Rahul's ramta jogi ...not as good as...

Out of all the performances, Rahul was the best singer but personally I did not enjoy it. I know everyone in the forum seems to be in love with Rahul and loves it but you really have to hear
Hemachandra sing ramta jogi from srgmp 2005.
You'll be blown away.
After that you can't give 10 marks to Rahul... no way.
Here's the youtube link....
http://youtube.com/watch?v=oK2go96eG3M&feature=related

What do you think....?

rahul vaidya's perfo..was a good stage show performance....

and hema's was more technically right in singing aspects.....

any day i prefer...hema's version....which i felt better than rahul's..........

omg!!! hemu was simply awesum in srgmp!! when i heard tht song i remember subhash ghai himself was present and he gave the standing ovation !!
when hemu sang ..i felt tht he did justice and was sumwhere near the original ....and i really got the feel when he sang!!
rahul was gud no doubt but still i found sumthing missing th twas needed to perform this song 😊

ya he was not as gud to get 10/10 but he was much better thn other contestants and once compare him wth karunya's ramta jogi in indian idol 2 then u will know who sa ng it better

i will say the difference guys this is not any saregamapa or indian idol where they have to prove themselves .these contestnats already proved their calibre once in their respective show and also if it was any saregamapa or indian idol or voice of india contest then the contestants shd be 24 hrs wth the channel ppl and under contract but this "jo jeet woh suiper star" where they r just coming to the studio andf singing and go back to home and do their other works like concerts or any thing so they get very less time to practice . 👏 👏



so guys think abt this and judge them and for gods sake dont compare their indian idol performance or saregampa performance becoz they wont get tht much time to practice as before becoz now they r professionals and they will be busy too so think abt the other side of the coin also.

👏 👏 this show roxxx

Rahul was honestly over hyped for that performance..it was good but nothing exceptional..

doesnt deserves 30. it was just OK performance.

Originally posted by: Niceup

doesnt deserves 30. it was just OK performance.

Totally agree!

I just watch HemaChandra's version and I think it was awesome !

Hemu's version was mindblowing..his version seemed so original..didnt seem lyk he was trying to copy sukhwinder's voice .. 😳 but the rest of singers who sang ramta jogi were gud too..but rahul's version certainly didnt deserve 30 marks IMHO