Mahabharat Retelecast Discussion Thread 6 - Page 115

Originally posted by: Armu4eva

Draupadi vilification and Karna whitewashing is the worst outcome of the popular MB adaptations.

To add to it Krishna saving Draupadi from Vastraharan

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

So you mean to say that someone who was capable till two Yugas after his birth, suddenly got aged after one Yuga? Yes Karna was 2 generation after Bheeshm n Drona but is it anywhere Mentioned that Karna was the only student of Parashuram at that time? Even if he was, as I said he went to Parashuram and not vice versa so this simply means that Parashuram was approachable for people back then, so why not in Kaliyuga?

If God intervened only when Adharma reaches peak, then the level of Adharma was much more during invaders reign than during the rules of Jarasangh, Shishupal or Duryodhan

And yes Krishna did intervene in the events, most of the war strategies were given by Krishna, Hanuman joined Arjun whenever he fought, he met Bheem n guided him, so why not do that in Kaliyuga? We all know that even if Kauravas has ruled, the Adharma wouldn't have been to the level as it was during the reign of the invaders, so why Krishna thought Dwapar as the time of Dharma ki haani and Hanuman took it onto himself to ensure Arjun's victory back then, but thought of ignoring in Kaliyug? And Hanuman helped him without being asked for help by Arjun

See it is impossible to disprove a thing, you can never disapprove if I say that there is a white crow or pink elephant in this universe, but we know that nothing suggests that there could be one.

So yes we can not prove that 7 immortals don't exist but nothing absolutely nothing suggests that they could

Hanuman never sat on arjun's rath , it's a myth . Vishwa karma created d illusion of him .

Parshuram is definitely not approachable 4 humans coz he said 2 reside in Mahendra parvat , I don't know by which name now Mahendra parvat is known .

In starbharat it was shown how much difficulty amba faced to reach parshuram ( I know it frictional ) but still he don't live in a place which is easily reachable by human.

Not only parshuram but hanuman 2 retired from his wordly duties

Acc 2 u what r duties of seven Chiranjeevis ? What u expect them to do ?

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

I am not blaming them of anything, rather proving that they aren't/weren't present. I am simply saying that anyone just anyone who is capable to save an innocent from brutal torture would go and save him/her, irrespective of whether or not it's their duty.

Any normal human would get traumatized by seeing the conditions and hearing the pleas and would try to help within their capacity

No one helped him because no one was capable to do so, but that isn't the case with Parashuram/Kripacharya, they were capable to help yet they didn't.

If he broke his oath for teaching Bheeshma, he could break it for common people in India too. Do you think they wouldn't have prayed to him/requested him?

If Parashuram was approachable by humans in Dwapar Yug, although even that wasn't his Yuga, why did he hide himself in Kaliyug?? At a time his guidance was needed the most. What couldn't he become approachable to at least guide people?

And each of these points are valid for Kripacharya as well

That they didn't do anything among these is a proof big enough that they aren't alive at all.

Aside in no way it's possible that Parashuram of Mahabharata was the same as Parashuram of Ramayana and the a Parashuram of Satyug who made Dharti Kshatriya viheen.

Many things in Mahabharatha are completely impossible.

Do you really think that Bheeshm's mother was a river? Is that possible anyway? Can a river take human form marry a king, have kids? And when she did so was the river completely dry? Because she would have been in Shantanu's palace right?

Do you really think that Takshak, Kalikeya etc. Nagas were snakes with multiple heads?

Do you really think, Sun who is like thousand times greater than earth came to Kunti to just impregnate her? Could Karna really be born with Kawatch Kundal? Forget other things, Kunti would have died during childbirth had the child coming out have metals surrounding him?

Anyhow if you really want to believe what is written in a poem/ poetic book over laws of physics and nature, over what/what can't happen then it's your belief, but that isn't possible at all, neither is there any proof of it.

You are right we must end this discussion there couldn't be one between belief n logic. Let's agree to disagree. Peace out

Sorry if I ever sounded rude

No u were not rude , u definitely have all d right to put ur pov .

Despite being present in duet sabha kripacharya was a mute spectator of draupadi's humiliation , what made u think he will do things now?

Kailash Mansarovar lake had a snake with 5 hoods.

Where did bheesam's mother go , if supposely died , then it would had been mentioned somewhere. Did she disappeared ?

Sun is considered god coz it is d most visible form of god , that's why it is worshipped .

Acc 2 hindu mythology all things have human form , which they take according 2 their will . Be it sun , moon, fire , wind etc.

We don't know how or what was karn's kavach Kundal thing .

If u think all these a lie , why u believe mahabharat happened , coz vedvyas wrote a poem using metafors, whole mahabharat is a big lie .

How did whole dwarka submerged in sea ? Thou ghandhari cursed krishna about it ? Why dint sea submerged dwarka when Krishna was residing in dwarka ? Who gave permit to sea to submerge dwarka once Krishna left d mortal world ?

Can u tell me how part of dronagiri Mountain reached srilanka? Dronagiri is part Himalayan range . It's known as Sanjeevani parvat in srilanka . Archeologist team searched about it , found it this mountain soil matches dronagiri Himalayas soil not Sri Lankan soil .

How do every year amarnath have shivling made of ice in cylindrical form ?

How can only shivling & Nandi idol got saved in kedarnath flood ? Who saved them ?

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

h

To add to it Krishna saving Draupadi from Vastraharan

I think this is THE biggest distortion.

But add the Kunti misspeak leading to polyandry as close 2nd when Arjuna knew going in what was supposed to happen.

I just noticed this thread🤣

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/mahabharat/5169037/introduction-to-vasundhara

Originally posted by: HearMeRoar

I just noticed this thread🤣

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/mahabharat/5169037/introduction-to-vasundhara

This is OS fan made story

Originally posted by: deepikagupta9

This is OS fan made story

I know it's not real. That person is writing in 1st person as though she is the character😆. Best friend, Karna. And I'm not sure why anyone would want to claim a sexual assaulter as best friend.

Originally posted by: HearMeRoar

I know it's not real. That person is writing in 1st person as though she is the character😆. Best friend, Karna. And I'm not sure why anyone would want to claim a sexual assaulter as best friend.

Sorry I misunderstood

Originally posted by: HearMeRoar

I just noticed this thread🤣

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/mahabharat/5169037/introduction-to-vasundhara

Is it?? I never knew about her

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

Is it?? I never knew about her

It's not a real character. Some Karna fan writing in 1st person as an imaginary sister