SBD - AJ save Alisha instead of Guddan ! Poision kaand ! - Page 2

Originally posted by: Meenakshi-rg

Komal we cant even apply any logic here . If we do , it takes time for a parent to form a bond when a child drops in after 16 years . No matter what anyone says , I dont believe the bond can come in a day .

And second point ,yes knowing the fact that the person is your own child will give an edge to the child and any parent would do that . But the ideal case there would be when they are both real parents .

Here no matter what AJ does he will be wrong as it is not mother vs daughter its his young 22 yr old wife vs his daughter .

WHat about guddan his wife ??/Eh seems to forget she is a young vulnerable girl too ,

After sleeping with antara he was ready to let go guddan ,For sister bond he was ready to let go guddan ......... Now it will happen for daughter !!!!! It goes on !!!

WHat I mean is the only solution AJ has is letting go guddan !!!! That is taking away the aura !!! He was shown so resourseful when he would sort out complex issues with his intelligence and power !!!

I know here with poison and daughter , its an no win situation for him and I blame the writers !!!!

Anyway its all so bizzarre , dont even want to think much . Always it has to be life threatening blackmail . Life and death matters taken so lightly !!!!

bond or not Guddan or Aj would save a child first no matter what, blood or not blood, bond or no bond. That's just who they are. I don't believe it takes away anything or takes away his aura, its just what they would do. Guddan in reverse will save others first before AJ (as she has before, granted its been family members but she would make the same choice as AJ). Doesn't really bother me.

Originally posted by: Meenakshi-rg

Komal we cant even apply any logic here . If we do , it takes time for a parent to form a bond when a child drops in after 16 years . No matter what anyone says , I dont believe the bond can come in a day .

And second point ,yes knowing the fact that the person is your own child will give an edge to the child and any parent would do that . But the ideal case there would be when they are both real parents .

Here no matter what AJ does he will be wrong as it is not mother vs daughter its his young 22 yr old wife vs his daughter .

WHat about guddan his wife ??/Eh seems to forget she is a young vulnerable girl too ,

After sleeping with antara he was ready to let go guddan ,For sister bond he was ready to let go guddan ......... Now it will happen for daughter !!!!! It goes on !!!

WHat I mean is the only solution AJ has is letting go guddan !!!! That is taking away the aura !!! He was shown so resourseful when he would sort out complex issues with his intelligence and power !!!

I know here with poison and daughter , its an no win situation for him and I blame the writers !!!!

Anyway its all so bizzarre , dont even want to think much . Always it has to be life threatening blackmail . Life and death matters taken so lightly !!!!

I agree you said it all dear I am tired now and the saga continues ...of AJ choosing other over Guddan ...

Originally posted by: kshah1987

bond or not Guddan or Aj would save a child first no matter what, blood or not blood, bond or no bond. That's just who they are. I don't believe it takes away anything or takes away his aura, its just what they would do. Guddan in reverse will save others first before AJ (as she has before, granted its been family members but she would make the same choice as AJ). Doesn't really bother me.

Doesn't bother me too .!!!! And its not about saving komal . saving lives is a separate issue . that they take so lightly is what I am pointing out .

Aura for me has been damaged by his choices in this entire track .Antara , revti !!!! All tracks cld have had a more sterner AJ !!!!

Again I may be diverting from the issue !!!

Saving lives you made the right point , they wld both save the other person first !!!! And it may not be a daughter !!!

Originally posted by: kshah1987

bond or not Guddan or Aj would save a child first no matter what, blood or not blood, bond or no bond. That's just who they are. I don't believe it takes away anything or takes away his aura, its just what they would do. Guddan in reverse will save others first before AJ (as she has before, granted its been family members but she would make the same choice as AJ). Doesn't really bother me.

And when I said the same will happen in daughter track , I meant later he will let go guddan .

Not about this poison thing .

In poison case no matter whom he chosses , he will be not right !!!!!My POV

Originally posted by: mahakh

Ria I feel you are just taking the show too seriously, I support you a lot and I understand your concerns so much, I have bene like you, well I still am sometimes, I overthink so much like no one else does , but now I am realizing that, I wasted so much of my life overstressing whereas I could have spent that on important things

Please wait for the episode atleast and then you can watch

I am sure AJ will find a way to sav both Guddan and Alisha, he will somehow save both of them, let's see how will he do it, AJ can do anything in the show , enjoy your weekend , it is Friday

I am also like you who takes everything seriously, even a show, but not anymore, I won't take things seriously anymore, I have lost so much in my life because of it, I won't overstress, you also don't

exactly, well said. I have no interest in dissecting logic on itv shows or take anything that seriously on this one. It's way too stressful 😆 So ....if the scenes are nice then i'll tune in and if it goes south, then can easily quit. But so far, i'm generally fine with this track.

Originally posted by: Meenakshi-rg

Doesn't bother me too .!!!! And its not about saving komal . saving lives is a separate issue . that they take so lightly is what I am pointing out .

Aura for me has been damaged by his choices in this entire track .Antara , revti !!!! All tracks cld have had a more sterner AJ !!!!

Again I may be diverting from the issue !!!

Saving lives you made the right point , they wld both save the other person first !!!! And it may not be a daughter !!!

AJ's made some poor choices during the antara track, that i agree with. But he more than made up for it in my view and his actions during revti track, I understood completely. Sterner AJ was there only when there was no one to care about, that whole phase from early days on Guddan unitl he fell in love with Guddan, was never the real AJ. Some elements, yes but that ruthless persona was only a facade.

Originally posted by: kshah1987

exactly, well said. I have no interest in dissecting logic on itv shows or take anything that seriously on this one. It's way too stressful 😆 So ....if the scenes are nice then i'll tune in and if it goes south, then can easily quit. But so far, i'm generally fine with this track.

You have the right approach komal . I dont get as attached as ria does , but I do fall in love with characters and their behavior does affect me in a certain way at least for a while !!!!! But it doesnt last luckily !!!!

Originally posted by: Meenakshi-rg

And when I said the same will happen in daughter track , I meant later he will let go guddan .

Not about this poison thing .

In poison case no matter whom he chosses , he will be not right !!!!!My POV

he might let go of her but again, this is his blood and his child. I can't blame him for that at all. It's a horrible situation but ultimately he should let go of Guddan and i'd expect the same from Guddan if she was in his situation.

Originally posted by: mahakh

Ria I feel you are just taking the show too seriously, I support you a lot and I understand your concerns so much, I have bene like you, well I still am sometimes, I overthink so much like no one else does , but now I am realizing that, I wasted so much of my life overstressing whereas I could have spent that on important things

Please wait for the episode atleast and then you can watch

I am sure AJ will find a way to sav both Guddan and Alisha, he will somehow save both of them, let's see how will he do it, AJ can do anything in the show , enjoy your weekend , it is Friday

I am also like you who takes everything seriously, even a show, but not anymore, I won't take things seriously anymore, I have lost so much in my life because of it, I won't overstress, you also don't

Originally posted by: kshah1987

he might let go of her but again, this is his blood and his child. I can't blame him for that at all. It's a horrible situation but ultimately he should let go of Guddan and i'd expect the same from Guddan if she was in his situation.

Okay lets argue this out . I agree he should do that . And what if after few episodes its proven that the child is not his ????? SO In my opinion he should be strong enough and also authoritative enough to keep both of them .. He should work towards that rather than just letting go . That is what I dont like . He just gives up . Let guddan go .

Guddan doesnot do that . She tries to find solution where all relations can be maintained .