vishal-shekar...bias and wrong judges?

i think its wrong to have vishal-shekar as judges....they have already been the judges of an other show.....i find them bias against some ppl in the show...like when priyani from VOICE OF INDIA....sung that song from sathiya this week....it was awesome......she has sung this same song before in Voice Of India....and she got 10's......she sung it the same exact way!!

I dont agree either. VS are the most unbiased judges anyone could ask for.

I think they both are great judges. They listen to you with enthusiasm, they tell you vey frankly wht the probs were... my only disappointment is that they've been showing a little fovorism lately.
But apart from this, the'yre gr8 to have as judges. 😊

I won't call them biased judges. If at all , they may be called emotional judges. They very often praise good performances to skies. Standing ovation is quite common. Overall they are very good judges but they need to be less emotional and should stop giving standing ovation frequently.

Originally posted by: Hrithik_rocks

i think its wrong to have vishal-shekar as judges....they have already been the judges of an other show.....i find them bias against some ppl in the show...like when priyani from VOICE OF INDIA....sung that song from sathiya this week....it was awesome......she has sung this same song before in Voice Of India....and she got 10's......she sung it the same exact way!!

I agree to an extent... Firstly, they ask rooprekha - kya aap hamare liye gaayengi😆 zaroor gayengi 😆 well, i wont believe she was that great that u offer her a song right away... Second, on Prajakta issue, giving 10s was a blunder... Fine, she wasnt well or whatever, but how does it ask for 10/10...😕

Originally posted by: smallwonder

I agree to an extent... Firstly, they ask rooprekha - kya aap hamare liye gaayengi😆 zaroor gayengi 😆 well, i wont believe she was that great that u offer her a song right away... Second, on Prajakta issue, giving 10s was a blunder... Fine, she wasnt well or whatever, but how does it ask for 10/10...😕

i 3rd agree althoug i dont dislike VS... i like vishal atleast he gave priyani 9 nd she really deserved more marks frm all judges... but faraha gave her 7 while she gave neha 8 which dosnt make any sense😕.. in harshit case also same...comon they r not thr to judge how popualr song they sing ..harshit was really fantastic..even if they hvnt heard dt song b4 they should be capable of figure out how he sang it since they r gud muzic directors..nd they should kno how to comment abt sur nd thaal ..evry body knows he sang such a difficult song nd i was really impressed.... but they ended da discussion wit his song selection being not popular which i didnt like most.. otherwise i feel the judges r okk not bad...but i think they should stop being emotional.. like they did in prajakta case by giving her 10 althoug i felt bad for her as she is a fab singer👏

Originally posted by: smallwonder

I agree to an extent... Firstly, they ask rooprekha - kya aap hamare liye gaayengi😆 zaroor gayengi 😆 well, i wont believe she was that great that u offer her a song right away... Second, on Prajakta issue, giving 10s was a blunder... Fine, she wasnt well or whatever, but how does it ask for 10/10...😕

i totally agree especially with the prajakta case..it was weird😕..but i still like them as judges ..i mean i wont they that they r exactly biased...many a times i do agree with their comments but yes they shud be less emotional...and be lil more just

I mean no one is perfect... but compared to most of the judges in reality shows VS are way better.

i dont find them to b biased...till now (xcept 4 prajakta gettin 10) they have been pretty fair in their marks n comments...a little diff in the judgments can b put down to individual choice but on the whole they have been pretty spot on

Originally posted by: madhy

i 3rd agree althoug i dont dislike VS... i like vishal atleast he gave priyani 9 nd she really deserved more marks frm all judges... but faraha gave her 7 while she gave neha 8 which dosnt make any sense😕.. in harshit case also same...comon they r not thr to judge how popualr song they sing ..harshit was really fantastic..even if they hvnt heard dt song b4 they should be capable of figure out how he sang it since they r gud muzic directors..nd they should kno how to comment abt sur nd thaal ..evry body knows he sang such a difficult song nd i was really impressed.... but they ended da discussion wit his song selection being not popular which i didnt like most.. otherwise i feel the judges r okk not bad...but i think they should stop being emotional.. like they did in prajakta case by giving her 10 althoug i felt bad for her as she is a fab singer👏

perfectly said!!

thats kinda wat im trying to say....!!

ok mabey there not that bias....but i still think that they are not fair..