BW Movies which are difficult to understand?

Which BW movies were difficult to understand for you?

For me:

1. No-Smoking -- Couldn't make head or tail of it

2. Talaash - Couldn't fathom whether it was neo-noir, symbolic or ghost story

3. Rockstar to a certain extent -- Did the girl die at the end?

Roy.i could not understand what was happening in the movie.

I found Barfi also a bit confusing.

I agree with you.

Adding one from my side:

15 Park Avenue ( for those who haven't watched it, it has Konkona and Shabana ) and it too has open ended story. The movie is based on Schizophrenia and I took time to understand the end and still get confused. A good but disturbing movie.

Rockstar

Kank and Kalank it's not just the movies but the thought inside maker's head .banayi hi kyu ye movies

I thought I would be the only one who would say rockstar

Talaash...such a boring movie n dint understand the genre...

Not that the movie as such was hard to understand, but how a movie could be made with SUCH AN ANNOYING male lead i will never understand. Ae Dil Hai Mushkil.

I would slap Ranbir's character in the movie 500 times if I could. Fkn killed off Alizeh. Why?? They couldn't make him live the rest of his life without understanding that she doesn't love him and he's forcing himself on her? They had to kill her off?

The film production of Mein Prem Ki Dewaani Hoon is difficult for me to understand.

Bollywood - Y U DO DIS?

I thought Shabd was very interesting and open to many interpretations. Quite enjoyed it.

And with the way it was critically received, I am 100% sure very few people actually got it.

Paheli.