FAMEGURUKUL VS SAREGAMA - Page 4

Originally posted by: aditigill

guys 90% of the singers in FG wont be allowed or even qualify as audience in SAREGAMAPA and the only one closest to go to sing on stage is Arijit. Arpita had her sting but its history, the kind of singers SAREGAMAPA has FG cant even think abt in its dream. FG is -100/10 if SAREGAMAPA is 10/10

I saw several of these SRGMP singers in the audition of II1(they r showing the rerun now in US).Iremember keka being there.How come if they r so great they did'nt make to the top 10 in II1.

And there were some of them in FG audition as well.I think Debujeet was there.I don't know the names of some others that i saw

Originally posted by: mans76us

😊 😊 😊 yepp...Dharmesh hope nobody counts here how many times ur sur gir gaya or we will be in trouble👏

yupe, will keep that in mind myself... and even if i do that won't tell it to anyone..oops.. sorry..😆

Originally posted by: aditigill

That was the best way to judge i felt, u have scientific way to judge. clarity and no bias, come on in FG when we felt someone sang good, someone else was in safe zone, but there, we were clear how many errors, how many times she missed in sur and all...

yupe i kinda agree to that, even though it is subjective, they can mark it on the sur's but dunno if daler has/had any idea of the surs or the other judge took care of that part of grading😆

Originally posted by: aditigill

That was the best way to judge i felt, u have scientific way to judge. clarity and no bias, come on in FG when we felt someone sang good, someone else was in safe zone, but there, we were clear how many errors, how many times she missed in sur and all...

U can't use a scientific way to judge music.There is no right way but then there is no wrong way either.music is subjective.

Originally posted by: ani11

I saw several of these SRGMP singers in the audition of II1(they r showing the rerun now in US).Iremember keka being there.How come if they r so great they did'nt make to the top 10 in II1.

And there were some of them in FG audition as well.I think Debujeet was there.I don't know the names of some others that i saw

i think all these contestants are mostly strugglers and want to go to all of them to grab any chance they can. abt the inclusion/exclusion in some show or the other, i guess that all depends on what the show organizers want (not what they r looking for) from the contestants (drama, singing, dancing, looks etc.) and how the contestants perform during audition to fit in those criteria's...

also they might deliberately bring in some weak links or funny beings for more variety to the show (and not to forget diversity) as u can see we have contestants from all regions of the country and all major religions as well.

aditi... but still Daler Paji's method had flaws. It makes sense if all contestants are singing same song I mean if someone is singing simple song his sur may not drop ( drop may not be right word) as many times as someone is singing complex song ..

Originally posted by: mans76us

aditi... but still Daler Paji's method had flaws. It makes sense if all contestants are singing same song I mean if someone is singing simple song his sur may not drop ( drop may not be right word) as many times as someone is singing complex song ..

u r right😃