The Hero Study

This show. What's wrong with it? How can everything be so right but the makers keep destroying it in bits and pieces.

The way I have always praised Aman for always being a certain way.. they have completely butchered him if we go by the precap. What kinda man does that. Its not something a 'hero' does. There is no excuse for that. He throws his wife out for his sister's marriage on the insistence of sister's in laws? Like? How is this 'hero' like behaviour? Nomatter what, is this really digestible? There are certain things that tarnish a character beyond a limit and I can honestly say this is one of the things for me. His own wife? Really?

I really have to question Gul's regressive ass mindset for this. What's going on in there? If they have no further story to develop right now till Lal Chand ki Raat happens then give us fillers but seriously.. this? How many times he is going to kick her out? And how many times will she continue being an absolute doormat who comes back again and again in the guise of being Ayaana and saving the Nawab?

The fact that Roshni saved Chotu just now.. if the Precap is true...what kinda human being does it make Aman? It makes him so pathetic. I wanna go easy on bashing Aman because the show is literally him and Roshni but the way the CVS are butchering his character I don't even think am bashing the Aman I know and love - its like am talking of someone else.

Aman- is supposed to be a Nawab,is supposed to be educated,a classy intellectual hero who has a dark side which he hates. He said the most wonderful things and I loved how vulnerable and sensitive he was.

This one is not that Aman.

I don't know what's up with Gul and the CVS and whether Mrinal's new show is responsible for these dragged to death and character-butchering tracks BUT LET ME JUST SAY THIS : She is destroying the very reason I loved the show. Aman.

And Roshni.. here's the truth : nomatter what Roshni has done,anything at all..She does not deserve this treatment. She's like this commodity that the Khan family is using but there's no respect for her.

They only care for Ayaana saving their Aman and not Roshni. How can Aman kick her out like that..and the rest watch. What an ungrateful ass family. And Roshni wants to protect them? I say,Roshni needs protection from them! Except Chotu,nobody in that house is worth protecting.

I was one of those people who was ecstatic with Aman's reaction with losing Roshni in the chhal kua. I really thought it would be a turning point. But he's back to doing shit again. No conscience. No reflection. Why did it even happen lol? What was the point? That Roshni once again puts her life on the line for him and Aman once again dismisses it and treats her like shit.

Sigh. I should have known actual feminist,sensitive MLs cannot be a reality on ITV. Its the same old crap once again. I really thought YJHJK was doing it well. I was rooting for the show to be different but looks like Gul can't make a show that's not regressive. They had everything right in this show. There was no need for the ML to be this much of a pathetic person,for the FL to be this spineless( SHES SUPPOSED TO BE A WARRIOR PRINCESS). They could have told us a good story.

The concept that the ML will only care about the FL when she dies, and the ML will cry buckets of tears everytime he thinks he is losing her but feels no inkling to respect her when she's alive and breathing.. I find it hard to root for that kinda dynamic. Its very superficial. Its like the value of Roshni's life is nothing- just her Ayaana is worth saving and crying for.

Am gonna see how that Precap plays out, and if he's really shameless enough to throw her out like that..well. Am kinda done then. I don't find a ML like this appealing. And with the new entry coming up,if that man has to teach basic manners and how to respect your own wife to Aman, the latter was not much of a hero to begin with.

Sometimes precaps are misleading. Let's see the episode first

Can't agree more..but seems like it's just a build up to break this marriage and saima being in JM only. Precaps may be misleading but he did say this in front of everyone if rosh is the reason for breaking this marriage then she will not be my wife anymore and bring her outside the JM . It's humiliation only. He just can't treat rosh according to his will . You don't love her it's okay but atleast respect her as a human being . Somewhere I'm still expecting that it's part of his plan and all to expose aftab and Sameer . Because otherwise I'll be so disappointed with his characterization .Already I'm done with Parveen character. And frankly speaking the way story is going I'm not at all interested in any new entry .. Aman realizing his love for rosh out of jealousy and after her being on death bed is so 🤢. Mtlb rosh kuch Bhi krle pr jb tk Marne ki haalt mein nhi hogi he will not trust her and appreciate her presence in his life 🤷. Also it's not like I'm against jealousy tracks ,in some shows it works perfectly but definitely do not want it here.....neither adaa nor with new entry.

Originally posted by: purepunjabi

Can't agree more..but seems like it's just a build up to break this marriage and saima being in JM only. Precaps may be misleading but he did say this in front of everyone if rosh is the reason for breaking this marriage then she will not be my wife anymore and bring her outside the JM . It's humiliation only. He just can't treat rosh according to his will . You don't love her it's okay but atleast respect her as a human being . Somewhere I'm still expecting that it's part of his plan and all to expose aftab and Sameer . Because otherwise I'll be so disappointed with his characterization .Already I'm done with Parveen character. And frankly speaking the way story is going I'm not at all interested in any new entry .. Aman realizing his love for rosh out of jealousy and after her being on death bed is so 🤢. Mtlb rosh kuch Bhi krle pr jb tk Marne ki haalt mein nhi hogi he will not trust her and appreciate her presence in his life 🤷. Also it's not like I'm against jealousy tracks ,in some shows it works perfectly but definitely do not want it here.....neither adaa nor with new entry.

This. I was thinking this could redeem him a bit. But he would still humiliate Roshni. And this puts the 5 crore misunderstanding to a stop too which I don't think the CVS will let go off. Har misunderstanding ke upar they wanna spend a week. Jo bhi hain,his behavior after chhal kua is the same. Toh koi point tha kya uska?

About the new entry... Now I want the new entry to take Roshni away 😆 Duur le jao usse for her sanity. Nahi toh Yeh log will break her already broken spirit.

Are gul ko mat bolo wo writer kal hi aayi hai wapas

She will manage track

Thoda sa patience please as mrinal is writer

Wo character ki baja k character praise karti hai n villain ki norman waali dhullai

Please patience

Originally posted by: MagpieArshu

Are gul ko mat bolo wo writer kal hi aayi hai wapas

She will manage track

Thoda sa patience please as mrinal is writer

Wo character ki baja k character praise karti hai n villain ki norman waali dhullai

Please patience

I already know how Mrinal and Gul work. And they have presented regressive ass tracks before in many shows. I don't see the point of patience here like you say. Yeah,next episode main Aman could be the greatest man on the planet. But it still won't change how he's treating Roshni right now which is the point. Character toh kharab ho raha hain. Now if only he somehow knows the Sameer and video ka sach and this is his plan somehow,toh dekhte hain. Track Jo bhi ho, his treatment of Roshni should be criticised.

Originally posted by: AllThatCritique

I already know how Mrinal and Gul work. And they have presented regressive ass tracks before in many shows. I don't see the point of patience here like you say. Yeah,next episode main Aman could be the greatest man on the planet. But it still won't change how he's treating Roshni right now which is the point. Character toh kharab ho raha hain. Now if only he somehow knows the Sameer and video ka sach and this is his plan somehow,toh dekhte hain. Track Jo bhi ho, his treatment of Roshni should be criticised.

Extension k baad sab bakwaas hota hai

Gul k asya is my favourite n tanhaiyan webseries

My experience of mrinal - Wo Mujhe naagin 1 k 45 episodes naagin3 k 30 episodes bade achee lage from every angle and Nazar k bhi Mrinal ki writing me loopholes nai hote as supernatural elements I like

Nikita naamkaran writer wo bhi theek hai

Mukta is sadist

Well no doubt mrinal isn't there and jo bhi xyz writer track continue kiya bahut hi senseless hai And the way it has popped out no doubt image to ja hi rahi hai no doubt in that

Sb kucch chhodo,i really wnt to see roshni being independent and fulfilling her dream of bakery or whatever..i really wnt her to become independent and to stand up for herself instead of taking insult,tb lgega aman ko jhatka..but roshni being ayaana won't do this, farishte ka dil she has..Laal chand is approaching to after everything happened she'll go back i know bt for her self respect,she shouldn't give so much importance to aman now..

Originally posted by: MagpieArshu

Extension k baad sab bakwaas hota hai

Gul k asya is my favourite n tanhaiyan webseries

My experience of mrinal - Wo Mujhe naagin 1 k 45 episodes naagin3 k 30 episodes bade achee lage from every angle and Nazar k bhi Mrinal ki writing me loopholes nai hote as supernatural elements I like

Nikita naamkaran writer wo bhi theek hai

Mukta is sadist

Well no doubt mrinal isn't there and jo bhi xyz writer track continue kiya bahut hi senseless hai And the way it has popped out no doubt image to ja hi rahi hai no doubt in that

Wahi toh. Kuch boring si track bhi chalate toh bhi thik tha. Drama ke liye character ko kharap kyun karna. I want to recommend this show to people. Lekin aisa chalta raha toh kya karoon.

The concept that the ML will only care about the FL when she dies, and the ML will cry buckets of tears everytime he thinks he is losing her but feels no inkling to respect her when she's alive and breathing.. I find it hard to root for that kinda dynamic. Its very superficial. Its like the value of Roshni's life is nothing- just her Ayaana is worth saving and crying for.

👏👏👏👏👏

Couldn't have said it better. It was predictable that Aman butchering would be coming. Roshni didn't have much of a character scope to begin with anyway😆