been more convincing. And Dua shouldn't hurry into marriage before making sure they suit eachother.

Many ppl get married out of love, but those marriages end withing few years. It proves that having a same way of thinking and aproach for married life is important. Here Dua wants to build a muslim family, which is impossible with a hubby who doesn't believe in Allah. 😊

Thoda sa nai it was too contrived . Dua wasn't interested in marriage , she was giving one excuse after other to delay the marriage .the plot point was lies , obsession and manipulation of a guy who should be rightfully divorced . But dua puts a condition that she is ok with everything but not the fact that he is an aethist. Chalo. She divorced . Now she loves him n he pretends to be a believer ..if she didn't had the accident , he would be living this lie and she wouldn't know ..belief happened by chance 😆 Does dua even know what was mustajab ?love changed him, his mom's death or belief in Allah did ?or Fear that he will lose what's most precious to him?

somehow all is well that ends well. At least it was a happy ending. That's good.

Originally posted by: _charu_

Thoda sa nai it was too contrived . Dua wasn't interested in marriage , she was giving one excuse after other to delay the marriage .the plot point was lies , obsession and manipulation of a guy who should be rightfully divorced . But dua puts a condition that she is ok with everything but not the fact that he is an aethist. Chalo. She divorced . Now she loves him n he pretends to be a believer ..if she didn't had the accident , he would be living this lie and she wouldn't know ..belief happened by chance 😆 Does dua even know what was mustajab was but somehow all is well that ends well. At least it was a happy ending. That's good.

Right. It was a belief by chance. 😒 I hoped for a real change in Mustajab's behavior which happens after he realizes the need of belief in his life.. anyway.. Writing a spiritual drama isn't an easy task. KAM3 too wasn't convincing, because it promoted a non practical way of following religion, where Farhad apandoned his family and stayed jobless in that mazar. 😔