Imlie Written Updates and Episode Discussions 25 Feb 2022 - Page 15

Originally posted by: Krantikari

What can I do, since my contextual reading skills are so weak.😛

maybe be more clear in your writing next time for dumb dumbs like me who don’t hold PhDs in literary criticism unlike you.😆

Oh, forgot the lesson where my PhD supervisor told me that I must start every sentence with a noun because pronouns and contexts are such uselessly poor writing devices.

Thanks for this obviously constructive criticism.

[I meant to thank you, the original poster, in the sentence above. Just to be clear! :)]

Originally posted by: Deltablues

Since, we are talking about storyline, it is based on a precap which you have taken a priori for your entire storyline that doesn't exist as of yet. That was my point in saying that "Usse manipulate karne toh, abhi tak Kiya bhi nahi hai".

This reminds me too much of students who just chhapo article abstracts and Wikipedia intros, and then get failed for logical fallacies.

I mean, I would also fail a student for being lazy enough to write an entire critique by just chappoing things, but who am I to comment with my strawmen, lol.

I’ve seen enough of these shows to know how they usually go. And that’s what I’ve said here.

Imlie’s behavioural pattern has been pingponging between Tripathis/Adi and ASR. It’s only logical that her behaviour will not suddenly change after marriage with ASR.

As for ASR’s manipulating, he’s also manipulated her ever since he’s entered the show. Obviously his behaviour also won’t change overnight.

LISA!

Another atrangi dictionary!

Originally posted by: Deltablues

A forced marriage was always a given since Gul show. I was saying this since we had that poll in dt 14-15. The difference between Aryan and Gul's previous forced marriages, including the shotgun wedding, is that Imlie wouldn't have to earn the rights of a wife because Aru doesn't shirk responsibilities. All the whilst he will do his best to not act entitled towards Imlie. Sure, his possessiveness will surface most prominently to every third-party but he'd do his best to not curtail Imlie's personal freedom. He'd make sure their personal equation doesn't change beyond what is unavoidable.

I'd give it a benefit of doubt for now. Because nothing has aired yet. All we have is a vague promo and few words.

Yes the truth wouldn't much different but isn't half knowledge a lot dangerous ? I do hope they show some morality while executing the track given they've been so hell bent upon showing the differences between Aryan and AKT.

Ignoring both the men, speaking and thinking as a woman , it'd be great injustice if they force her into another marriage. Unfortunately we cannot do anything about the plot. The best we can do is not put on rose tinted glasses and call out things if they're wrong. Abuse is abuse and toxicity is toxicity. Be it anywhere

We cannot ignore what's wrong with us just because there's an opposing fandom and a conflict of interest. This applies to both the sides.

Coming to Aryan, given his character arc, making him do such a despicable thing would be shooting yourself in the foot. Let's hope they don't do that

Originally posted by: Potterhead3009

I'd give it a benefit of doubt for now. Because nothing has aired yet. All we have is a vague promo and few words.

Yes the truth wouldn't much different but isn't half knowledge a lot dangerous ? I do hope they show some morality while executing the track given they've been so hell bent upon showing the differences between Aryan and AKT.

Ignoring both the men, speaking and thinking as a woman , it'd be great injustice if they force her into another marriage. Unfortunately we cannot do anything about the plot. The best we can do is not put on rose tinted glasses and call out things if they're wrong. Abuse is abuse and toxicity is toxicity. Be it anywhere

We cannot ignore what's wrong with us just because there's an opposing fandom and a conflict of interest. This applies to both the sides.

Coming to Aryan, given his character arc, making him do such a despicable thing would be shooting yourself in the foot. Let's hope they don't do that

Oh absolutely. I didn't mean Aryan coercing or cornering Imlie into a marriage, I just meant a an abnormal marriage that wasn't followed by a courtship. A marriage of convenience, if you will. I, honestly, don't see a plausible reason why Aryan would need to manipulate Imlie into a marriage. None of the plot till this point indicates that he's thinking in those terms. If anything, he's tormented by the fact that he might have to let her go.

The precap is just a bait because why would Aryan care about saving Aditya from something so severe that Imlie might be compelled to marry him unwillingly?

I won't just end up defending or condemning Aryan when I don't even know what the storyline is. What I did see in the last episode is Aditya breathing down Imlie's neck when she's explicitly asked him to not touch her or get too close to her twice before. So there goes that

Originally posted by: Deltablues

Oh absolutely. I didn't mean Aryan coercing or cornering Imlie into a marriage, I just meant a an abnormal marriage that wasn't followed by a courtship. A marriage of convenience, if you will. I, honestly, don't see a plausible reason why Aryan would need to manipulate Imlie into a marriage. None of the plot till this point indicates that he's thinking in those terms. If anything, he's tormented by the fact that he might have to let her go.

The precap is just a bait because why would Aryan care about saving Aditya from something so severe that Imlie might be compelled to marry him unwillingly?

I won't just end up defending or condemning Aryan when I don't even know what the storyline is. What I did see in the last episode is Aditya breathing down Imlie's neck when she's explicitly asked him to not touch her or get too close to her twice before. So there goes that

We exist in the same fandom behen, I get your intentions completely 🤍🤍

My post was in a general sense, you know basically saying 'yes, we ship them but not at the cost of common sense'

I believe we can seperate Aryan and Imlie and view the circumstances and consequences of the marriage individually.

At the end of the day they're their own person and it'd be an injustice if erase that individuality to ship them.

Originally posted by: Potterhead3009

We exist in the same fandom behen, I get your intentions completely 🤍🤍

My post was in a general sense, you know basically saying 'yes, we ship them but not at the cost of common sense'

I believe we can seperate Aryan and Imlie and view the circumstances and consequences of the marriage individually.

At the end of the day they're their own person and it'd be an injustice if erase that individuality to ship them.

Haina? Especially when, for the first time in a decade, we have a romantic hero who priortises the FL's freedom over everything else. I am reminded of the unease he felt at her submission when she switched to "sir"/"aap" while asking him for that loan

He's his flaws but he won't ask Imlie to lose out her individuality, career, ideas just to be his wife. He's not that man, and Imlie is simply not that woman anymore.

Originally posted by: Deltablues

Haina? Especially when, for the first time in a decade, we have a romantic hero who priortises the FL's freedom over everything else. I am reminded of the unease he felt at her submission when she switched to "sir"/"aap" while asking him for that loan

He's his flaws but he won't ask Imlie to lose out her individuality, career, ideas just to be his wife. He's not that man, and Imlie is simply not that woman anymore.

Exactly..Aryan's dark. No one can disagree with that. Even Imlie in some corner knows that he wouldn't do something with giving it a thought and calculating profit.

It's better to grapple with a known devil than to live with a misplaced sense of just and righteousness. Anyone who refuses to look beyond their own POV is someone that should be dropped.

Exactly, let's hope this Imlie won't be treated as a servant under the pretext of beginning of a new love.

I have high hopes

Originally posted by: Potterhead3009

Exactly..Aryan's dark. No one can disagree with that. Even Imlie in some corner knows that he wouldn't do something with giving it a thought and calculating profit.

It's better to grapple with a known devil than to live with a misplaced sense of just and righteousness. Anyone who refuses to look beyond their own POV is someone that should be dropped.

Exactly, let's hope this Imlie won't be treated as a servant under the pretext of beginning of a new love.

I have high hopes

Imagine Aru, who refused eat at the table upon which she was serving, letting anyone treat his wife as a servant.

Just, eh, don't rehash Ishqbaaz or some ish and I am good.

Btw, did we ever get a scene of eating at the Tripathis?

By forced marriage, I want to know how people define it ? I might be playing the devil's advocate here but for me, AKT's and Imlie's PD marriage was a forced wedding where people's (mainly AKT's) lives were at stakes. Here, just according to the promo we saw Aryan saying to Imlie that if you want to save Aditya, you have to marry me. I am assuming it's not something that is fatal to AKT's life, it's probably his job or him somehow going to jail. Bachana /Save kab karna padhta hain? If the person was wrong before or did something unsavory, that is why he has to be implicated. Now what I gathered from here is that Aryan gave Imlie a choice, she has the choice to not save BS, hence not going through the wedding. Right now, AKT is her nothing except step-jijaji (Malini being step sister) but as we know Imlie, she will jump right in to everything related to Tripathis. And her saviour complex will flare up again and she will marry Aryan. Still, I can't particularly call it being forced to marry, it will imply a lack of choice/consent. Here she knows what she is getting into, no matter how difficult it is for her. She chooses to save AKT. She is making a choice. Of course, she will get the feeling of being cornered and forced to make a decision, but the decision is hers at the end of the day.