Manna Dey - Youth lack classical music

Youth lack knowledge of classical music: Manna Dey By PTI Mar 25, 2008, 08:03

Bangalore (PTI): The young generation of singers lack basic knowledge of Hindustani classical music, laments doyen of Hindi film music Manna Dey.

"Music is not totally out. While some have awareness and knowledge in general, it is lacking among the young singers of today," Dey said.

"There is no knowledge about 'swar' (notes), 'laya' (tempo) and 'tal' (rhythm) among young voices. For this it is necessary that they are guided and trained by good masters," the veteran said.

Dey said good film music is an amalgamation of lyrics and melody, adding "Obscene songs like 'Choli ke peeche kya hai' make a mockery of music itself".

Reflecting on Bollywood music scenario, the singing sensation of yesteryears said the fifties and sixties was the golden era of music while the early seventies had melodious music. The 1998-2008 period saw a lull, but some composers are now composing good music.

When asked which young voices he find good in the wake of changing trends in music industry, Dey showed all likes for Sonu Nigam, Shaan, Shreya Ghoshal and Sunidhi Chauhan.

The 89-year-old classical singer said he still practices for two hours daily. "I also believe in good health and being physically fit," he added.

"Music is not totally out. While some have awareness and knowledge in general, it is lacking among the young singers of today," Dey said.

Agreed but not fully. The ones who are finally making big in the music industry have a classical background. It's just that compositions are not being made which can show their talents.

Dey said good film music is an amalgamation of lyrics and melody, adding "Obscene songs like 'Choli ke peeche kya hai' make a mockery of music itself".

If old senior composers like Gulzar can make Bidi Jalayi Le why blame just the young ones!!!!

Originally posted by: Bhaskar.T

Agreed but not fully. The ones who are finally making big in the music industry have a classical background. It's just that compositions are not being made which can show their talents.



If old senior composers like Gulzar can make Bidi Jalayi Le why blame just the young ones!!!!

i think manna dey ji is correct in his assumption...by young singers he doesnt mean sonu or any one from his generation because they arent really that young....he means singers that have emerged in the last 5 years or so...and i think hes correct....most of them don't have classical training and if they have it is very limited....out of the many singers that debut each year...only a very limited few are trained in classical sangeet....

yes and i thenk to 😊