Vote: Which actor has the best acting talent among the lot? - Page 3

Originally posted by: Maroonporsche

Dharmenda is unarguably one of the finest actors Bollywood has seen.

Unfortunately, rather inexplicably, he never got his due. Neither in the media, nor by way of awards.

Tell me one actor who can boast of a repertoire like Anupama, Aayi Milan Ki Bela, Satyakam, Phool Aur Pathhar, Aankhen, Chupke Chupke, Sholay, Mera Gaon Mera Desh and Pratigya in his kitty?

Your also missing

Dilip Kumar

Rajesh Khanna

Shammi Kapoor

Naseerudin Shah

I have precisely included those names who are active in Bollywood including Big B. But those names whom you have mentioned have either demised or not currently active much in Bollywood.

Originally posted by: ffkhan

Oops, I would add the option of your fav had there been 11th option.😛 So sad there's only 10😭

No my dear

You have wrongly assumed this

Even if you have included sallu bhai

And even if I didn't disliked srk for his malicious persona, I would have the exact same stance

Mainly because he is a very weak superficial actor...

A lot more Weaker performer (with even serious issues of heavily hamming in most movies) than a majority in the list.

:)

---------------------

Originally posted by: tanya_91

Absolutely

Only roles that came naturally to him were those intense ones at start of his career...that's it....and it was some 25 years ago.

He cannot get into the skin of his characters and mainly injects the same learned superficial gimmicks in every performance...

No depth, no natural nuances, no layered acting outputs unlike a majority of REAL actors in the list.

Everything seems so superficial in a huge majority of his performances.

But I appreciate his fans loyalty for him, its kinda annoying yet sort of cute at the same time. 😃

--------------------------

Agreed. When I go through old videos of his I found him very likeable and focussed. Till date I feel he is one of the most well spoken and articulate celeb in the industry. I guess that's what education does to you. I also liked the fact how he wants his children to complete their education (even if its a degree in performing arts) before entering the industry. Also I had read an interview of his where he said that he regularly Skype calls his children to keep track of their studies. Thats one thing I admire about him.

But on the other hand, his arrogance puts me off. KKHH and then K3G gave him that superstardom and he was untouchable for the longest time. Well...success does go to people's heads.

Originally posted by: ffkhan

I have precisely included those names who are active in Bollywood including Big B. But those names whom you have mentioned have either demised or not currently active much in Bollywood.

is srk active ???

Lol..Ranveer Singh got more votes than Aamir..

Can we rank them in order?

Originally posted by: Maroonporsche

is srk active ???

He has taken a long break if I'm not wrong. The alive actors that you've mentioned are way more inactive compared to him and for a longer time as well.

Originally posted by: niyati13

Lol..Ranveer Singh got more votes than Aamir..

Can we rank them in order?

That's what I wanted to see whether favoritism wins in front of talent in this forum. Here it's impossible to get an accurate result when we compare so many actors altogether.😏 But I am glad to see that AB is winning the poll.

Originally posted by: ffkhan

That's what I wanted to see whether favoritism wins in front of talent in this forum. Here it's impossible to get an accurate result when we compare so many actors altogether.😏 But I am glad to see that AB is winning the poll.

I personally rank Ranveer, Ranbir and Shahid above Aamir....Simply because the other 3 have tried and succeeded in a variety of roles in their short careers which Aamir didn’t do in his 30 years of career...He is only been experimenting since the last 10 years!

EDIT ADD: Aamir has a knack of choosing the best scripts but that shouldn’t be confused with best acting...If you see his multi starers like RDB and 3Idiots, you see him being dominated by the likes of Sidharth, Madhavan etc....Even in Dangal, all the 4 girls stole the show with their acting....I will give it to him that he doesn’t stand out like a sore thumb with his bad acting !

So AB sr winning is accurate. But Ranveer getting 2% more votes than Aamir is not accurate in the same poll?? What kind of logic is that??

What about Srk getting same amount of votes as AB sr. He is also winning the poll. Is that accurate or biased like Ranveer's votes according to you?

Ranveer has given splendid performancea over the past years. So I see nothing wrong in him getting more votes than Aamir. Aamir is hella boring on-screen. Even his movies are not entertaining for me. So I definitely choose Ranveer over him with ease.

Originally posted by: ffkhan

That's what I wanted to see whether favoritism wins in front of talent in this forum. Here it's impossible to get an accurate result when we compare so many actors altogether.😏 But I am glad to see that AB is winning the poll.

For me Its AB Sr on a pedestal....

SRK/Aamir/Ajay

Ranbir/Hr

Rajkumar

Shahid

Ranveer

Anil

All of them are excellent actors...IMO..thoda unees bees ka fark hai...they all have the capability to out do each other....but not AB Sr...

@ Ashley Tisdale....why?? I thought of you as someone who doesn't indulge in unnecessary mudslinging...but may be I misjudged...koi baat nahi ...ho jaata hai..just a little surprised..😳