HS-Mini: Pata nahin kaunse janam ki preet hai - Page 6

Originally posted by: AreYaar

You know the other touching thing? When she first told him she's leaving, he tried to cover up his own heartbreak by mentioning Babita first.....ki Babita nahin reh sakti Mini ke bina. He only got to his own emotions later.....when Mini said ki you guys will have your own kids soon and get busy in that....that's when he paused and said...."aur tu?....mhaari Veer Balika?".....his voice deepened into a different tenor in that bit.....really well done by AD.

Oh yes, for sure. He was talking about Babita but actually referring to his own feelings too, i.e. he would be broken, he loves her a lot.

I really like that moment when after telling her Babita loves her a lot, he paused to look at her and then asked her to turn toward him before beginning to tell her what she means to him The lines that followed were just... ❤️

Yes, I also love that a part of him was taken aback to think Minnie would consider herself outside their family sphere once Hanita's babies came into the picture. He corrected her perception immediately that she would always be his VB first.

AD's voice modulation, and also the way his voice broke during the phone call... The whole performance was phenomenal.

There is just so much in this scene to gif.....sigh

Originally posted by: AreYaar

There is just so much in this scene to gif.....sigh

Some of their scenes cannot be described in words, I don't know how the writers scripted them. Pretty sure Aniruddh and Ashnoor also added their own flavors in.

Originally posted by: inlieu

Some of their scenes cannot be described in words, I don't know how the writers scripted them. Pretty sure Aniruddh and Ashnoor also added their own flavors in.

This.

I have no doubt AD and Ashnoor play it instinctually and it comes out so beautifully but I must applaud the director also....he envisions the scenes beautifully and captures the expressions so well.

Another one of my fav. bits was the way he said, "Sun....idhar dekh, mhaari taraf?".....just the way he said that softly....you could tell he could sense something was off....and that is why despite her saying she's fine, he tried in his own way to give her the assurance about what she means to him....taaki mann mein koi malaal na rahe....

Originally posted by: AreYaar

These are just making me so emotional right now... But I love them!

Thanks for posting here.

Originally posted by: inlieu

These are just making me so emotional right now... But I love them!

Thanks for posting here.

Thank you....I hope to be able to gif the rest of the scene today, time willing.

Baaki toh aaj however their conversation goes, we will have these moments to remember

Originally posted by: AreYaar

Babita is fundamentally very self-absorbed and Mini has in a way spoilt her by constantly coddling her emotions.....this is why Babita started taking her for granted and expected her daughter to always fall in line with whatever she was feeling and wanting.....this is why she fears losing this to Ashok too. I must say, even as Babita realized that she went too far in anger, it was obvious that she feels she can easily puchkaaro Mini and manaao her.....she still doesn't realize that she has pushed her daughter too far now......some words you cannot come back from. And some lessons are learnt the very harsh way......isse pehle Babita ne jo bhi project tode, she never had to pay such a heavy price...the ultimate price....losing her own beloved daughter....which is why she didn't learn her lesson about not doing things in egotistical impulses.....but now she may once she loses Mini.

Today's scene again showed how emotionally stunted Babita is.......even if she realizes something is wrong, her first reaction is panic and then she tries to put on some bravado to cover the panic but you can actually sense her desperation underneath.....she struggles with deep set fears and when she realizes she's done something wrong, she can't cope with the possibility that it may be more damage than can be fixed. This is what I gathered from the bit when she was stuttering ki main Maa hoon, Mini meri bacchi hai, gudiya hai, main manaa lungi.....sad case hai. Babita in a sense is eternally trapped inside her mind.

Yes mini has spoilt her. I always saw this coming. you can coddle someone but not so much that the person dosent realise when things are going too far. Mini put too much of Babita in her life. put her too much above her and everyone else. It is ok to be selfless but its not a good idea to get absorbed with someone so much that nothing exists beyond that person. You sometimes need to take a stand for yourself and let the person know that he/she wont be allowed to treat you that way. That is why once things are breaking up with babita she wants to leave everyone and go away because she is not able to handle it. She cannot handle other relations and cannot stay or come back for them.

HS is also blamed for spoiling babita . As if mini wasnt enough, he saying that aaj se ghar me aap ki chalegi gave babita a new sense of dominance over everyone. The meek scared babita before divorce was much better than this empowered babita who has become regressive than before

Babita is very much emotionally stunted. Even when HS was explaining about his hurt related to his father yesterday she had a blank expression she never understood him. HS frustration was so apparent ki woh kisko samjhane ki koshish kar raha hai & ultimately blamed himself that he should have stepped up to understand minis needs.

Mini-wise....the FBs as she's angrily packing her suitcase shows how much she's fed up of both her parents now.....the adults got so caught up in their own drama and tug of war over Mini that ultimately it's gotten to her also.....I sensed a lot of anger and self-loathing in her in that moment.....the words ringing in her ear...."apne baap ki beti".....Ashok Khurana once told her she can never escape the reality of her blood bond with him.....and now her own mom saying it to her ripped open a whole new gash on Mini's psyche that will likely fester for years now.

True mini never wanted to be Ashoks beti. he was still biological father to her but she always felt ashamed for being his biological daughter. She has said this also few times. Babita used the very same thing to hurt her badly by saying that she is after all ashoks beti.

Maybe if mini HS would have wholeheartedly accepted each other as father daughter she could have taken more pride in being called HS daughter. It would have freed her of ashok one day. Todays scene showed that but HS never spoke up. If only he had said what was in his mind.

She's literally been in the same outfit since last Friday....lol even HS finally got to change in the precap....but she's still stuck in the same clothes.....maybe Monday's epi will bring a change of clothes as morning dawns for her leaving.

Originally posted by: naq5

True mini never wanted to be Ashoks beti. he was still biological father to her but she always felt ashamed for being his biological daughter. She has said this also few times. Babita used the very same thing to hurt her badly by saying that she is after all ashoks beti.

Maybe if mini HS would have wholeheartedly accepted each other as father daughter she could have taken more pride in being called HS daughter. It would have freed her of ashok one day. Todays scene showed that but HS never spoke up. If only he had said what was in his mind.

Mini definitely doesn't want to be Ashok's beti.....today's scene made it abundantly clear that she wanted to be HS ki beti.....but for whatever reason that I guess the writers won't bother to clarify in the last stretch....lol....HS couldn't accept her as his own.

Seemed like a case of lack of courage, especially on HS's side....he made the presumption that he's lost her trust for good so he isn't even going to bother trying anymore and on Mini's side, it seems to be a case of immense disappointment in him.....so they left it at a stalemate.

What I didn't get is why the dialogues tried to spin it as HS not being able to accept Mini as his apni beti....what did he mean by kaash tu meri apni beti hoti? And even later on, they showed NB saying what if it was your own daughter in the boat with Babita....who would you save then? So even NB is convinced that he never considered Mini his own daughter cuz she isn't his blood? lol

Ek taraf she is his Veer Balika, he calls her beti etc.....dusri taraf there is still a gap of "Meri apni beti"?

They totally insinuated in that NB scene that HS would always choose Babita over Mini cuz she is his wife and responsibility while he has no direct relationship with Mini so he wouldn't choose her......after a couple of epis of good scenes, it was again back to the mute version of HS who just sits around listless, silent, and helpless.

Oh well....I kinda had a feeling they would leave it vague in the last stretch....which is why I'm happy with what we got on Wednesday.....muqammal na hoke bhi muqammal ho gaya us din HS-Mini ka rishta.